I thank Katy Clark for bringing this debate to the chamber, especially given the recent events that have been mentioned, which have so badly affected families and businesses, not only in my own region but across the whole of Scotland.
I pay tribute to the personnel of the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service who risk their lives and dedicate their expertise to our nation’s emergency response capacity, and in particular to the firefighter who tragically lost his life fighting the fire at the Jenners fire in Edinburgh in 2023.
As I rise to make my speech, I am reminded of when I was a young officer in the Royal Navy visiting a Vanguard-class submarine: a vessel that makes an irreplaceable contribution to our strategic nuclear deterrent. During that visit, one of my fellow guests asked: “We spend billions of pounds on the construction and maintenance of these weapons, but they are, thankfully, never used. Could that money not be better spent elsewhere? What are they supposed to do, other than sitting there doing nothing?” The captain replied: “What they are supposed to do is exactly what they are doing right now: doing nothing.”
I know that an increased number of fire stations or equipment will not, in and of themselves, deter or prevent a fire from starting and spreading. However, it is a question of capacity to deal with the ultimate emergency, should it ever happen. As we have heard, it is indisputable that, over a 10-year period from 2012, personnel numbers decreased by 15 per cent. However, have we seen a corresponding decrease in the risk of fire emergencies?
Globally, instances of wildfires have decreased to record lows, sitting at around 50 per cent of the levels seen in the year 2000. Regionally, however, in our area of operations, we have seen a steady increase in the instances of wildfires. And yet, in the face of this, in the Highlands, we have seen station closures formalised at Nethy Bridge, Ratagan and Isle of Muck, and at Fetlar in Shetland.
I do not presume to know the Government’s position, but I predict that mitigation will be furnished in the form of increased efficiencies, wider safety awareness initiatives and the centralisation of services. However, in remote and rural areas, 100 miles is still 100 miles, and that cannot be overcome by efficiencies, especially in the face of ongoing transport problems and trunk road upgrades, and when a team reaches an area, a fire engine cannot be in two places at once if there is another incident.
As Ben Macpherson and Rachael Hamilton touched on, there are wider risks that relate to battery storage sites, proposed artificial intelligence hyperscale data centres and the fact that the review did not seem to take into account ongoing and future increases in regional infrastructure, such as major leisure resorts and residential developments, which will increase local demand.
I am offering members a short summary of the increased burden and risk of potential fires. Under this Government, there is not only a staffing and infrastructure level that does not increase correspondingly with the risk, but a centralisation of capacity away from remote areas, which is compounding more than a decade of previous cuts. The safety of the Scottish people should never be at the mercy of budgeting pressures, and I urge a rethink and a new plan that ensures that communities across not only the Highlands and Islands but the whole of Scotland are safe and have a well-resourced, well-staffed fire and rescue service that is fit for the 21st century.
18:36