Welcome back. Item 3 is consideration of two draft Scottish statutory instruments. The Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee has made no comment on either of the instruments.I welcome to the meeting Jim Fairlie, Minister for Agriculture and Connectivity, and his supporting officials. Kelly Minio-Paluello—I probably massacred the pronunciation of your name, for which I apologise profusely—is a solicitor for the Scottish Government. From Transport Scotland, we welcome Carole Stewart, head of the bus strategy and funding policy unit; Gary McIntyre, economist, bus active travel and low-carbon economics; and Jenn Ruddick, team leader for concessionary travel.Both instruments have been laid under the affirmative procedure, which means that they cannot come into force until the Parliament approves them. Following this evidence session, the committee will be invited to consider two separate approval motions—one for each instrument. I remind everyone that officials can speak under the current item but not in the debate that follows. Minister, you may make a brief opening statement.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
National Bus Travel Concession Schemes (Miscellaneous Amendment) (Scotland) Order 2026 [Draft]
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jim Fairlie SNP 69
- Edward Mountain Con 54
- Monica Lennon Lab 24
- Mark Ruskell Green 20
- Carole Stewart Transport Scotland 10
- Douglas Lumsden Con 10
- Michael Matheson SNP 9
- Bob Doris SNP 7
- Gary McIntyre Transport Scotland 6
- Kevin Stewart SNP 3
- Kelly Minio-Paluello Scottish Government 3
The record
216 contributions · showing 1–200
link
Thank you, convener. I will start with the draft National Bus Travel Concession Schemes (Miscellaneous Amendment) (Scotland) (No 2) Order 2026. The order gives effect to an agreement that was reached with the Confederation of Passenger Transport, which represents Scottish bus operators. It sets for 2026-27 the reimbursement rate and capped level of funding in the national bus travel concession schemes for older and disabled persons and young persons. The order will enable reimbursement of bus operators for journeys that are made under both schemes after the expiry of the current reimbursement provisions, on 31 March 2026. It specifies the new reimbursement rates and capped level of funding for both schemes for the next financial year, to 31 March 2027.An updated reimbursement model for both schemes, which was agreed and developed in partnership with the industry, was used for the first time last year. This year, we have used that model once again to set the proposed rates and budget caps for the schemes. The model uses the latest available data and evidence on industry costs, passenger demand and travel behaviours. The proposed reimbursement rate for the older and disabled persons scheme in 2026-27 has been amended from 52.9 per cent to 53 per cent of the adult single fare, and the capped level of the funding will be set at £248.2 million, which is an increase of £33.1 million from this year.The proposed reimbursement rates for the young persons scheme for 2026-27 are as follows. For five to 15-year-olds, the rate will be 48.1 per cent of the adult single fare, which is an increase of 0.2 percentage points from the current rate of 47.9 per cent. For 16 to 21-year-olds, the rate will be 72.5 per cent, which is an increase of 0.1 percentage points from the current rate of 72.4 per cent. Since it began, in 2022, the young persons scheme has not been subject to a budget cap, as demand and patronage have been uncertain while the scheme has become established. However, demand is now relatively stable, with uptake by young people reaching around 90 per cent of the eligible population. The draft order before you therefore includes a budget cap of £220.6 million to be applied to the young persons scheme for 2026-27.The national concessionary travel schemes continue to deliver life-changing benefits, supporting social inclusion, embedding sustainable travel habits and supporting 2.4 million card holders to access essential services. The draft order being discussed today will ensure that we can continue to deliver those successful, highly valued schemes, which provide a degree of stability to the bus sector on a basis that is fair to operators and affordable from public funds. I recommend that the draft order be approved.
Are you going to talk about the other order at the same time?
link
The two Scottish statutory instruments are completely different. They are not linked.
I understand that. We will take a decision on them later. I am happy to go to questions on both instruments, if you would like to do it that way, minister. I would be happy with that.
link
If we could deal with the first order first.
Let us keep it simple. I agree.Turning first to the concessionary travel one, I ask you to help me. The two concessionary fare schemes amount to about £468.6 million. The level 3 line for concessionary fares in the budget is £472.8 million, so there is a difference of about £4 million. Could you explain that to me?
The level of reimbursement is £468.6 million, as you say. The additional £3 million or £4 million will be related to the operational costs of running the scheme—not the actual reimbursement of operators, but the operational costs of administering the scheme itself.
That is £4 million.
Yes.
That seems quite a large figure, does it not? Who gets that £4 million? Is it bus operators, for running the scheme, on top of the tickets? I am now totally confused. I have never picked up, in 10 years of looking at such things, that there is a £4 million admin charge.Are you going to help me, Monica?
No—I might have misheard. Is this about the operational costs—the costs of running the scheme?
Yes.
So—
We have not had an answer yet. I am trying to work out who gets that £4 million.
On the reimbursement figure, which is the money that goes to the operators for carrying passengers on the scheme, there are additional costs for administering the scheme itself, to cover the staff who are involved in running the scheme, the concessionary travel products and the back-office systems that relate to paying operators. I do not know whether those costs total £4 million, but there is additional money in the budget to allow for those expenses, on top of the money that goes to operators for carrying passengers.
So, it goes to the operators for all the back-office-run things.
No—
If it does not go to the operators, does it go to the Government? Is it a Government expense, for all the civil servants running the scheme?
It is a Transport Scotland expense for running the scheme itself.
It seems quite a large sum.
This is an interesting place to start. The £4 million is effectively the cost of running the scheme, so that people can have their concessionary travel cards. Will that cover staffing costs?
Staffing costs will be part of it. I cannot confirm whether £4 million is the figure for this part of the scheme, but there is money allocated in the budget to allow for the expenses of running the scheme itself. So, yes—that covers the staff costs and the back-office costs of the system itself.
The minister perhaps knows the answer.
link
If the committee would like a breakdown of what that is, I will have officials send that on to the committee.
That would be jolly helpful, as £4 million seems quite a large amount of money. It would be nice to know where it is going.Sorry—please continue, Monica.
It is disappointing that we cannot get clarity on that just now, given that the minister is here with four officials.
link
That figure is 1 per cent of the cost of the entire scheme. It may sound like a large figure in its own right, but a hell of a lot of work goes on behind the scenes in administering the scheme. If the committee would like a proper breakdown of that sum, however, I would be more than happy to provide that if we can do so.
I think that that would be helpful. Percentage figures often hide the true cost. We are talking about £4 million. It might be only 1 per cent, but £4 million is £4 million of anyone’s money. It is a huge amount of money to me.
link
It would be helpful if the committee could compare like for like. It is probably not something to discuss this morning, but, when you come back to the committee, it would be helpful if we could have the values from previous budgets.Four million pounds is a sizeable amount, but we do not know whether that amount has gone up from £3 million in previous budgets, whether it has gone down or whether it is holding steady. The question relates more to the budget than to the statutory instrument that we are considering. However, it would be helpful to have that figure set in context.
Kevin Stewart might have some knowledge that can help us.
