To ask the Scottish Government whether the publication of the draft curriculum improvement cycle, which introduces new concepts, big ideas and a know-do-understand framework, reflects an assessment that the existing skills-focused approach within curriculum for excellence has not achieved its intended outcomes for pupils. (S7O-00136)
Màiri McAllanSNPThe Cabinet Secretary for Education, Culture and Gaelic · Clydesdale
In 2021, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development endorsed curriculum for excellence as the right approach for Scotland, while noting that it would benefit from a systematic approach to curriculum review, which is exactly what we are undertaking, seeking to clarify the position of knowledge and create clearer progression between the broad general education and the senior phase.
The curriculum improvement cycle represents the most significant reform to our curriculum in a decade. It will ensure that learners can continue to achieve positive destinations in record numbers and the strong vocational and academic excellence that was shown in this year’s exam results.
At this time, teachers are delivering results through a knowledge-based senior phase that contradicts the existing curriculum for excellence skills-based focus. The curriculum improvement cycle adds yet another layer to the Government’s Jenga education system, and the non-contact focus in the Scottish National Party manifesto admits that workload is already too high. Is it not the truth that teachers are expected to hold the system up while the Government keeps piling on the weight?
I disagree with that characterisation. As I mentioned in my initial answer, what we are doing is part of a recommendation from the OECD, which endorsed curriculum for excellence but was clear that systematic periodic review would benefit the system. As I said, that is exactly what we are undertaking just now.
Angela Ross is right to mention teacher workload, which is always an ongoing concern for the Government. However, the work of the curriculum improvement cycle in clarifying the roles of knowledge and progression through the curriculum will, I hope, aid teachers in relation to their workload, as will our work on reducing class contact time, which we continue to take forward with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities.
The cabinet secretary will be aware that thousands of pupils across Scotland received their exam results last month. What is her assessment of how pupils have handled this year and how curriculum for excellence has supported that?
There is much to celebrate in this year’s exam results, which were released over the summer. Pass rates at national 5 and higher improved on last year, which had itself involved increases, and are above the pre-pandemic levels of 2019, and the advanced higher pass rate also increased, demonstrating academic excellence. Alongside that, there was a further surge in young people gaining qualifications in vocational subjects—great subjects such as journalism, personal finance, childcare and construction. That demonstrates the breadth and strength of Scotland’s education system. Those results having been released over the summer, I take the opportunity to thank the teaching workforce, supportive parents and carers, and the young people who did us very proud.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.