link
To ask the Scottish Government whether planning authorities have adequate guidance on how to assess proposed hyperscale artificial intelligence data centres. (S7O-00034)
Official Report · Chamber
Portfolio Question Time
This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.
link
To ask the Scottish Government whether planning authorities have adequate guidance on how to assess proposed hyperscale artificial intelligence data centres. (S7O-00034)
link
Planning authorities have qualified planning officers who apply their professional analysis and judgment to inform decisions. I recognise the speed of the development of hyperscale AI data centres and their scale in a very new and evolving part of our society. They present risks, upsides and downsides that need to be considered.
The national planning hub has been working with planning authorities, infrastructure providers and industry stakeholders to share an understanding of those benefits and impacts. We will continue that work with diligence and thought over time. We will consider whether there is more formal guidance that would be beneficial to a planning authority locally. We will need to ensure that local authorities are appropriately supported in the assessment of the coming data centres.
link
This is a new and rapidly evolving situation. I hope that the minister recognises that, because there have been huge concerns raised about the proposed data centre at Auchtertool in Fife in relation to its size, its proximity to the village, the energy and water demand and the fact that Fife Council has not requested that an environmental impact assessment be conducted.
I hear what the minister says about time, but, given the lack of specific guidance and the inconsistencies that we are seeing across local planning authorities in Scotland, will she commit to urgently reviewing and updating planning guidance to ensure that the full impact of the AI data centres is considered? We are talking about a problem that exists now, not in the future. Planning authorities need to make proper decisions now.
link
AI data centres are a rapidly evolving sector. It would not be appropriate for the Scottish Government to comment on individual development proposals, because we want to ensure that we avoid any suggestion of favouritism.
The Scottish Government is clear that the voices of communities that are affected by such developments must be central in any considerations, and that planning authorities have a responsibility to consider the environmental impacts of all developments that require planning permission. We are also clear that any new AI infrastructure development should minimise reliance on fossil fuel solutions. Our AI strategy for Scotland is clear that data centre development should include steps to assess and mitigate potential risks presented by infrastructure, including in relation to environmental sustainability.
link
The Scottish Government’s AI strategy has a clear aim of promoting Scotland as a centre for green data centres, but it is less clear on what the terms mean in practice. It says that
“guidance on what factors are prevalent in a ‘green’ data centre”
is expected to be published in 2027. Would that include the necessity to have an environmental impact assessment? At the moment, my understanding is that there would be no such necessity.
Does the minister think that the timescale that we are working towards is still appropriate, given the number of projects that are already seeking planning permission in principle?
link
Claire Baker will appreciate that there are local planning decisions that I cannot comment on from a Government perspective. To be honest, the issue that she raises is a planning matter that is devolved to Fife Council, so I would put to her that it must be Fife Council that considers it.
link
I firmly believe that Scotland cannot be left behind in the new digital age. However, that should not come at a direct cost to the environment or local communities without those communities seeing substantial benefits.
Many parts of Fife have been hit badly by deindustrialisation, with generations of people struggling with unemployment and underemployment. Does the Scottish Government agree that, if those data centres go ahead, the sufficient creation of permanent full-time jobs, with upskilling opportunities for local workers, should form part of the conditions for granting planning permission for them?
link
Economic growth, job creation and benefit within communities that host infrastructure projects such as data centres have to be at the front and centre of the issue. In my portfolio, I am starting to explore the use of planning as a tool. I had a meeting with planning officials yesterday. I am still to get my head around exactly what can be done, but I am sympathetic to using planning as more of a tool to stimulate the kind of growth and benefits that Julie MacDougall has talked about. Given our devolved powers, planning is a tool that we could use to our advantage. I will take that on board as I continue my thoughts and questions. I do not yet have an answer, but the issue is on my agenda and in my mind.
link
Similarly to Mark Ruskell’s data centre in Fife, a 150-hectare data centre that would cover an area larger than 200 football pitches is proposed for the wilderness of the Lammermuir Hills, in the Borders. In the absence of a Scottish Government strategy for locating energy-intensive industries, communities are being left to fight ad-hoc developments that might have potentially irreversible environmental impacts. Does the minister agree that such industrial projects belong in industrial areas and not our pristine wilderness? [Duncan Dunlop has corrected this contribution. See end of report.]
link
Again, I will not comment on specific planning applications that are going through councils. However, there is a difference between industrialisation and industry. Especially in areas of the Highlands and Islands, it is clear that industry can co-exist alongside communities, nature and built heritage. It is about making sure that we equip local authorities with resources and appropriate funding from our side to be able to handle that.
It would be inappropriate for me to comment on individual cases, but I am sympathetic to Duncan Dunlop’s point about the difference between industrialisation and industry, because a balance needs to be struck, especially in rural and island communities.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.