I would not say that I have knowledge, but the minister is correct in saying that 1 per cent is not a huge amount for the administration of any scheme. If most schemes were run with 1 per cent spent on admin costs, that would be good.The minister has agreed to send a breakdown to the committee. It would be useful for us to see every aspect of the administration cost, including for the scrutiny of the schemes, because some folk have questioned whether there could be abuses of the scheme by operators through ticketing and all the rest of it.When I was the minister for transport for a short period of time, I asked for a fair amount of scrutiny, to ensure that we were getting the best value for money. If we could have those breakdowns—including scrutiny of the 1 per cent—that would be wonderful.
Are you nodding at that, minister?
link
Yes.
I have a couple more questions, but Mark Ruskell also has one, so I will bring him in first.
link
Do 2.2 million people benefit from the two schemes?
link
Yes.
link
Okay. Well, £4 million seems like quite a low amount.I want to talk about the overall spend, though. We are looking at £472.8 million—half of the Scottish bus industry’s income. The industry says that the scheme is neither a benefit nor a disbenefit to it, but, when we see those figures, it is hard to see how it is not a massive benefit to the industry when substantial numbers of people travel by bus who would not do so were it not for the Government’s investment in the schemes, which is very welcome.How do we get more out of this? What about the conditionality for the bus companies? What about the linkage with investment in better bus services at either a community level or a regional level? What about the Government’s target for a vehicle mileage reduction? Are we getting the most out of the investment? Could we be hitting other public transport policy objectives by using the existence of the cards and the massive investment as a lever to get more bang for our buck?
link
The purpose of the order is to ensure that the scheme continues. I think that everyone on the committee agrees that it is a good scheme and that we want it to continue. It is helping to shape travel habits.As to whether it is giving us the best bang for our buck, the fair fares review said that we would review the scheme, so it will be for the next Parliament to consider that. You are right to say that it is a substantial amount of money, but it is an investment, and it is working for the people of Scotland.From the conversations that I have had—with younger people, in particular—I know that the scheme has given people access to education and employment and that it has allowed them to keep up with friends and family. The value to those who use the scheme is enormous.Is it doing enough to get more people out of their cars and using public transport? Is there more to be done on that? Are there other ways that we can use it? There are always different ways to look at it. I am quite sure that the next Parliament will look at the spend on the scheme and ask whether we are getting as much as we want out of it. Another Government might take a different view to the current one. We will just have to wait and see what the next Government says.
link
What does Transport Scotland think about it? Does it have any creative ideas as to how we could use that huge investment to get more people out of their cars? What is the offer for people out there? Are we linking this with travel planning for colleges, universities and workplaces? I do not know. As a transport policy, this has been fantastic, and it is a great initiative that supports individuals. However, when it comes to all the wider transport issues that we are really struggling with at the moment, how do we use this to drive modal shift? That is the key question. What do your officials have to say about that?11:00
link
This is only one aspect of the offering with regard to creating better public transport and better travel options. As members are well aware, huge amounts of money have gone into active travel, too. Is there more that we can do? Of course there is. There will always be more that we can do, and that review is on-going.Carole Stewart might want to say something about the bus infrastructure fund, the plugged-in communities grant fund and all the other things that we are doing to make bus travel an attractive option.
link
What about putting conditions on bus companies? If they benefit from this scheme, they should not be, say, cutting rural bus services. What about that kind of conditionality?
link
The condition in the particular scheme in this SSI is that companies will be left no better and no worse off. This is not seen as a direct benefit in terms of putting more people on buses; it is a no better, no worse approach, which is why the rate goes up or down slightly.
link
But we are talking about half the bus industry’s income. How can that be a no better, no worse approach? Would the industry miss it if this money disappeared?
link
That would very much depend on how many people continued to use the bus. A lot of people have no choice but to use the bus, and they would end up paying for it themselves. The people who would be hurt would be the passengers, not the bus companies.
link
Do your officials have any thoughts on conditionality?
It is something to look at in the next parliamentary session. A lot of different policy options could be explored with regard to improving bus services—for example, implementing the powers in the Transport (Scotland) Act 2019, putting in place specific provision to support rural services in other areas and linking the schemes with car reduction policies on a regional basis. A whole suite of policy options could sit alongside, or be integrated slightly better with, the concessionary travel schemes.
link
Thanks.I have one last question. I am aware that, at long last, a scheme has been put in place to extend concessionary bus travel to people trapped in the asylum system, who have no recourse to public funds and are effectively destitute. However, I believe that the current budget for the scheme will end on 31 March. Will the Government extend that provision into next year?
link
That would be a decision for the Cabinet, not for me.
Before I bring in Monica Lennon, I should, for clarity, declare what I think I declared at the previous meeting on this matter, which is that I am entitled to a free bus pass. I am sure that no one else on the committee has to worry about that, but I am over 60.On that note, I will move swiftly on to Monica Lennon.
I will make no such declaration, convener.Minister, I want to pick up on what you said about young people and those in education telling you that the scheme has been a game changer for them and that they really value it. As we know, the scheme is about opening up opportunities for young people, as well as changing behaviours; indeed, you said that it was habit forming. In the conversations that you are having, are you open to the scheme being expanded so that young people who go over the age of 22 but who are still in education and training can continue to benefit from it? At the moment, just as they have started to get used to the bus they no longer have the benefit of the card. Where do you sit on that issue?
link
Again, that will be part of the discussion on how the budget for the schemes is used and whether the next Parliament decides it wants to take such a decision. What we are discussing today is the SSI in front of us, which is about reimbursement rates. You are taking the conversation into the area of policy decisions that will be made by whoever forms the next Government.
Committees are always curious about ministers’ views. You have had these conversations with young people, and you have said that they are talking about the benefits of the scheme. We are exploring what more could be done in policy terms. Would the sort of extension that I have referred to be desirable, if the funding were available?
link
My view is that the scheme has been exceptionally successful. I am very proud of it, and I think that the Government should be very proud of the fact that it has brought it in. The next Government might decide to expand it, but that will be a decision for it.
Thank you.
Bob Doris and Douglas Lumsden have follow-up questions.
link
My question will be very brief, convener, because I feel that we are drifting somewhat from the instrument before us.I ask the minister to exercise a bit of caution in any initial thoughts on how we could better use that quantum of cash. We have already had a bid from Mr Ruskell, understandably, on conditionality on rural services, and from Ms Lennon on jobseekers and colleges. Once a young person no longer qualifies for concessionary travel, lots of other things will be put into the mix, including regionalised aspects of the cash that goes to bus companies in Strathclyde and other regions. Strathclyde currently has franchising, for example. Before we come to a decision, we could take stock, more generally, of that quantum of cash, and work in partnership with regional transport authorities—perhaps giving them a bit more power. I ask the minister to be slightly cautious and to carry out a wider review, without any preconceived outcomes.
link
I have no preconceived outcomes whatsoever. Carole Stewart talked eloquently about all the things that could be done differently if the next Government chooses to do them, but those are decisions for the next Government and the next session of Parliament.
How much does free bus travel for asylum seekers cost per year? Is it within the £468.8 million figure for next year? I assume that it is not, because you have not decided on it.
link
The asylum scheme is a pilot scheme. It is budgeted at £2 million, but, beyond that, those are budget questions that you would have to ask the cabinet secretary.
