Again, as I said in my response to you, it is my expectation that that is what would happen. As Bob Doris pointed out, there is no ministerial direction here—it has to be an operational issue for Transport Scotland. As a minister, it is my expectation that such criminal acts would result in the loss of the bus pass. However, Douglas Lumsden has made the point that we would then be looking at retrospective decision making. I am not going to talk about the individual case, but he is talking about retrospective decision making, and that is not something that I can talk about right now.I will have conversations with the Cabinet Secretary for Justice and Home Affairs with regard to all the things that we have talked about today. A huge amount of work is already going on in the Scottish Government that is well beyond the scope of the order, and nobody is going to defend the rights of women and children more than me or my colleagues in the Government—we have been very proactive in doing so. I am more than happy to continue working across Government, if that is what Monica Lennon wants to happen.
Minister, that was a statement; an intervention is usually a question, so I will ask Monica Lennon to conclude what she was saying, so that I can go to Mark Ruskell.
I think that I have been clear in making the point about my intention with the order. From what I have heard, I believe that the Government has failed to look at the issue in a wider sense. The discussions with the justice secretary could have happened earlier in the process. I will leave my remarks there, convener.
It is clear that when individuals carry out serious criminal behaviour and end up in court, it should be in the gift of the courts to restrict their access to a bus pass, or even to public transport full stop, should they consider that appropriate. That is the way to deal with criminals who are going through the criminal justice system.With regard to the order, which is about concessionary bus passes, I cannot see how it will make any difference whatsoever to that criminal behaviour—not one jot. All that we are saying, in effect, is that somebody does not have a free bus pass any longer, but they are still at liberty to get on board whatever bus they want. They are still at liberty to be in a bus station or throw bricks at a bus from the side of the road, as we have seen in Clackmannanshire and in Edinburgh.The order will not change anything, but it will set up a very costly bureaucratic system—
In a second. The order also poses the risk that we conflate bad and discourteous behaviour on buses with serious criminal behaviour. Even though we have a revised code of conduct in front of us that focuses more on criminality and harassment, there is still a danger that judgment calls will be made and that bad behaviour on buses will be conflated with criminal behaviour. At the end of the day, the order will not make any difference at all.I would like the Government to put in place the approach that has been taken on the trains with the ScotRail travel safe teams. I know that the Government has work very closely with the rail unions on that, and I think that a better approach can be taken on buses, learning from that experience on the trains, but I just do not see the order making any difference at all.I will not stand in the way of the order—I will abstain—but I tell you now that I do not think that it will make any difference at all, and that there will still be risks and dangers. The real issue here—restricting people who have shown clear criminal behaviour—will still exist and will not be addressed by whether somebody is going to pay a quid to get on a bus or get on the bus for free.Minister, did you want to come in?
I was merely going to ask whether the member accepts that this is an opportunity to put a deterrent in place for antisocial behaviour. However, he has made his position clear, so that is probably a moot point.
I respect where the minister is coming from, and I suspect that we are not that far away from each other on this, but I just cannot see the deterrent. Those people will swap cards with their friends, and they will try to get on the bus whether they have a card or not.People who are involved in serious antisocial behaviour will do what they do. They will continue to throw stones through the windscreens of buses and they will continue to cause havoc at bus stations until we have an approach that deals with the root causes of antisocial behaviour, brings those who have been involved in criminal activities to justice, and deals with some of the underlying causes. I am sorry, but I do not see the order as part of the mix. I will not stand in its way, but I will not vote for it.
I am just looking around the room—I see no other member wanting to comment. I will comment and then go to the minister. I say at the start that I will not take any interventions.I have been a convener in the Parliament for nine years and I have sat through the consideration of numerous SSIs during that time. I have been supportive of a lot of them, and I have not been supportive of some of them. In those nine years, there is only one SSI that has come back after it was rejected, with the motion not moved the first time because it was quite clear that the policy behind it was immature and not properly thought out. It has happened only one time—with this order.We waited and were told that a draft code of conduct would come to the committee. The draft code of conduct was submitted with a letter from the minister. I have to say that the draft code of conduct, as produced to this committee, is poor in content and unhelpful in a lot of respects, because it raises more questions than it answers. I was extremely grateful for the input of the deputy convener and Kevin Stewart in explaining to the committee some of the things that the minister was unable to explain.I want the order to be approved, and I will vote for the motion on the basis that I agree with the principle of the order. Do I think that it is ready to be implemented? No, I do not. If the order is approved, it must be implemented by 24 March. That allows the Government 28 working days to come up with a code of conduct that works well and is able to support the order. Do I believe that that can happen? No, I do not.I have to say—and it is really sad that I have to say this—that in my time in the Parliament, the consideration of this order has proved to be the most difficult thing to convene, and it has perhaps shown the Parliament at its worst when it comes to dealing with SSIs. Those are strong words, and I do not say them lightly.Minister, I will come to you now, if you would like to comment.
I hear the convener’s points. I will go back to Mark Ruskell’s comment that he will not support the order but will abstain, and that is absolutely his choice. People will swap their cards, but if they do that, it is fraud and therefore a criminal act. The purpose of the removal of a bus pass is to crack down on antisocial behaviour. It is, I hope, a deterrent more than anything else.With regard to being able to lay an SSI as a completed piece of work, the convener is well aware that, quite often, we will lay an SSI and then develop the policy and its workings as we go forward. This order will be ready to be implemented by the autumn of this year. There has been a demand for us to lay the order in order to put out the message that antisocial behaviour on buses will be tackled. The order is the first stage of the process. A tremendous amount of work has already gone into it and a tremendous amount of work will continue to go into it in order to make it operational by the autumn of this year.
ForDoris, Bob (Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn) (SNP)Lennon, Monica (Central Scotland) (Lab)Lumsden, Douglas (North East Scotland) (Con)Matheson, Michael (Falkirk West) (SNP)Mountain, Edward (Highlands and Islands) (Con)Stewart, Kevin (Aberdeen Central) (SNP)AbstentionsRuskell, Mark (Mid Scotland and Fife) (Green)
The result of the division is: For 6, Against 0, Abstentions 1.Motion agreed to,That the Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee recommends that the National Bus Travel Concession Schemes (Miscellaneous Amendment) (Scotland) Order 2026 draft be approved.
Gosh, I thought that you were all going to pause then. I thank the minister and his officials, and I suspend the meeting until 12.30 to allow a changeover of witnesses.12:24Meeting suspended.12:30On resuming—
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.