Welcome back. Item 6 on the agenda is consideration of a further draft Scottish statutory instrument, on which the Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee has made no comment.I welcome Gillian Martin, the Cabinet Secretary for Climate Action and Energy, and her supporting officials Joel Hankinson, who is the head of Energy Act implementation in the offshore wind directorate, and David Moffat, who is a solicitor for the Scottish Government.The instrument is laid under the affirmative procedure, which means that it cannot come into force unless the Parliament approves it. Following the evidence session, the committee will be invited to consider a motion recommending that the instrument be approved.I remind everyone that officials can speak under this item but not in the debate that follows. Would you like to make a brief opening statement, cabinet secretary?
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Conservation of Habitats and Species (Offshore Wind) (Miscellaneous Amendments) (Scotland) Regulations 2026 [Draft]
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Edward Mountain Con 16
- Gillian Martin SNP 10
- Douglas Lumsden Con 4
- Michael Matheson SNP 3
- Joel Hankinson Scottish Government 3
- Monica Lennon Lab 3
- Mark Ruskell Green 2
The record
42 contributions
link
Thank you for the opportunity to speak to the instrument. I will try to be as brief as possible. Under the current habitats regulations, projects that affect protected sites must secure compensatory measures that are targeted specifically at the impacted habitat or species. In practice, only a limited range of measures can be evidenced to that standard, which creates a significant constraint for offshore wind development and puts climate and energy security ambitions at risk.As a result of the passing of the Energy Act 2023, which was introduced by the former Conservative Government and delivered by the current Labour Government at UK level, we can now lay this Scottish statutory instrument, which introduces a more flexible approach but with strong safeguards. The core habitats regulations assessments remain, but new environmental safeguards will be brought into place and projects with potential adverse effects must still secure robust compensatory measures.The SSI enables compensatory measures that support the wider UK marine protected area network, not only the impacted feature. Additional safeguards include the establishment of a compensation hierarchy to prioritise like-for-like measures but also enable wider alternatives when they are appropriate and offer enhanced ecological benefits.We will publish guidance on how to apply the legislation and hierarchy and will review both regularly to ensure that the framework remains robust, transparent and responsive to new evidence. That guidance is being developed collaboratively with the UK Government and key stakeholders to ensure that it is grounded in scientific and industry expertise.The SSI applies to Scotland’s inshore region, with a corresponding instrument to be introduced by the UK Government for offshore waters. The two instruments have been designed to align closely, and the guidance will apply across both inshore and offshore areas to support a consistent, joined-up approach.
The deputy convener has the first question.
Good afternoon, cabinet secretary. The instrument is an important step, given the challenges that the previous regulations have posed for the development of projects. I suppose that one of the key issues will be the governance process for the decision making on where mitigations for a particular project can be put in place and how that process will be managed and prioritised. How will that governance process operate in order to decide where an alternative form of mitigation could take place? How will that work on a four-nations basis, given that it is possible that mitigations could take place across the whole of the UK?
link
In practice, the governance associated with the process is still the normal consent process, which is about the habitats regulations and the compensatory part of any kind of application for consent. As at the moment, developers will have to produce plans on what they intend to compensate on and the data associated with that, but the difference is that they will be able to include wider measures.The hierarchy is very important in that process: at the top, developers must consider like-for-like measures wherever possible and applicable, but those measures might be augmented by other measures in tiers 2 and 3 of the hierarchy. The marine directorate consents unit will analyse all the data and plans that are put forward. Developers will be able to get advice on that from the marine directorate and also from NatureScot.Developers can put forward their own plans, and their application will be judged on those plans, but they can also apply to the Scottish marine recovery fund. There is a strategic recovery fund for the whole of Scotland that will enable large-scale and strategic projects to take place. Gillian Martin has corrected this contribution. See end of report. There will be a range of particular workstreams that might be able to be applied to and funded as part of that.The decisions, which are made on the habitats regulations and will have due regard to the hierarchy, will still be made by the marine directorate licensing operations team—MDLOT—but will come to ministers, along with all the advice, as is usual.
