link
To ask the Scottish Government what action it is taking to ensure that communities hosting energy infrastructure receive direct benefits from it. (S7O-00192)
Official Report · Chamber
Portfolio Question Time
This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.
link
To ask the Scottish Government what action it is taking to ensure that communities hosting energy infrastructure receive direct benefits from it. (S7O-00192)
link
[Inaudible.]
link
Your microphone is not on. Is your card in, Mr Gethins?
For the future, if any member forgets their card when coming to the chamber, they can always get a replacement from the front desk.
link
Thank you, Deputy Presiding Officer. It should be working now.
I ask Jenni Minto for her forgiveness and I thank her for raising the issue, because it is important to her and her constituents. Communities that host infrastructure should see some benefits. She will be aware of my recent comments when the United Kingdom Government announced upgrades to lines but the community did not see as much benefit as it might have expected.
The Scottish Government has some limited powers and we are taking action by refreshing our good practice principles for community benefits from onshore renewables developments. The guidance will reflect the renewable energy sector’s evolution, ensuring that host communities receive sustainable, meaningful outcomes from renewables developments.
link
Renewable energy is a key part of our journey to net zero and Scotland already produces huge amounts of renewable power, with the potential to create much more. However, too often, communities such as those across Argyll and Bute host the required infrastructure without feeling the benefits, while continuing to pay some of the highest energy bills in the UK.
Does the minister agree that all energy powers should be devolved to Scotland so that we can ensure that Scotland’s energy production has greater benefits for the people of Scotland?
link
Jenni Minto is right to raise that, and people in Argyll and Bute will be particularly concerned. I agree, and—despite what others might think—the majority of parliamentarians in this Parliament agree, that full control over energy policy should sit in this Parliament, where the benefits of Scotland’s energy wealth can be achieved. They cannot be achieved within the current devolution settlement.
Jenni Minto has rightly raised the fact that Scotland is energy rich yet our bills remain among the highest in Europe, despite the promises from the Labour Government. The Scottish Government wrote to the UK Government to formally request that those powers be devolved, on the basis of a vote in this Parliament, so that we can take decisive action in areas such as reducing bills, tackling fuel poverty and making sure that we feel the benefit of Scotland’s vast energy wealth, but we have still not had a response.
link
Communities hosting the Kintore to Tealing energy infrastructure in Aberdeenshire report that it will reduce the value of their properties by up to 40 per cent. They have heard absolutely nothing from the Scottish Government about what benefit they will get out of it. What action is the Government taking to get them direct benefit from hosting that infrastructure, or are they right that the Government has abandoned them?
link
Mr Kerr will be aware that I cannot comment on certain applications for consent. He will also know that those grid upgrades were a matter for the UK Government in terms of the money off bills and that, further north, in his region of North East Scotland, that was—as I have already commented—insufficient.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.