So that £468.8 million does not include asylum seeker travel.
People seeking asylum in Scotland who are already eligible for the national concessionary travel scheme on the basis that they are under 22, over 60 or have an eligible disability are included in that overall figure.
But all the others who are aged between 22 and 60 are not included in the £468.8 million figure. Is that correct?
That is the additional £2 million.
At present, it is not in the budget, so it would need to be added to the budget if the scheme were to continue past March. Is that correct, minister?
link
Yes.
Is there any evidence that concessionary travel for under-22s has reduced the demand on school transport? I am intrigued by whether there is any crossover there, because it might have an effect on school transport.
link
There has been anecdotal evidence that some local authorities—I will be careful how I word this—are encouraging the use of an under-22 pass as an alternative to having dedicated school transport. There is evidence that that is being done in some areas.
That might be something for the next Government and the next minister to look at.We move to The National Bus Travel Concession Schemes (Miscellaneous Amendment) (Scotland) Order 2026, which relates to the code of conduct. Minister, do you want to make a brief opening statement?
link
Okay. As we have discussed, the free bus travel provided by the national concessionary travel scheme is invaluable to those who use it—it provides life-changing benefits for many people. As the committee is aware, the legislation being introduced today is designed to protect those benefits by increasing safety on the bus network and ensuring that a small minority of cardholders who engage in antisocial behaviour are deterred from doing so. That policy has been asked for by members of the public, politicians and the bus sector itself.The legislation will allow access to concessionary travel to be suspended or withdrawn from anyone who breaches the code of conduct. It sets out appropriate behaviour for those travelling on the bus network who are using their entitlement to free bus travel. The code will explain the kinds of behaviours that might result in suspension of concessionary travel and will apply to all cardholders, regardless of age.A draft of the code has been shared with the committee to aid its scrutiny of the instrument. The definition of antisocial behaviour in section 143 of the Antisocial Behaviour etc (Scotland) Act 2004 is deliberately broad. That reflects the fact that the exhaustive list of behaviour considered antisocial by the Government would be unworkable and anomalous. For the same reason, the draft code of conduct does not include a comprehensive list of behaviours, but broadly outlines the behaviours that might have a significant impact on bus drivers or other passengers.Given the impact that the suspension might have on a cardholder, the code is designed to ensure that withdrawal or suspension of free travel is considered only by exception and that it is proportionate.To support enforcement of the code of conduct, officials are developing supporting policies relating to reporting, suspension and review of any decisions to suspend. I have provided a high-level written overview of what is being considered regarding these procedures, but we will continue our approach of close collaboration with stakeholders to finalise the procedures.Before I take questions, I want to be clear that our phased approach to implementation is appropriate and necessary. It is essential that we establish a fair and robust process that considers business impacts, child wellbeing and poverty considerations, data implications and options to phase in the policy to ensure that it is known to users, and that we address any operational issues. The instrument will secure the enabling power for the policy and send a clear message that antisocial behaviour on the bus network will not be tolerated. It will provide a strong foundation for Transport Scotland to continue the work with operators and partners—which strongly support the legislation—to finalise the supporting procedures.I am happy to take any questions. I move the motion and recommend that the draft order be approved.
You will get a chance to move the motion under the next item, so that is fine.I am looking round committee members to see whether anyone wants to ask questions on the draft order.
Keith Rollinson, a bus driver in Elgin, was killed in February 2024. When his killer is released, he will still be entitled to a free bus pass. Can you guarantee to us that, if Parliament approves the order, Keith Rollinson’s killer will not be allowed free travel on the buses again?
link
I am sorry, convener, but I cannot answer questions about individual cases.
Let us not make it about an individual case. Instead, let us assume that somebody who has killed a bus driver is due to be released. Will the order that we are being asked to approve stop the situation where the colleagues of the person who was killed are forced to take that killer back on board free of charge? Can you guarantee that approving the order will stop that situation?
link
The purpose of the order is to allow Transport Scotland to take actions to remove a bus pass from someone who is committing antisocial behaviour. I am not going to comment on the death of Mr Rollinson and I am not going to go any further with this conversation about him. I think that it is inappropriate and disrespectful. I am sorry, Mr Lumsden, but I am finding it really distasteful, because we are discussing an order that is about antisocial behaviour going forward, not about something that has happened in the past. I cannot give guarantees on anything in relation to Mr Rollinson’s position, and I would rather not discuss Mr Rollinson’s position.
Mr Lumsden, I will try to steer a way through this so that I can understand it myself.Minister, the draft code of conduct that you submitted with your letter says that acting“in a way that hurts or threatens others”could result in the loss of entitlement to free travel.Let us take a step back, if I may, minister. If somebody is hurt by a person who is entitled to concessionary travel, the person who did that would be in contravention of your draft code of conduct. Is that right?
link
Yes, they would be.
Right. Under this code of conduct, when the bus company or Police Scotland reports breaking of the rules, Transport Scotland has three options: do nothing; send the person a warning letter; or suspend their free travel.
link
Correct.
Could you confirm whether suspending free travel could be done for the entire duration of the concessionary pass if the hurt were sufficiently serious?
link
That decision will be made by Transport Scotland as it goes through the process. As stated in the letter that I sent you, Transport Scotland will go through all the procedures that you have just outlined and will give the person the chance to put their case on the incident. Subsequently, it will be for Transport Scotland to decide whether there should be a temporary or permanent removal of the entitlement to free travel.
Thank you for clarifying that. The word that I was looking for was “permanent”—that it could be a permanent removal if the offence were considered serious enough.
link
That would be an operational decision for Transport Scotland to make.11:15
I am not asking you to make the decision, I am trying to understand the draft code of conduct.I hand back to Douglas Lumsden. Do you have a further question to ask?
I do. If the antisocial behaviour happens in the bus station and not on the bus, I presume that the code of conduct would not apply and that there would be no basis to remove free travel from that person. Is that right?
link
This SSI is about during the transport, which is when they are on the bus.
Do you think that that scope is wide enough or should it be reviewed in the future?
link
The order that is currently in front of us is about what happens on the bus. If other antisocial behaviour issues need to be dealt with, Police Scotland and the criminal justice system will deal with them.
Can I just try to help with this? A lot of buses start from a central depot with a stance that the bus pulls into and then pulls away from. Are you saying that if the antisocial behaviour happened on the stance rather than on the bus, this order would not cover it?
link
No, it would not. It is about what happens during the travel.
It is purely about when the person puts their foot on the bus.
link
Yes.
So, for argument’s sake—and I do not foresee myself being in this position—if I were rude and abusive to everyone around me, including the bus driver and anyone else, before I got on the bus, would I not lose my concessionary travel?
link
No, you would not, because the instrument is about behaviour on the bus.
Okay. I am sorry to jump in, Douglas.
That is all—I just wanted that clarified, convener.