The hierarchy is helpful in trying to understand part of the process. Outwith the direct project, who will decide what the mitigations to offset the habitats impact of the project should be? Will the developer put forward the proposal on, for example, plans to do stoat or rat eradication on a particular island? Or will the developer accept that it cannot mitigate it all within its particular site and therefore seek advice from a third party, through the Scottish Government, to direct what the mitigation should be? I am trying to understand what that process looks like.
link
You are right that the developers will put forward their own plans. However, their own plans might not be sufficient, or they might discover, as they are working to put forward their plans, that there are not enough compensatory, like-for-like measures—those at the top of the hierarchy—in order for them to deliver adequate compensation. I will bring in Joel Hankinson on this point; he might have more detail on it, as he has been working heavily on the governance and policy around this. Developers will be able to engage with the marine directorate and also with NatureScot, both of which will have an impact on what the marine recovery fund will deliver, so they will be able to suggest mitigations. Joel will have more detail.
There will still be two alternative ways in which strategic compensation or compensatory measures could be brought forward under the new regime. The ability for offshore wind developers to individually propose compensation to offset their adverse impacts will remain. They can bring forward either wider measures or like-for-like measures, and they will go through the ordinary consenting process as part of that, engaging with—as Ms Martin said—MDLOT and statutory nature conservation bodies to understand that.The marine recovery fund is also being explored as a mechanism for delivering strategic compensation. That would be a voluntary mechanism established by Government that will require its own governance process to look at the impacts of strategic compensation and how it can be delivered effectively. That will need a different type of advisory group or monitoring framework or approach.On the question about wider governance, when we went out to consultation, we proposed two things. The first was a mandatory review period on a five-year cycle across the UK as a whole, including working with the UK Government, in order to understand the impacts of the legislation and where we might need to make changes. We will be working very closely with the UK Government as part of that process.We also proposed the establishment of a technical advisory group to look at how we approve strategic compensation to go into a marine recovery fund, for example, and how we understand what further research needs to be undertaken. That work is still being developed at this stage, so we can return with further information in due course. It is very much a case of live policy development at the moment.
link
I add that there will also be analysis of the impact of the compensatory measures. The committee will be very familiar with the Scottish marine energy research programme, or ScotMER. The data associated with applications, and the data that goes into ScotMER about the marine environment, biodiversity and the impact on species, will also feed in to the analysis of the impact of all the compensatory measures that have been made, so that that forms part of the wider analysis. We will also share learning across the borders of the four nations.
There are only so many mitigation measures that can be put in place, so there will be only so much mitigation that can be done. Given the Scottish Government’s ambition to reach 40GW of offshore wind by 2040, where we are in the delivery pipeline in Scottish waters, as well as there obviously being a pipeline in England and Wales, what will be the process to ensure that it is not simply a case of first come, first served? If you drop all the scope mitigations that could be put in place outwith your own project, that could result in projects further down the line finding that there is not much left for them to do. It will not be quite like that—I am putting it in a fairly crude way—but I am trying to think about how we can ensure that we are giving as much scope as possible to maximise the process in a way that keeps in mind that it will be way into the 2030s before some projects are delivered and that there is a need to ensure that there are still some mitigation measures that they can help to support, when it comes to the point at which they need to do that.
link
Biodiversity loss is happening across many parts of the food chain, particularly those associated with seabirds. As data improves and science develops, I imagine that we might be able to take more suites of measures to protect seabirds from the various stresses that they face. That sharing of knowledge will be very important. Also, as I said, we will look every five years at whether the approach is workable, which is really important.You make an important point. Obviously, there is some work that can be done now on a like-for-like basis. Will those measures be sufficient to stop the decline in the seabird population? Possibly not, but other measures may come through that might have an impact on the seabird population. This is way into the future, but we could even be looking at some strategic stuff around the impacts of avian flu, for example. Predator eradication and invasive species work is very time-consuming and costly and will take decades to keep on top of. Managing and eradicating invasive species will not be fixed in the next five years—it will require constant maintenance. That is like-for-like work.Moreover, mitigation will not have to happen only in the geographical area where the development is. It could happen across Scotland, in any area in which a particular type of species is nesting, breeding or feeding. There will be quite a lot of scope.The other thing is that it is about the entire UK marine protected area network. We are further ahead in our marine protected areas in Scotland, but species do not care about borders. Where they are and where they move to could be any part of the UK waters. That is why the strategic approach might yield more ambition in relation to taking away the stressors to marine life.
