To ask the Scottish Government what its position is on whether the current fiscal framework is biased against Scotland. (S6O-05629)
Official Report · Chamber
Fiscal Framework
General Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- John Mason Ind 2
- Shona Robison SNP 2
The record
4 contributionsThe fiscal framework will always be suboptimal compared with having the full powers of independence.
In the meantime, discussions with the United Kingdom Government on the scope of the next review of the framework are under way. That is an opportunity to examine thoroughly the framework’s current arrangements and secure further improvements that benefit Scotland. I am seeking a more ambitious and broadly scoped review. However, agreement on that must be reached with the UK Government.
I thank the cabinet secretary for the fact that we are looking for an ambitious review. The fiscal framework was based on our competing with or matching the rest of the UK. We can do that with most regions in Northern Ireland and Wales, but we struggle to do that—and always have—with London and the south-east. On top of that, the Barnett formula squeezes our spending and ignores needs such as rurality.
At the start of the fiscal framework, we thought that we were getting a good deal, although the Conservatives wanted us to accept something poorer. However, in retrospect, we can see that the fiscal framework is not working. The Government must demand a serious review. I know that the cabinet secretary will not be here, but can she commit the Government to that?
I agree with John Mason that some of the comparators are very challenging. Given the advantages and fiscal position of London and the south-east, it is very difficult for Scotland, Wales, Northern Ireland or, indeed, English regions to compete with them. Given that the fiscal framework is based around some of the very difficult comparators of growth or otherwise, particularly in relation to the population and tax base, it is very challenging.
To answer John Mason directly, it is important that there is a thorough review of the fiscal framework that goes back to some of the fundamentals. We absolutely require fiscal flexibilities. We need only look at the global factors that are impacting on public finances at the moment to see why Governments—whether it is the Scottish Government or other Governments—face headwinds, and we have very limited levers to respond to that. A fundamental review is required at this stage.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 12 Mar 2026 →- 11:40 General Question Time Questions · 1
- 11:40 Cost of Living Support (Glasgow Anniesland) Questions · 4
- 11:40 Fiscal Framework Questions · 4
- 11:40 Queen Elizabeth University Hospital Questions · 6
- 11:40 Bus Services (Rural and Coastal Constituencies) Questions · 6
- 11:40 Energy Project Objections Questions · 7
- 11:40 National Health Service (Decision Making and Accountability) Questions · 4
- 11:40 NHS Ayrshire and Arran (Financial Sustainability) Questions · 4
- 12:00 Dunblane Shootings (30th Anniversary) Debate · 6
- 12:06 First Minister’s Question Time First Minister’s Questions · 1
- 12:06 Glasgow Union Street Fire First Minister’s Questions · 8
- 12:06 Glasgow Union Street Fire First Minister’s Questions · 6
- 12:06 Maternity Services (Caithness) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- 12:06 Heating Costs (Rural Households) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- 12:06 Private Healthcare (NHS Consultants) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- 12:06 Measles Vaccinations First Minister’s Questions · 5
- 12:06 Leaked Memo (Devolution) First Minister’s Questions · 5
- 12:06 Eljamel Public Inquiry First Minister’s Questions · 2
- 12:06 Police Scotland (Data Protection) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- 12:06 UK Government Policies (Impact on North-east Scotland) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- 12:06 Baird Family Hospital and Aberdeen and North Centre for Haematology, Oncology and Radiotherapy First Minister’s Questions · 2
- 12:06 School Strikes (Funding) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- 12:53 Point of Order Procedure · 3
- 12:56 Edinburgh Medical School 300 Members’ business · 8
- 13:16 Education and Skills Questions · 1
- 13:16 Colleges (Borrowing Powers) Questions · 8
- 13:16 Rural Schools Questions · 6
- 13:16 Defence, Aerospace and Space Sectors (Skills Shortages) Questions · 6
- 13:16 School Investment Programmes (Cumbernauld and Kilsyth) Questions · 5
- 13:16 School Provision and Safe Travel Routes (Robroyston) Questions · 5
- 13:16 Budget 2026-27 (Apprenticeships) Questions · 6
- 13:16 Schools (Violent and Disruptive Incidents) Questions · 6
- 14:26 Tackling Child Poverty Delivery Plan Statement · 38
- 14:58 Assisted Dying for Terminally Ill Adults (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 655
- 21:58 Decision Time Decision time · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.