Members have lots of other questions. I will come to Mark Ruskell next.
link
To be honest, I am still struggling with this. The order does not prevent violent and abusive people from getting on to buses; it only means that their entitlement card will be suspended. They could quite easily walk on to a bus and pay a fare.I am trying to understand the relationship with the wider conditions of carriage, which apply to everybody who gets on a bus, regardless of whether they are a young person, disabled, an older person or whatever. Most bus companies—all the bus companies in Scotland, I think—have conditions of carriage and they all cover threatening, abusive, dangerous and unsafe behaviour. That seems like the nub of the problem that we are talking about.Minister, you say that this order is completely separate to any action that operators might take in relation to conditions of carriage.
link
Correct.
link
Surely the conditions of carriage are the central issue. It is about why certain people are allowed to travel on buses and yet, potentially, they will abuse people or be rude or abusive. How is the Government dealing with that issue? That is not about what age they are or whether they have a disability; it is about whether they should allowed on buses—full stop. I am struggling to see how this measure will deter anybody who is serious about abusing people and causing a nuisance on public transport. Do you see where I am coming from?
link
I see where you are coming from. I think that you are trying to use the ability to remove the bus pass as a cure for antisocial behaviour across society—but it is not. The order is about protecting people who are travelling on the buses. When they are travelling on the buses, if people are carrying out antisocial behaviour, a sanction can be placed on them and that should be used as a deterrent. I hope that very few people, if any, will have their passes removed from them, because the threat of the deterrent should be enough to make them behave in a way that is appropriate.A letter was received from the following representatives of bus companies: Sarah Boyd from Lothian Group; Duncan Cameron from First Bus Scotland; Colin Craig from West Coast Motors; Fiona Docherty from Stagecoach Ltd; Alistair Todd from Todd’s Travel; Simone Walsh from Scottish Citylink; Sandra Whitelaw from Whitelaws; and Tony Williamson from McGill’s. It said:“There have been queries as to why a national approach to this is required, rather than it being dealt with locally through our own Conditions of Carriage. We believe that as the Concessions Schemes are National Entitlements (rather than determined at the local level) they should be accompanied by a national standard of conduct and potential sanction.”The bus companies are asking the Parliament and the Government to do this for them, but that does not remove their ability to use their conditions of carriage.
link
Would a better approach not be to have national conditions of carriage that apply to everybody, and to look at ways of enforcing them? This committee received evidence from West Midlands Police, which has introduced a travel safe team on buses, as we are doing with ScotRail, to make sure that the buses there are safe.We have also had evidence to suggest that those who are perpetrating antisocial behaviour on buses are often males over the age of 22, who are not affected by the concessionary schemes because they are not eligible for them. I am trying to understand the Government’s national approach to enforcing conditions of carriage and making progress in that regard.Last week, the Cabinet Secretary for Justice and Home Affairs announced, in relation to the railways, 11 key actions that have been agreed with the unions to make our railways safer. I am just not seeing it with the approach that we are discussing. I am seeing the bus companies arguing for a restriction on the national entitlement card, but I do not see evidence that that will lead to any behaviour change whatsoever.Finally, I will ask about the consultation on the code of conduct. Clearly, bus companies have been calling for it to be brought in for a long time and have been part of those conversations. However, have you engaged with organisations that understand young people in particular, such as the Young Scot card operators and the Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland? How have they been involved? If you are talking about changing behaviours, it is really about getting inside people’s heads and thinking about motivations and how you turn the situation around. I am not seeing the involvement of the Scottish Youth Parliament or organisations that work with young people in the production of the code of conduct, but perhaps you will want to inform me otherwise.
link
There are a number of different points in there, so you will have to forgive me if I forget some of them. You will have to come back and remind me of the issues that you have raised.The removal of a pass will not solve all antisocial behaviour. You are absolutely right that there will be people over the age of 22 and under the age of 60 who commit antisocial behaviour, and those people will be dealt with through the conditions of carriage of the relevant bus company.Should we have national conditions of carriage? You might be able to do that if you had a national bus company, but we do not. We have individual private companies that have their own conditions of carriage. The concessionary travel scheme is a national scheme that is delivered by the Government through Transport Scotland, so the bus companies are asking for a national approach and conditions of carriage for the scheme itself. That is what they have asked us for.On how we change behaviour, we are dealing with a wide range of measures. Siobhian Brown has been carrying out work on antisocial behaviour. We will be engaging with education facilities to ensure that young people understand the conditions of the scheme, as well as with older and disabled people, so that they also understand the conditions of the scheme. They will be given that information when they are given their passes.We have engaged very widely, including with the Scottish Youth Parliament. We did not engage directly with the Young Scot card administrators before we announced that the order was being laid, but there has been a lot of engagement with young people themselves. The Scottish Youth Parliament asked for direct correspondence and engagement with Carole Stewart and her colleague. Carole sat down with the Scottish Youth Parliament to discuss what it meant for those young people.Some of the SYP members’ concerns were about how they felt on buses. We know that there is a wider societal issue of antisocial behaviour, and the removal of a bus pass will not solve all of that, but the SSI will allow us to have in place a deterrent, which has been asked for by the bus companies, by transport users and by the Parliament. That is what we are delivering.
link
Convener, I would like to ask a couple of specific questions about the code of conduct, if that is okay.
As long as you are brief.
link
The issue that I want to address is quite narrow compared with what is covered in the conditions of carriage. I know from talking to groups such as Engender that work to tackle violence against women and girls, that they would perhaps call for types of harassment to be specified in the code. At the moment, the code refers to “any kind of harassment”. It does not refer specifically to sexual harassment, which we know is a major issue for women and girls on public transport. I am curious about why the code makes a broad reference to harassment without specifying sexual harassment.The code also mentions indecent language, which I do not think is included in many of the operator conditions of carriage. I am thinking about how members of staff such as bus drivers will police that. What is considered indecent language? What kind of training will be available? It will not be members of the public who will report such instances; it will be hard-working bus drivers and other operatives who will have to make a judgment about whether someone has crossed the line.
link
You are asking why the code is not more specific.
link
That was the view that I got when I spoke to Engender about the issue in relation to violence against women and girls. It was surprised that sexual harassment is not spelled out in the code.
link
It should not have to be spelled out that violence against women and girls is not acceptable. We should tackle that issue at every opportunity and in every setting, not just on buses. It should not be considered only in the context of whether folk get a bus pass. The challenge that we face in tackling violence against women and girls is far broader than that.The code is laid out in broad terms in order to allow judgment to be exercised as to whether a pass should be removed. As we discussed with the convener, a determination will be made after the process has been gone through. In making that judgment, Transport Scotland will ask the person who has been reported what they believe the situation was. The decision will be made by Transport Scotland.As far as abusive, threatening or indecent language is concerned, that will be a judgment for Transport Scotland to make, because that is an operational issue.
link
It is also a judgment that bus drivers will have to make in compiling the evidence for various types of harassment and indecent language.What kind of national support or guidance will there be to ensure that, regardless of whether we are talking about buses in Aberdeen, Edinburgh or anywhere else, people will have a full understanding of what the code of conduct means and what evidence will need to be gathered? At a previous meeting, Sarah Boyack raised the issue of people who have Tourette’s syndrome. Would what they say be considered indecent language?
link
If someone uses indecent language and it is then discovered that they have Tourette’s as part of the process that is gone through to decide whether their bus pass should be removed, Transport Scotland will come to the appropriate conclusion. It is up to Transport Scotland to make such operational decisions.
