I thank colleagues on both sides of the debate for their contributions. I particularly thank those who are making their final contributions in the chamber, whether, as Douglas Lumsden and Paul O’Kane observed, they realise it yet or not.
Today’s debate has certainly emulated the debate that we had at stage 1, back in May. It has been a high point of this Parliament. I echo Liz Smith’s comments and the plea to those who are elected to the next Parliament that we up our game more consistently. I again pay tribute to Liz Smith, who will be an enormous loss to this Parliament.
Reflecting on the debate, it seems clear that the Parliament might well vote against the bill shortly. If that is the case, I believe that it is a decision that many in the chamber, including many who will not return to it after May, will come to regret deeply, although not as deeply or as painfully as those dying Scots and their families who desperately need us to act with courage, compassion and urgency.
With apologies to the Parliament, we are now beyond debate and I simply need to set out why the ban on assisted dying is failing too many people at the end of life, despite the best efforts of palliative care, and why passing up this opportunity to address that failure and the trauma that it causes would be unforgivable.
I know that there are members whose position on assisted dying has been set for some time—both those for and against. I respect those positions, even when I fundamentally disagree. In the time that is available to me now, I plan to address those who remain conflicted. Some voted to support the general principles at stage 1 and others did not. All that I know is that they feel torn. They know that the current law lacks compassion and safety, yet they wrestle with doubts and questions.
This decision weighs heavily on us all, but, for some, there will be genuine fear. Despite consistent evidence of overwhelming public support for assisted dying, including among those of faith, there is fear that comes from being denounced from the pulpit or in church circulars.
Despite the bill being explicit that disability alone is excluded from eligibility criteria, and despite peer-reviewed research from Professor Ben Colburn at the University of Glasgow showing that such laws do not cause harm to people with disabilities or undermine healthcare accessibility for disabled people, there is fear that there might be an impact on those in the disability community, who, again, polls suggest strongly support a change in the law.
Despite the House of Commons Health and Social Care Committee finding no negative impacts and, in many cases, improved investment in and engagement with palliative care in jurisdictions with assisted dying laws, there is fear about the interaction with such care.
Despite no evidence from other jurisdictions and the fact that medical professionals already deal with such assessments in relation to patients stopping eating and drinking, and in relation to decisions about taking, refusing or withdrawing treatment, there is fear about coercion, when amendments to the bill last week put in further safeguards.
Despite there being absolutely no possibility of any act coming into force without robust no duty/no detriment protection or key training, qualification and experience provisions being in place, there is fear about protection for medics.
There is fear about a so-called slippery slope, for which, as the Commons health committee concluded, there is no evidence anywhere in the world in relation to terminal illness mental capacity models of assisted dying. Moreover, the courts here have made it clear that this is a matter for the Parliament to decide.
There is then the more generalised fear about taking a decision of such significance.
I do not underestimate those fears, but they are nothing compared with the fear felt by those who must be at the centre of the debate.
There is the fear of 22-year-old Brian Churcher, whose cancer left him in agony for two weeks in a hospice, where he pleaded with his family to kill him. His mother, Tracy, whom I met outside the Parliament earlier today, said:
“This will remain with me the rest of my life. Cancer took everything from Brian. Before it took his life, it stripped him of his dignity.”
There is the fear that was felt by Nicola and her late husband, Graham, whose bowel cancer led to terrifying hallucinations and a final two weeks of hell, during which Graham asked hospice doctors to help him to die.
There is the fear that was experienced by Tora, Zoe, Sarah and their mother, Heather. They explained:
“When she lay down, she made a choking noise. So they gave her medication to clear her tubes. Then came hours of vomiting brown foam … We cut up downie covers, towels, pillow cases … using them to mop up constantly … She said, ‘Tora, just kill me now’.”
There was the fear of Leighanne, whose wife, Gill, died from stage 4 melanoma but who threatened to jump in front of a bus to end the pain.
There was the fear of Cath Shepheard, who sat in the garden lobby back in 2023 and told me of her experience with motor neurone disease:
“I … wondered if I could find some drugs so that I could overdose, but I didn’t know … how much to take to do the job properly”.
Then,
“the idea of stopping using my … [feeding tube] came into my head … and I literally felt my whole body relax”
and
“I wish I could choose something quicker, because this … may take two to three weeks”.
She was right. It took Cath 17 days to die.
In 2019, the “Inescapable Truth About Dying in Scotland” report was published, drawing on testimony from palliative care professionals, dying people and bereaved families. I had planned to spare the chamber the details of some of the cases that were highlighted in that report. However, given where we stand—given the risk that the bill may fall—that no longer seems tenable, so I will quote for the chamber—and for Sir Harry Burns—the palliative care consultant who said:
“One of the most distressed patients I have ever seen in my life was a man who had had a penile cancer. His penis had been removed and he was left with a big open hole directly into his bladder. He was a very gentle person. He was so ashamed and he would cry. He was begging to have his life ended because he just hated it and he had lived for months in that condition … He was also in pain, but that was not the main thing; it was the utter degradation. I felt so helpless. We could do nothing about that.”
During this debate and in the run-up to it, some colleagues have declared their opposition to the bill. I realise that to act otherwise now would be difficult and uncomfortable, but I ask those colleagues to measure that short-term discomfort against the enduring agony and humiliation that I have just described. Could any of us face that palliative care consultant or the family of that poor man, look them in the eye and say honestly that nothing can be done, that there is no alternative and that introducing more choice, in the way that many other states and countries have done safely and successfully over recent years, is beyond us here in Scotland?
Responding to the report, Professor Sir Graeme Catto, former chair of the General Medical Council, made a plea that we need to
“listen carefully to … the compassionate honesty of palliative care professionals who recognise the limitations of their speciality; the trauma of bereaved relatives whose precious memories have been poisoned by the things no son, daughter, mother, father, sister, brother or partner should ever have to witness; and the fear of dying people who simply want the peace of mind that comes through having choice and control at the end of their lives.”
Colleagues, Tracy Churcher has said that, when she thinks about her son Brian now, she remembers not the smiling boy on holiday but the terror of his illness and the agony that he experienced in his death. That breaks me.
The bill is tightly drawn, heavily safeguarded and legally defensible. MSPs can have confidence that what they are voting for will be delivered in practice. Those who are tempted to vote no this evening need to realise that doing so will not make anyone safer but will leave ever-increasing numbers of dying Scots more at risk, isolated and vulnerable.
The issue is not going away. However, by refusing to take this opportunity to act, the Parliament will simply force people to travel overseas and take decisions behind closed doors, with no safeguards, no protection and no support, or condemn them to suffer like Brian, Cath and Heather.
Throughout this process, I have sought to be measured, reasonable and respectful. In my view, that is the only way to address an issue of such sensitivity. I am enormously grateful for the nauseating compliments to me and my staff. At this point, however, I hope that colleagues will forgive me if I am also blunt. I simply cannot see how those who vote no this evening will not forfeit their right to step outside the chamber and tell themselves, their constituents and the wider public that they support the principles of a change in the law but not this bill, not at this time and not in this way. That is just not good enough. More importantly, it is a woefully inadequate response to the suffering and trauma that is experienced by the dying Scots and their families who are being grotesquely failed by the ban on assisted dying.
As a growing number of countries and states around the world, including Jersey and the Isle of Man, are proving, there is another way. We can and must do better. This is the time, this is the bill, and this is the change that dying Scots desperately need us to make.
I implore MSPs: have the courage of your convictions. Listen to the overwhelming majority of people across Scotland; most of all, listen to Lisa and the hundreds more like her, and back this bill.