To ask the Scottish Government what its response is to reported comments by the Fire Brigades Union that years of real-terms budget reductions have left the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service “creaking”, and that proposed workforce reductions would increase the risk to community safety, particularly following the recent fire in Glasgow. (S6T-02973)
Official Report · Chamber
Scottish Fire and Rescue Service (Budget)
Topical Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Siobhian Brown SNP 6
- Sharon Dowey Con 3
- Pauline McNeill Lab 1
- Maggie Chapman Green 1
- Foysol Choudhury Ind 1
The record
12 contributions
link
I echo the First Minister’s recognition of the service’s response to the Union corner fire. We recognise the vital role that the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service plays in keeping our community safe, and we remain committed to sustaining that capability.
The 2026-27 budget provides an additional £23.8 million to the SFRS, taking our total funding of it to £436 million, which demonstrates our continued support for the SFRS so that it can deliver the high-standard services that are required to keep Scotland safe.
We are aware of the concerns that the Fire Brigades Union has raised about long-term pressures that the service is facing, and our focus has always been on community safety and protecting front-line services. The SFRS’s evidence-based service delivery review will align resources to modern risks and demands, ensuring that resources are directed where they are needed, and we will continue to discuss its further funding requirements.
The devastating fire on Union Street in Glasgow once again demonstrated the extraordinary professionalism and bravery of Scotland’s firefighters. However, we have heard deeply concerning warnings from the FBU that years of real-term budget cuts have left the fire service “creaking”. There have been 1,250 firefighter posts cut since the creation of the national fire service. Ten high-lift appliances have been cut. The service has an ageing fleet, with only one new fire engine coming into service in the past two years. Fire stations have closed, 18 stations are without running water, and the list goes on.
It is noticeable that the fire service review has been kicked into the long grass until after the May elections. Given all those cuts, how can the public have confidence that community safety will not be compromised?
link
It is right that the service review is about the SFRS identifying the optimal service to keep communities across Scotland safe in the future by addressing changes in risk. The emergencies that the SFRS responds to have changed significantly over the years; for example, dwelling fires have reduced by more than 20 per cent since 2013. Statistics also show a 33 per cent reduction in non-fatal fire casualties between 2009-10 and 2023-24 and a 32 per cent reduction in fatal fire casualties over the same period. The SFRS chief officer would not make any changes to operations that would put the public at an unacceptable level of risk.
I note the minister’s response, but it will be of little reassurance to firefighters on the ground who are being asked to do more with less. Firefighters have been clear that there are fewer firefighters, fewer appliances and longer response times, and none of those things logically results in safer communities. In response to an article that the minister wrote in her local press, the FBU said:
“The Minister’s call for improved fire safety at a time when she is overseeing a service being systematically stripped of jobs and fire fighting capacity shows she is in complete denial about what is going on in the service she is responsible for.”
Is the minister in complete denial about the effects of her Scottish National Party Government’s cuts to the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service?
link
Absolutely not. I highlight to the member that the reduction in firefighter numbers since 2013 is not because of cuts. Forming a single national service allowed the SFRS to protect front-line services while reducing duplication. We will continue to work with the SFRS to assess the impact of possible pressures on the budget for 2026-27 to ensure that service levels are maintained.
link
The centralisation of the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service was not just about reducing duplication; it was about much more than that. In 2023, 166 firefighters were cut from the service and there was a temporary withdrawal of 10 fire appliances. It was not simply about duplication.
Last week, Colin Brown of the FBU wrote to the First Minister and said:
“It is impossible to accept the argument that fewer firefighters, fewer stations, fewer pumping appliances … and longer response times will somehow make communities safer.”
The Criminal Justice Committee has heard not just from the union but from SFRS management that they are concerned about the budget’s impact. Is it right for the board to make a decision in June, when the new Parliament will only just have been elected? I think that that will result in the burying of bad news. Surely the minister shares my concerns about the issue. Is it not time to shift that decision, at least until the Parliament settles in and we can have a proper look at the impact of the budget on the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service?
link
As I said to the other member, the chief officer has said that the service will not make any changes to operations that put the public at any unacceptable level of risk. With the service delivery review, it is right that the SFRS takes its time to go through the more than 3,000 responses and to make decisions. The SFRS is the expert in the area, and we should allow it to take the decisions on how the service should best be configured.
link
Across Scotland, people will share the FBU’s concern for the service, given the fire in Glasgow. They will have noted the skilled and dedicated work of the firefighters who attended that awful scene. We must have a well-resourced fire service that can respond to ever-changing urban and rural environments. However, there is uncertainty about the future of many fire stations, including the one at Balmossie, in my region. Workers and communities have waited too long to hear what will happen to their local station and staff. When will that uncertainty end? When will firefighters and the communities that they work to keep safe know what their future will be in terms of firefighting safety?
link
We do not have a definite date for the service delivery review but, as I said to Pauline McNeill, the SFRS is taking its time to go through the consultation responses. It is not a short-term plan; it will be implemented over the next five years.
What analysis has been conducted of the potential change in response times for the north-east of the city of Edinburgh should the proposed closure of Marionville fire station proceed?
link
That is an operational decision, and the analysis will come from the Scottish Fire and Rescue through its service delivery review. The SFRS continues to respond to every emergency incident with the appropriate level of resources. That was evident at the fire in Glasgow just a few weeks ago, at which there were more than 250 firefighters.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 24 Mar 2026 →- 10:00 Sport and Activity as a Force for Good Members’ business · 17
- 11:00 Animal Welfare (Sentencing and Public Protection) Members’ business · 18
- 11:27 Time for Reflection Time for reflection · 2
- 14:03 Topical Question Time Questions · 1
- 14:03 Deaths of Babies (Co-sleeping) Questions · 6
- 14:03 Scottish Fire and Rescue Service (Budget) Questions · 12
- 14:03 Home Care Services Questions · 9
- 14:22 Climate Change Plan Statement · 35
- 15:00 Restraint and Seclusion in Schools (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 22
- 15:58 Visitor Levy (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 28
- 16:57 Crofting and Scottish Land Court Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 25
- 17:53 Crime and Policing Bill Bill debate · 3
- 17:53 Tobacco and Vapes Bill Bill debate · 3
- 17:53 Armed Forces Bill Bill debate · 3
- 17:54 Railways Bill Bill debate · 4
- 18:01 Standing Order Rule Changes (Cross-party Groups) Debate · 3
- 18:03 Standing Order Rule Changes (Miscellaneous and Minor Amendments) Debate · 3
- 18:03 Standing Order Rule Changes (Miscellaneous and Minor Amendments) Debate · 3
- 18:05 Lobbying (Scotland) Act 2016 (Modifications) Resolution 2026 Debate · 3
- 18:06 Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 3
- 18:07 Decision Time Decision time · 30
- 18:20 Point of Order Procedure · 3
- 18:22 Bank of Scotland Branch Closures Members’ business · 14
- 19:00 Adoption Support for Families Members’ business · 15
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.