Several members have follow-up questions.
In order for us to make a judgment on the instrument, we need to fully understand the Government’s intention. What I am not hearing clearly enough—I am giving you an opportunity to put this on the record so that people who are listening understand the Government’s position—is that the Government takes a zero-tolerance approach to not just antisocial behaviour but serious violence and abuse on Scotland’s buses.There are people at home and people at work who are frightened to go on a bus. To have a free bus pass or to be able to use Scotland’s buses is a privilege. If people do not respect that and do not have due regard for others, that puts other people at risk and, frankly, it keeps people off our public transport network. Is it the Government’s intention to be robust and to be straight with people who are the victims of crime in saying that the Government is on their side and has their back, rather than it just being a matter of the issue being considered by officials and every case being looked at individually?Colleagues have alluded to very serious crimes that have happened. Mark Ruskell is right to say that we must name crimes such as sexual assault and not just hide such incidents behind the language of antisocial behaviour.Does the minister agree with the points that I am making? On reflection, to people in Scotland who are behaving badly and who are engaging in criminality, is it clear that the measure that you have put forward today will cover the whole spectrum of behaviour? Does the minister recognise that, if we talk about antisocial behaviour, that sounds like behaviour at the lower end of the spectrum?11:30
link
You are talking about two different things. Is there zero tolerance of violence? Absolutely—of course there is and, in particular, there is zero tolerance of violence against women and girls. I would not be vague about that.
Where is the messaging on that? For anyone who is thinking about getting on a bus today or tomorrow and behaving in a way that is beyond the pale, where is the messaging from the Government that that is not acceptable?
link
Again, messaging goes beyond what the scheme is trying to do. The antisocial behaviour—
It is important to understand the policy intention. If the intention is zero tolerance of crime and—
link
Which is criminality.
Yes, so why are we just talking about antisocial behaviour?
link
We already have zero tolerance of criminality and the justiciary will go through the process to prosecute criminality. What we are talking about is antisocial behaviour, which is a different thing. If there is criminal behaviour, the police and other authorities carry out the processes that they have to carry out to deal with that. This is about giving Transport Scotland the ability to remove the entitlement to a bus pass if somebody is displaying antisocial behaviour, being foul and abusive, hurting someone physically or harassing people in any way.We are discussing two different things here. I absolutely agree, 100 per cent, that there is zero tolerance of violence; I could not agree more. However, that is not what this is. The direct result of somebody committing violence and then being convicted of a crime is, in all likelihood, that they will lose their use of a bus pass, but that would be incidental to the fact that they have been prosecuted for criminality.
You are saying “likelihood”. I do not know whether victims and families affected by crimes that have happened on buses feel that the Government fully has their back on this.
link
I disagree entirely with that.
Sorry—I want to try to help in this situation. I know that Monica feels passionately about this; that is very clear. If somebody commits a criminal offence outwith a bus, how will Transport Scotland know to remove the privilege—I agree with people who have described it as a privilege—of having concessionary travel? Transport Scotland will not know, will it, minister?
link
Your question is about when somebody commits an offence outside of a bus, but that is not what the SSI is—
I know. That is what I am trying to get at.
link
That is not what the SSI is designed to do. It is not designed to deal with antisocial behaviour across society.
However, if the offence is criminality on a bus, they will lose it.
link
I am not going to say what Transport Scotland’s decision would be, because Transport Scotland would have to go through the process. However, if somebody is carrying out criminality on a bus, my expectation is that Transport Scotland would go through the process, ensure that it is being robust and take the appropriate action.
Okay. Monica, I apologise if I have been unhelpful. I was trying to find something out. Back to you.
It is not about a personal passion of mine; it is about the perception out there in the country. There are many people, particularly women and girls and marginalised people, who do not feel safe on the bus. What I am getting at with the message of zero tolerance is not about us just talking about it in rooms such as this; it is about how the Government gets that message out there. With all the partners that you work with, minister, how will you get it out there loudly and clearly?We have to deal with the instrument that is in front of us. I have sat in rooms in the Parliament with the minister, cross-party colleagues, bus operators and the police when there has been a genuine request to the minister to act in an urgent manner. Sadly, I do not think that we have seen that today, but we are where we are.I want to ask about the right to review. If someone who has been told that they can no longer have their bus pass because of their conduct can ask for a review or an appeal, what criteria will Transport Scotland look at? In what situation could someone who is a violent killer or someone who has sexually assaulted women and girls on a bus be successful with that appeal?
link
First, I will push back on what Monica Lennon said to me, which is that the scheme was asked for urgently and that it has not been delivered well. It has been delivered as quickly as was possible. As we go through these conversations, the complexity of what is involved is quite clear—it is not simply a case of somebody being able to say, “I’m having your bus pass.” It is far more complex than that. Several issues must be considered, and it will take time to get it right. If we want speed, we can get it, and we will get a scheme that will not work in the way that it is expected to work, or we can ensure that it is done properly so that people get a full understanding of what it will do.Secondly, on the question that you have asked about the reviews, those will be an operational decision for Transport Scotland, which will work with partners—including operators and the young and older people who will be affected by the scheme—to work out the appropriate results. Those partners will look at the operational aspects in order to get the process to where it needs to be. The SSI is about giving the power to be able to do so, and it is not unusual for us in the Parliament to work through the guidance and policy development with the partners that will be on the ground doing it.
I must come back in. I will try to keep my remarks short. I am listening carefully, minister, but every time that you are asked for clarification, you seem to delegate that answer somewhere else. The Parliament will want to know what we are being asked to support, both today and when the matter goes to the Parliament. I will not mention individual cases, but members of the Parliament will have in their minds cases of very serious violence and sexual assault, and other cases, in their constituencies or regions. However, you are not able to tell the Parliament what your intention is.You are the minister, you have the responsibility and a lot of influence here, but you do not know what criteria would be available or when it would be acceptable for someone who has sexually assaulted a passenger or a bus driver to retain a bus pass or win an appeal. It seems that you have no view on that and are happy to leave the matter to others to decide on in the future.
link
I am sorry, but you are mischaracterising what I have said—
So, you do have a view. Will you please tell us what it is?
link
It is not about whether I have a view. It is about the process that we are putting in place and about the fact that the Parliament and stakeholders are asking us to put an SSI in place to allow the Government and Transport Scotland to go through a process to remove somebody’s right to have free bus travel.I am afraid that you are completely mischaracterising what has been discussed, which is unfortunate, because I hoped that, given that it has been a demand from the entire Parliament, we would get to the point at which the SSI gets passed.
This is called scrutiny. In what situation, minister, do you think that it is okay that someone who has seriously harmed a passenger or a bus driver should be allowed to retain their free bus pass or win an appeal to get it back? Please tell me in what circumstance that is okay.
link
We have already discussed that. If an incident takes place on a bus, Transport Scotland will scrutinise that in conjunction with the discussions that it has had with stakeholders about whether it is appropriate to remove a bus pass. We will not sit here and give a prescriptive list.I have also said that the instrument is deliberately broad to allow the proper scrutiny by Transport Scotland, in its wisdom, to decide whether the pass should be removed.
