I am grateful for the opportunity to bring this issue to Parliament because, although responsibility for driving tests rests with the United Kingdom Government, the consequences of the current system are being felt by people and communities across Scotland.
I am also grateful to all those members who signed the motion. I understand that, for the first time during my time in Parliament, in almost 20 years, a members’ business debate nearly did not happen because a member who had signed the motion withdrew their name from it. Members from two parties are required to sign a motion for debate, and a member from the Reform UK party withdrew her name this afternoon, which put the debate in jeopardy. I do not know whether that was a mistake, or if she had not previously read the motion and did not like it in some way, or was trying to spike the debate. Nonetheless, it was very unfortunate, and I see that there is not a single member of Reform in the chamber tonight.
I know from the correspondence that I have received that the problem of driving test delays is not theoretical—it is affecting people’s ability to work and to study and, in particular in rural communities, simply to get on with their lives. I first became aware of the scale of the problem through constituents contacting me about their experiences of trying to book a practical driving test. One constituent described logging on before 6 o’clock in the morning, only to find himself behind tens of thousands of other people in the queue. The reason for that is that people do not join a local queue for a test in Stirling or Scotland—they join behind everyone in the UK. Other constituents have described waiting for hours to access the booking system only to find no suitable tests available, or experiencing technical problems and losing their place altogether.
For people who work or attend college, or who have caring responsibilities, sitting online for hours in the hope that an appointment might appear is simply not realistic. There is also a significant financial consequence. Learner drivers are paying for additional lessons while they wait, and some are seeing their theory test certificates move closer and closer to the expiry date while they are unable to secure a practical test.
That is why I wrote to the UK Government earlier this month, setting out the experiences that my constituents had brought to me and asking what action was being taken. I have now received a response from the Minister for Roads, Justin Madders MP. I welcome the fact that the minister acknowledges the “frustration” being experienced by learner drivers and, importantly, that he recognises the particular impact on
“young people in rural areas, where access to work, education and social activities”
can
“depend on having a driving licence.”
However, the minister assures me that action is being taken. He says:
“Scotland is included in the Driving and Vehicle Standards Agency’s … programme to increase … test capacity”,
including through recruiting and training new examiners,
“encouraging qualified staff to return to examining roles, expanding training capacity and offering overtime incentives.”
He tells me that waiting times have now fallen “to under 21 weeks” and that
“Testing capacity is … at its strongest level in more than a year”,
with appointment availability at
“its highest level since … 2024.”
I really hope that that is the beginning of a genuine improvement, but there is a problem: it is simply not the experience that is being reported to me by people on the ground. People are contacting my office not to complain that they have been given a test in 24 weeks’ time rather than 20 weeks, but because they cannot get a test at all. We need to distinguish between two different things: waiting times and availability. An average waiting-time statistic is of little comfort to the learner who logs on to the booking system and cannot find an appointment anywhere reasonably accessible to them. If there is no test available to book, the theoretical waiting time is almost irrelevant.
I would like to know, therefore, what the national improvements that the UK minister describes actually mean for people in Clackmannanshire and Stirling and across Scotland. How many additional tests have been made available locally? How many additional examiners have been recruited or deployed here? How has capacity changed at individual test centres? Most important, when should learners in our communities expect to be able to log on and find tests that they can actually book?
The minister’s letter says that resources are being deployed
“to areas of highest demand”
and that
“workforce planning and demand forecasting are being strengthened”.
If that is happening, we need to see the evidence of it locally.
There is also the question of changes to the booking system. I absolutely understand why action had to be taken against the manipulation and resale of driving tests; nobody should be able to profiteer from a shortage of appointments. The UK Government says that
“reforms have significantly reduced … manipulation and reseller activity”
and that the Driver and Vehicle Standards Agency has carried out
“more than 6,000 enforcement interventions since”
the changes were introduced.
That is welcome. However, we need to ask whether measures that were designed to stop abuse have inadvertently made the system less flexible for genuine learners and legitimate driving instructors. Tackling the resale of appointments should not make an already difficult system even harder for the people whom it is supposed to serve.
There is another group for whom the delays create a particularly acute problem. One constituent who contacted me had moved to Scotland from the United States to work with the Church of Scotland. As a US licence holder, they have a limited period, following arrival in this country, during which they can drive using that licence. However, before they can even book a practical test, they must first meet the residency requirements for taking the theory test. That significantly reduces the window that is available for them to complete the whole process. A practical test wait of many months—assuming that they can secure an appointment at all—means that what should be a straightforward process becomes extraordinarily difficult.
That illustrates why the matter goes well beyond inconvenience. For some people, having a driving licence is fundamental to their ability to work. For young people in rural communities, it can determine whether a particular job, apprenticeship or college course is realistically accessible.
There is an inequality here, too. Somebody with the financial means to continue paying for lessons for months while waiting for a test is in a very different position from a young person or family already struggling with the cost of living. I therefore also ask the UK Government to consider what can be done for people whose theory certificate has expired because they have simply been unable to access a practical test. People should not have to pay again and repeat a test that they have already passed because the state has been unable to provide the next stage of the process within a reasonable period.