I thank Stephen Kerr for the intervention. He is absolutely right that we could do with a United Kingdom strategy, but the Scottish Government is in charge of planning here, so we need a Scottish strategy.
The energy demand shows why guidance is urgent. Current Scottish applications would require an estimated 7,300MW of electricity. To put that into context, Scotland’s peak winter electricity demand is just over 4,000MW, so, on paper, the proposals could demand significantly more power than Scotland uses at peak winter demand. That should worry everyone.
On 18 August, the Minister for Public Finance announced that councils must notify the Scottish Government within seven days of receiving an application for a data centre of over 50MW. The Government should be told about plans, but then what? Nobody knows. The central questions remain unanswered: what is a green data centre? What limits apply to diesel or gas back-up generation? What air quality standards can residents rely on?
We also need to know how many of these things Scotland needs, and where they should go. The minister has had all summer to do that thinking, but we have yet to hear the conclusions. Today may be the day that we find out, but I suspect that it will not be.
Data centres are now part of the essential infrastructure of our modern economy. Some data centres already operate here, and in some areas people would barely know they are there. They support cloud computing, online banking, digital public services, cybersecurity, business productivity and, increasingly, artificial intelligence, so we should not simply say no to them. We should welcome investment, innovation and jobs but, equally, we should not wave vast projects through based on marketing slogans, speculative promises and undefined claims of being green.
There is a positive case for investment. Scotland has renewable energy potential, engineering expertise, former industrial land that needs regeneration and a workforce capable of supporting high-value digital jobs, but recognising those benefits does not mean writing a blank cheque. Communities in Ravenscraig, Larbert, Newhouse, West Calder and Chapelhall are entitled to straight answers and protection.
Twelve of the sites in the planning system are on green-belt sites or farmland, including at least two on grade 2 farmland, which is the best that Scotland has. The two brownfield sites are allocated for 1,400 homes. None of the sites in the planning system appears on the priority list drawn up by Government bodies in 2021 and updated in 2023.
Then we have energy and emissions. Data centres need back-up generation and the proposals that we have seen so far in Scotland would use diesel generators. Done well, operators could use renewable power, invest in storage, improve grid connections, recycle waste heat, meet high efficiency standards and deliver local benefits that could support growth and decarbonisation.
That is why I am not arguing for blanket opposition; I am arguing for proper rules, but right now those rules are not clear enough. National planning framework 4 talks about green data centres, but it does not define the term. The guidance should be practical and clear, and it should define what qualifies as a green data centre and set limits on diesel and gas back-up generation.
Transparency matters, too. APRS says that nine of the 16 proposals that reached environmental impact assessment screening were initially not required to carry out those assessments, though three decisions were later overturned by ministers.
Presiding Officer, I have taken some interventions, I am a wee bit over time, and I might have to leave early, so I will finish here. I am calling on the Scottish Government to issue urgent guidance now so that communities, councils and developers know what standards apply before decisions are made. I am really looking forward to hearing the other contributions.
17:29