As you have designed the instrument, there will be discretion for civil servants to decide that someone who has committed a serious crime and caused harm to others would be able to continue to use the bus with a concessionary travel card.
link
That is not what we have done; again, you are mischaracterising what has been said. The draft code of conduct is quite clear that someone could lose their pass if they“act in a way that hurts or threatens others.”It includes some examples of that, such as hurting someone physically, which is a criminal act; using abusive, threatening or indecent language; any kind of harassment, such as racial abuse; and how it would be decided that it is antisocial behaviour. Mark Ruskell asked what would happen if someone was using indecent language and they have Tourette’s. Transport Scotland officials will have to look at that before any decision is made about whether to remove the individual’s bus pass. Those decisions would have to be made on an individual basis.More importantly, I very much hope that the code will act as a deterrent and that it will not be a normal process to remove someone’s bus pass. It is about antisocial behaviour on buses; it will not solve the criminal justice system across Scotland.
I will hand back to the convener, but it is unfortunate that the minister has been extremely vague. We are designing a process that could allow for any number of outcomes. I am asking the minister not to get drawn into individual cases, but whether it is his intention that someone who has committed a serious crime on a bus or has displayed antisocial behaviour could retain their right to use their bus pass. He cannot rule that out. I feel that it is a straightforward question.
We have taken it round the houses and I am not sure that we have got any further or that you have received a satisfactory answer. I have to move on to other questions; I apologise, Monica.
Good morning. I want to step back from the exchange with Monica Lennon and deal with the process. If an individual committed an offence on the bus, what evidential threshold would be used for determining any decision to remove their bus pass?
link
Again, that will have to be worked through with Transport Scotland’s officials and stakeholders, and it would have to be done on an individual basis, because there is a huge amount of complexity in this area. I cannot tell you what the exact threshold will be, because it would have to be worked out individually.
I am not asking for the exact threshold. I presume that the decision would be made on
the balance of probabilities, rather than a requirement that the evidence was beyond reasonable doubt. I am trying to establish the evidential threshold.It would be a civil matter, not a criminal matter and, therefore, I presume that the threshold would be the balance of probabilities. A criminal matter in the courts has to be proven beyond reasonable doubt but, obviously, a court of law will not be determining those matters.
link
As I said in my opening exchange with the convener, 95 per cent of buses in Scotland now have closed-circuit television. There will be reports from the driver and potentially other passengers. When a report is made, the evidence will be presented to Transport Scotland’s officials, who will go through the process to work out whether or not the balance has been crossed that would allow someone’s pass to be taken away from them.
I will ask the lawyer who is at the meeting. Kelly Minio-Paluello, what threshold is intended for the scheme to operate?
As you said, it would not be a criminal matter, so there would not be a requirement to have that evidential basis. Transport Scotland, in consultation with stakeholders, is working through a proper, fair and accountable process.
So, decisions would be made on the balance of probabilities
There is no requirement—
If it the threshold was going to be beyond reasonable doubt, you would have to call witnesses—
There is no requirement for a matter to be proven beyond reasonable doubt, as it is not the same process as for criminal matters.
If there was that requirement, you would have to be calling witnesses, et cetera, so decisions will have to be made on the balance of probabilities. Surely, that is the settled position.That means that, if someone commits an offence on a bus and they are subsequently convicted for it in a criminal court, they will lose their pass. It does not matter what the offence is. As soon as that person is convicted, they will have been convicted on a higher threshold than is required for the removal of their bus pass. It seems to me that, if someone commits a serious offence on a bus and they are convicted of it, they will lose their pass—without a doubt.
link
And I have said that that would be my expectation, but it will not be a ministerial decision.11:45
I understand that—I am not asking whose decision it is. I am just trying to establish the point that there has to be an evidential threshold, and that that evidential threshold has to be the balance of probabilities. Indeed, I cannot see how you can do it any other way, unless you are going to set up a court of law just to deal with bus passes. If someone commits an offence on a bus, and they are subsequently convicted of it in a criminal court, their bus pass will go, because they will have exceeded the threshold that would justify its removal. We should be clear about that, and I think that that deals with the question whether someone who commits a sexual offence on a bus and is convicted of it will have their bus pass removed. Of course, that will have to be referred into the system for it to be initiated.That brings me on to my next question, which is about the review mechanism involved. I presume that these matters will go back into Transport Scotland for review, but I also presume—and I appreciate that you might not have the detail of this yet—that any decision maker reviewing a matter would be outwith the original decision-making process, either in a different part of Transport Scotland, the Government or elsewhere. I presume that the intention is to separate that decision-making process and the individuals involved in the previous decision-making process.
link
I can absolutely tell you that the first part of what you have asked about—the review process—is still being developed. Carole Stewart works at that more operational level, so she might something further to add on whether the person involved will be independent of the first decision that was made.
The review process would require a further independent review of the decision that was taken and the length, or duration, of the suspension or withdrawal of the card.
So, an independent person would review the matter.
Yes, they will be separate from those involved in the first decision.
What exactly will the individual whose bus pass is potentially being removed receive? They will receive notification from Transport Scotland, but will they also receive details of the evidence that has been submitted by either the bus company or the police in support of the removal of the bus pass, so that, when they respond to any application, they will understand the details of what they are responding to?
Yes. A letter will be issued to the person subject to a suspension process, setting out a summary of the situation, the decision that has been taken and the process for requesting a review of that decision.
link
Good morning, again, minister—it is just about morning still.Those were really interesting and important exchanges that you have had with Monica Lennon and the deputy convener, and I have written down the phrase “independent from ministerial decision making”. You were asked to make some quite specific judgment calls by Douglas Lumsden with regard to instances in which a bus pass might be removed, and you were then asked to confirm the removal of a bus pass in respect of some quite disturbing crimes.I felt that, during those exchanges, the point that you were trying to make, without actually spelling it out, was that you could not confirm those things, because that would mean waiving your commitment to ensuring that the decision making of Transport Scotland was independent from ministerial interference. It would be helpful if you could say whether that was or was not the case.
link
You have put it far more eloquently than I did. Yes, those are not ministerial decisions; they will be operational decisions for Transport Scotland.
link
I think that that was helpful. The exchanges were important, but I just wanted to bottom that out and get it clarified.On balance, I welcome the rather broad nature of the code of conduct. Again, it was important to hear about specific examples of unacceptable behaviour that could be put into it, but I was left thinking that, as soon as we start to list types of unacceptable behaviour against certain groups, one group is going to be missed out. If you are a disabled person, and that is not covered by the list, or if you have another protected characteristic that is not on the list, some issues might arise in that respect. Therefore, it is right to keep the code broad.In order to operationalise the changes, will guidance be produced to support Transport Scotland in making decisions in cases that might involve gender-based violence, abuse, ableism or similar issues? Can you tell us a bit more about the guidance that would support such decision making?
link
What I was trying to say earlier is that there will be very wide engagement on the operational side of the issue. Those discussions with Transport Scotland will cover a very broad spectrum of things, so that we have the fullest understanding of how the changes can be implemented. The issue is complex, and a number of people have made the very simplified demand that we should just get the bus passes off them, but it is not that easy. There is a lot of complexity to consider.Carole Stewart and her colleagues will take time to work through it all. Making the changes is taking so much time because we need to work our way through all those things and ensure that we understand people’s positions and put in place proper guidance.
link
To push a bit further on the idea of guidance, I will give an example of a theoretical instance—one that, unfortunately, will occur in practice—in which a racial slur is used and which, in context, is clearly intimidating and designed to hurt and offend an individual. It might be considered harassment and offensive under the broad code of conduct, but the offence will not be written down on a list anywhere—that is the point that Ms Lennon made. Will the guidance be expanded a little further—without a definitive list being produced—to give examples of incidents that could be subject to action?
link
Carole Stewart will be working on that. Where will you take the guidance from there, Carole?
