To ask the Scottish Government whether, when briefed by officials on the full business case for the Monklands replacement project in March 2026, the then Minister for Public Health considered the £2.1 billion proposal to be at risk of rejection. (S7O-00165)
Angela ConstanceSNPThe Cabinet Secretary for Health and Care · Almond Valley
I reiterate that the case for the new hospital is well made and has not been rejected. Indeed, I visited the new site during summer recess and reiterated that a new Monklands hospital will be built at Wester Moffat. Work is already progressing with NHS Lanarkshire on refreshed design plans.
As I am sure the member will note from recent freedom of information returns, the Government had not fully completed the assurance of the full business case prior to the dissolution of Parliament. Advice to the minister in March noted that point and made it clear that further advice would follow, after those processes were complete. The business case was sent to the health and social care management board on 25 March 2026. Thereafter, we entered the pre-election period. On the formation of the new Government and following further advice, I assessed the business case and made the decision to pause and instruct the redesign to ensure value for money for the public purse.
NHS Lanarkshire submitted its £2.1 billion full business case in December 2025, but ministers did not announce the decision to reset the project until seven weeks after the election. The Government presented Monklands as a major capital project during the election only to send it back to the drawing board after votes had been counted. Why were the people of Lanarkshire not told before the election if there were serious affordability concerns? When did ministers first know that plans were going back to the drawing board?
Substantial information on the matter has, of course, been put in the public domain, and I made an important statement to the Parliament before recess.
It has always been the case that projects of such scale take time to consider fully and to take through the appropriate internal governance and assurance processes, as the public would expect when such significant amounts of public money are involved. In March, the project was still going through various internal assessments and the business case was not ready to proceed for decision before the Scottish Government entered the pre-election period.
For the record, I am 100 per cent focused on the delivery of this much-needed new hospital. I note that the Scottish National Party was the only party to have a commitment to the University hospital Monklands in its manifesto.
I wrote to the new Cabinet Secretary for Justice on 7 August on the back of the recent investigation by the Scottish Mail on Sunday, which reported that the Scottish Government was warned by national health service officials about several significant issues relating to the replacement Monklands hospital. That happened in March. Did the former health secretary know about NHS Scotland Assure’s concerns back in March while he was out campaigning for a new Monklands hospital in his Airdrie seat? Why is the former Cabinet Secretary for Justice and Home Affairs letting the former Cabinet Secretary for Health and Social Care off the hook?
I remind Ms Gallacher that Neil Gray was recused from decisions in relation to the replacement hospital. I also remind her, with respect, that I made the decision to call a halt and ask for the redesign on the basis of affordability, as the cost to the public purse would have been in excess of £2 billion. Nonetheless, I am 100 per cent committed to delivering a new hospital for Lanarkshire on the Wester Moffat site with core services, including accident and emergency.
If Ms Gallacher has further questions, I would be more than happy to meet or correspond with her.
Those of us who smelled a rat during the election campaign were right. The people of Lanarkshire were hoodwinked over Monklands. Given what we now know, how can they have any confidence that the SNP Government will build a new hospital? When will it be built and what is the budget?
I look forward to Mr Simpson attending the opening of the new hospital in Lanarkshire. As I have said on a number of occasions, I will bust a gut to ensure that plans for the redesign are before me by next year. The indicative plan is to commence building in 2028.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.