I am sure that I do not need to remind everyone about the time. The clock is not stopping for me—it never has done—and time is marching on. The next question comes from Mark Ruskell.
link
I think that the deputy convener has covered some of the areas that I wanted to go into, and I listened to the responses.I have only one question. I noticed that the responses to the consultation were quite divided—environmental non-governmental organisations were not really supportive of the measure and there were some concerns from the fishing sector as well, but the renewable energy sector was very supportive. Given what you have described in relation to the hierarchy and the need to look at the issue more strategically, how do you see those interests coming together? It is clear that the industry will probably run out of options for setting traps on islands to remove invasive species.There will be a need for serious investment in ecological restoration across the seas, which will require environmental non-governmental organisations and others coming to the table, working with the industry and coming up with some really big ideas that go way beyond what is being discussed at the moment. How do you ensure that that input is there and that you are not just having a circular conversation with the industry?12:45
link
What you have highlighted is extremely important. Some of the ENGOs might be reticent about the regulations, but they have to be in the room, along with all the stakeholders that are associated with the marine environment. One major advantage of that is that the ENGOs and the associated scientific community will be able to work with us on the compensatory measures.At the moment, the hierarchy is a proposal. We have not bottomed out all the actions that might be in the hierarchy, but the actions that are associated with all tiers of the hierarchy will be done in consultation with all stakeholders. Where there is an ability in the future to redevelop the hierarchy—the instrument will be reviewed every five years—we will be able to constantly analyse how the compensatory measures are working and whether we can do anything more. We might be able to add additional actions to certain tiers of the hierarchy. Given that there will be a marine recovery fund, the chances are that there will be an awful lot more funding associated with doing some of the bigger interventions. Every stakeholder that is associated with the marine environment needs to be around the table, because we cannot go forward without all that expertise.
To expand on that, we are in the process of drafting the guidance that will underpin the instrument and we have committed to engaging with ENGOs and other stakeholders as part of that, because we want them to meaningfully contribute to how the hierarchy works in practice and how it can be a meaningful safeguard. At the same time, we are progressing a series of research projects to look at what compensatory measures could be taken forward as part of the work. Again, we engage with ENGOs and other interested stakeholders as part of that.I do not expect the research that we are doing to be the end of the story—we will have to do more. As part of that, we will continue to engage with those stakeholders. We are fully cognisant that they know things about our marine environment that we do not necessarily know and that there are positive things that we can do. We can learn a lot from them, and we want them to be part of the journey.
Monica, you have a chance to ask another question, later. Are you happy to take that opportunity, or do you want to come in now?
I will wait.
Perfect. Douglas, you have a question.
It is only brief. The Scottish Government policy note says:“The policy is anticipated to have a negative impact on fisheries.”When I talk to people in the fishing industry, they are concerned that mitigation, perhaps for a wind farm down in the south of England, might end up restricting fishing off the north-east coast. What discussions have you had with the fishing industry about that? How can you give it some reassurance that the sector will not be adversely impacted by what happens elsewhere?
link
All the conditions that are associated with compensation from the developer will go in to MDLOT at the Scottish Government. To be honest, I cannot see a situation in which the scenario that you have described would happen, because we have developments of our own for which we need to find compensatory measures.Regarding our general engagement with the fishing sector, it will have, and already has had, opportunities through that engagement to help to shape the compensation measures that have been structured. We have already been working with it. There will be engagement on the proposed measures, opportunities to provide that detailed knowledge about fishing activity and local marine conditions, and we would work with it on any intelligence and data that it might want to provide on fish species. We need to ensure that all marine industries are able to co-exist, so marine spatial planning will be very important, and the committee knows very well the work that has been done in that area.The marine stakeholders in general have been involved in the development of the instrument and all the underpinning policy, which was done on a four-nations basis as a result of the Energy Act 2023. They have been able to input into that.Another aspect of the matter is that, when it comes to any consultation on particular developments, representatives of the fishing industry can also put their submissions in to MDLOT, on a case-by-case basis.
What, then, is the negative impact that you anticipate that your policy will have on fisheries?
link
The policy note is highlighting that there is that potential. We will work to avoid that as much as possible so that all marine industries can co-exist. All the impacts on any part of the marine sector are taken into account by MDLOT as an application goes through the consenting process.