We will produce guidance for the 2.4 million scheme users. We will also produce guidance for, and provide support to, bus operators and ensure that bus drivers are trained to understand the policy and processes. Within Transport Scotland, we will also develop a decision-making framework to help guide decisions.It is perfectly possible to use some example scenarios in the guidance for passengers and operators in order to indicate how a particular incident would be dealt with under the procedures and what its outcome would be through the review process. It would be helpful to use examples.
link
Okay—that gives a degree of reassurance.Earlier, Mr Ruskell raised conditions of carriage. In a previous session, I remember that I told you, minister, about having read First Bus’s conditions of carriage. I will not repeat the contents, but I wonder whether the argument is a bit of a red herring. In my experience as a constituency MSP dealing with antisocial behaviour on buses, I rarely have discussions about conditions of carriage.First Bus has been excellent in relation to routes where there could be issues, and a bit of good-quality driver training and driver continuity—so that the same drivers are on the same routes consistently, are experienced, and know what to expect and how to handle it—has made a real difference. First Bus has also delivered good driver training and built good partnerships with Police Scotland and with local organisations in an area where there could be pinch points and specific localised issues with antisocial behaviour. There are key risk times in the day and night when antisocial behaviour is most likely to flare up, and improvements could be made in key areas in order to deal with such behaviour at bus stops, but at no point do we say, “Let’s get the conditions of carriage out.”The reason that I put that on the record is that this is fundamentally about sharing best practice—reflecting Mr Ruskell’s important point about how we deter antisocial behaviour, which is not age-specific—and about how bus companies and local partners can do so to reduce and tackle antisocial behaviour in ways that go beyond simply withdrawing the bus pass. Withdrawing passes is important, but the issue is also the wider environment. Is there any on-going work on that?
Yes. We have a bus antisocial behaviour stakeholder group run by the Confederation of Passenger Transport. We have had discussions around strengthening operators’ conditions of carriage and on the potential for the code of conduct and the power contained in the SSI to be incorporated in those conditions of carriage.Those in the bus industry are not just working with us on the SSI and the suspension procedure in isolation; they do a lot of work in communities. They go out to schools and provide information on using buses safely and responsibly. They try to build up relationships between bus drivers, bus operators and people on their regular routes.We are also in discussion with operators on enhanced communication around safety and zero tolerance of antisocial behaviour on buses. The conditions of carriage and the suspension process are not the only policy or mechanism that we are working with; there is a package of measures to try and make things better.
link
That is helpful. I just wanted to get the point on the record. On the idea of looking through the conditions of carriage in minute detail, the minister said in the previous evidence session that that is not how we tackle antisocial behaviour and emphasised a wider approach. Mr Ruskell will probably agree here. I believe that the power to withdraw bus passes in a structured and considered fashion should be afforded to Transport Scotland.Colleagues have spoken about concerns that the measures must be specific to conduct on a bus. I think that, because of the complexities at play here, that has to be the case, as a starting point. Without setting the hares running, minister, could you envisage a case in a few months’ time or a few years’ time where it is clear that there are hotspots at bus stations and bus stops where a group of people with national concessionary cards are congregating? They could be of any age—they could be older or younger; it is not always young people—and they may be causing a disturbance when seeking to board a bus or after disembarking from a bus. Could some discretionary powers be afforded in the future to consider withdrawing concessionary entitlement in a more considered fashion?
link
That would be for the Parliament to decide in the next session. There is a lot of on-going work around antisocial behaviour that should tackle those things. There is on-going work with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities, Police Scotland the bus companies on hotspots. If there are hotspots, they will be known to the local communities. There is on-going work on that, and there is an independent working group. I think that five recommendations came out of that work on antisocial behaviour—not on buses, but on antisocial behaviour in general.This is a problem that we need to tackle more widely, but the SSI is specifically about action that we can take on people who are using their bus pass and committing antisocial behaviour while they are using that pass.
Kevin, we will come to you next. I will then give Mark Ruskell one question, Monica Lennon one question and me one question—I am limiting myself to the same as you two.
Much of what I was going to ask, which was on evidential thresholds, has been covered by the deputy convener. That questioning has nailed that point, I think.Minister, you are a sensible man—you are a man of common sense, I would say—but you are dealing with an order that is bus related only. I think that we get that. A huge amount of other issues have been raised today that are not dealt with by the order before us and that could never be captured by it, in my humble opinion. However, you can see the strength of feeling in the room. I am quite sure that you will undertake to relay that strength of feeling to justice colleagues in particular. It may well be that the Crown and the judiciary need to consider sentencing, if possible, to remove bus passes.I have a simple question. Will you relay to justice colleagues some of the strength of feeling that has been expressed today? Will you talk to them and ask them to speak to the Crown and the judiciary to find out whether anything else would be required to remove bus passes from folks who are committing antisocial and criminal acts outwith buses?12:00
link
I absolutely give that commitment, and I have already agreed to meet Ms Constance about the issues that we are discussing. I am in no doubt about the strength of feeling that is in the room regarding the antisocial behaviour that is being experienced across society. It is not my intention to diminish anything that anyone has said or for it to come across that I am doing that, because I get all the issues that have been raised. However, the order will not deal with those issues, because there are wider societal problems that we need to deal with.I will take on board the specific point about whether sentencing should include the removal of bus passes, and I will raise it with the Cabinet Secretary for Justice and Home Affairs—I have a meeting with her later on to discuss what we are discussing in this meeting.In no way would I diminish any of the points that have been made today, and I take them all on board.
In those discussions, it might be found that the removal of bus passes in such cases would require further legislative change that is outwith your remit. However, thank you for that commitment.
Mark Ruskell, please make your question short.
link
The code of conduct that is in front of us was published in January 2026. I am interested in how it will develop over time, and I am also interested in how many cases Transport Scotland will deal with every year based on the code of conduct. There is a franchise of 2.3 million people who have concessionary cards. Would you expect the number of cases to be about a couple of hundred, a couple of thousand or more than 10,000?We have heard today that the whole process of reviewing evidence, making a judgment and allowing appeals from cardholders could be quite time consuming. I am trying to understand what the numbers would likely be. It could be that a whole department would need to be set up to independently review the cases that come forward, particularly if the code of conduct includes—as in the current draft—reference to “indecent language” on buses, because that could involve huge numbers of people.
link
Are you effectively asking me whether we have done any modelling on how many bus passes will be removed as a result of the code of conduct?
link
Yes.
link
We have not done any modelling on the number of passes that would be removed. As I said, there is a lot of complexity involved in this issue. Officials will go through the operational process of working out what removing bus passes would mean.