I think that that has also answered my question. I am not sure whether your question on coastal communities has been answered, Monica, or whether you want to come in.
That has been covered. I am mindful of the time, so could I get just a word or two about the role of NatureScot? We heard from it earlier. Given the new governance structures around this and the four-nations approach, do you see any particular challenges for NatureScot in relation to this work?
link
I was not able to see NatureScot’s part of the meeting but I hope that it was able to give you comfort that it is preparing for this work and that it sees it as positive. NatureScot is looking at structuring its operations to ensure that it has in-house expertise, so that it can work with developers and signpost them to the best compensation measures that might be available to them. It has been preparing for this. As I said, the Energy Act 2023 was introduced in the previous UK Parliament, so all the agencies across the UK have been preparing for a few years for the eventuality that we will have this flexibility and new hierarchy.
To expand on that, statutory nature conservation bodies across the UK, including NatureScot, have been closely involved in the development of the policy and the approach that we are taking. We have had regular discussions with NatureScot about what we are trying to achieve and what its potential role could be in that. As I mentioned previously, we are still working through what that governance structure—the technical advisory group that underpins the policy—could look like in practice, but we very much see a role for SNCBs as part of that process.
That is helpful.
I am sure that the cabinet secretary will want to review the evidence that we heard from NatureScot this morning and be convinced that it is ready for the policy. I will leave it there. Do you have a follow-up question, Mark?
link
I am fine.
No member has indicated that they have any other questions, so we move to item 7, which is a debate on motion S6M-20459.Motion moved,That the Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee recommends that the Conservation of Habitats and Species (Offshore Wind) (Miscellaneous Amendments) (Scotland) Regulations 2026 draft be approved.—Gillian Martin.
Does anyone want to say anything?
I will be very brief because I know that time is against us. I find it very difficult to support something that says in black and white that there will be a negative impact on fisheries.I also have concerns about the governance arrangements that the deputy convener asked about. I do not think that they are all there yet—that is perhaps not to be expected—but I would like to know more about them.I have a concern that all the available compensations in Scotland could be used up for projects that are actually in different parts of the UK. You might think that that is okay, but I have concerns that especially the fishing fleet will be impacted by things that are taking place miles away. It seems that the only compensation that it will be entitled to are measures such as marine litter removal. If there is going to be an impact on the Scottish fishing fleet, I think that proper monetary compensation should be put in place for those people whose livelihoods will be affected. I hope that that will come in in future SSIs or legislation. As it is, I cannot support the instrument.
Can you sum up and respond to the debate, cabinet secretary?
link
I will just respond to that point. The governance framework will be set out after the SSI is approved. The governance framework is not in the instrument. That work is on-going. The compensatory framework and the hierarchy will be developed with stakeholders.
Okay, thank you. Interruption. Sorry?
I was going to ask for an intervention.
You were too slow—the cabinet secretary came to the end of what she was saying.The question is, that motion S6M-20459, in the cabinet secretary’s name, be agreed to. Are we agreed?Members: No.
There will be a division.
Doris, Bob (Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn) (SNP)Lennon, Monica (Central Scotland) (Lab)Matheson, Michael (Falkirk West) (SNP)Ruskell, Mark (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Green)Stewart, Kevin (Aberdeen Central) (SNP)Lumsden, Douglas (North East Scotland) (Con)Mountain, Edward (Highlands and Islands) (Con)
The result of the division is: For 5, Against 0, Abstentions 2.Motion agreed to,That the Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee recommends that the Conservation of Habitats and Species (Offshore Wind) (Miscellaneous Amendments) (Scotland) Regulations 2026 draft be approved.
The committee was a bit slow last time, so let us see if we can be quicker. Is the committee happy to delegate authority to me as convener to approve a draft of our report on the SSI for publication?Members indicated agreement.
You are. Good. Thank you so much. Thank you for attending, cabinet secretary and officials.12:56Meeting continued in private until 13:45.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportNo recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.
In this meeting
Everything on 17 Feb 2026 →- 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 09:00 NatureScot (Annual Report and Accounts and Future Priorities) Evidence session · 204
- 09:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 216
- 09:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 42
- 09:00 Correction Committee business · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.