We have had many discussions with Transport for London, which runs a similar suspension and withdrawal scheme for its Zip Oyster concessionary card, which applies to 11 to 15-year-olds in London. There are about three times more passengers who use our national concessionary travel scheme than use the London scheme, and there is one full-time member of staff in London.
link
Is that for the 11 to 15 scheme?
Yes. I am just giving those figures as a baseline to start with. However, we do not know how many cases will come through until we try withdrawing passes. Our national concessionary travel schemes are quite unique in their scale and scope, so we will need to see how withdrawing passes will work when we begin to operationalise it.
There you go, Mark—that was your one question. The next question is from Monica Lennon.
Given the serious nature of some of the questions about serious types of crime and antisocial behaviour that have been asked in this meeting, it is regrettable that there has been a lot of mansplaining at the committee today. Two former transport ministers have come to your rescue to some extent, minister.I tried earlier to get clarity on the Government’s policy intention. I understand the scope of the statutory instrument and I understand what the Parliament will be asked to vote on. However, as someone who has sat in a room in this Parliament with you, minister, and with other stakeholders who want urgent action taken to reduce and tackle violence on our buses, I am asking about the Scottish Government’s position and your position as the minister. I am not asking what you will do about wider societal violence or gender-based violence; my question is about buses. You have now been asked about holding discussions with justice colleagues on what could be done through sentencing. My question is whether, before getting to this point today, the Scottish Government considered what other action could be taken to provide for a situation in which violent criminals who have committed crimes on buses in Scotland would face the automatic removal of their bus pass—that is, would lose the privilege of having one. Was that considered? If so, why was it dismissed as an action that could be taken during this parliamentary session?
link
I do not believe that it was considered as a stand-alone thing. I believe that we took the findings from the round tables and the discussions that we had with various stakeholders and decided to look overall at the removal of bus passes in the case of antisocial behaviour. No specific thinking was done about criminality and the automatic removal of a bus pass. That is my understanding, unless Carole Stewart can tell me something different.
I think that your official is nodding in agreement with you. That is a clear answer, so I thank you, minister.
I will reiterate a question that came up the last time that you brought the draft instrument to the committee, minister. It relates to children who use their bus pass to get to school and might, if the concessionary aspect was removed, have no ability to get to school. What thought have you given to that since our meeting some three weeks ago?
link
We discussed that, but I reiterate that children who use their bus pass to get to school have a right to get to school via the local authority. Those are two different issues. However, the operational aspect of the code of conduct will look at all the reasons for, and implications of, the removal of a bus pass. We would rather that it be used as a deterrent, so that it does not happen. However, if it does happen, the young person will have a right to get travel from their local authority if they live beyond 3 miles away from their school. The two schemes are not the same and should never be regarded as such.
That is all our questions on both instruments.We now move to agenda item 4, which is a debate on motion S6M-20454, which calls on the committee to recommend that the draft National Bus Travel Concession Schemes (Miscellaneous Amendment) (Scotland) (No 2) Order 2026 be approved. For 100 per cent clarity, I note that this is the order that relates to the money for concessionary travel—the names of the two instruments are very close.I call the minister to speak to and move the motion.
link
I have nothing further to add, convener.Motion moved,That the Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee recommends that the National Bus Travel Concession Schemes (Miscellaneous Amendment) (Scotland) (No. 2) Order 2026 draft be approved.—Jim Fairlie
I invite contributions, including just statements, from members.Minister, as no one wants to speak, I now invite you to sum up and respond to the debate—although as there has not been a debate, you may just want to conclude.
link
I will conclude.Motion agreed to.
I invite the committee to delegate authority to me as convener to approve a draft report for publication.Members indicated agreement.
Item 5 is a debate on motion S6M-20799, which calls the committee to recommend that the draft National Bus Travel Concession Schemes (Miscellaneous Amendment) (Scotland) Order 2026 be approved. The order relates to concessionary travel and the removal of passes.Motion moved,That the Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee recommends that the National Bus Travel Concession Schemes (Miscellaneous Amendment) (Scotland) Order 2026 draft be approved.—Jim Fairlie
Does anyone want to say anything?
I will be brief. I fully support the order, but I must say that I have been disappointed by some of the minister’s answers. We all agree, I think, that if somebody does something criminal, losing their pass should be automatic. However, I have slight issues over the clarity of the situation when it comes to people getting that pass back.Today, I raised the case of a 16-year-old who killed a bus driver in Elgin. When they are released, they will still be under 22 and entitled to free bus travel. The minister should have been able to say that that individual would not have the privilege of that entitlement returned. The order, which we are being asked to recommend approval of today, should allow that to happen. I feel for the driver’s colleagues, who will probably have to see that individual again and take them on their bus, and for the driver's widow. It should have been easy to say that Keith Rollinson’s killer would not get that free entitlement again, and it is disappointing that the minister has not been able to rule out their getting their pass back today.
I will support the order today, because I recognise the broad aims that the minister has set out. I would have liked to hear more clarity about how the order will work operationally and what criteria will be considered for reviews or appeals. We got there towards the end, but I am disappointed by the missed opportunity to take further action. It sounds as if the issue should have been discussed more closely with the Cabinet Secretary for Justice and Home Affairs, who the minister is to meet.We have heard about what could happen in the next parliamentary session, but the issues have been discussed in the Parliament over the past couple of years, with strong interest from different parties and from lots of stakeholders. I feel that lots of victims and families will feel disappointed today.
link
I would like to understand what opportunity you think has been missed in terms of what we are trying to achieve with the order. I have not, in any way, tried to minimise the points that you have made during the discussion. The order has the specific function of removing, for antisocial behaviour on buses, passes from people who are entitled to them. There is massive complexity even within that, which is why it is taking time. I accept that the issue has been discussed for a number of years. However, proper and thorough investigation is still required as to whether it is the right thing to do, and, if so, how to do it. That is why we are here now.I am curious, and this is not a gotcha question: what is the missed opportunity here, and what would you rather see going forward?
I hope that I have been clear with the committee and the minister that I will support the order today, because it is the option that is in front of us and to delay action on it would not be the right thing to do. However, for the benefit of the record, I am saying that the Government has missed the opportunity to take more robust action to address the issues that Douglas Lumsden raised.I will not go into individual cases, but I have put to the minister today that, where it is very clear that individuals have perpetrated extreme violence or sexual assault on a bus, they should not be allowed the privilege of a free bus pass. I think that it is within the gift of the Scottish Government to have such a view, to state such a position, to take legal advice and to work across Government to get the right people around the table. I also feel that the meeting with the justice secretary has come a bit late in the process.I will vote for the motion today, but I would have preferred to see a much more robust package of measures from the Government to target these most serious crimes, so that, where they are committed, the victims and the survivors can see that Government is respectful of their feelings.12:15
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportNo recorded division on these motions that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.
In this meeting
Everything on 17 Feb 2026 →- 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 09:00 NatureScot (Annual Report and Accounts and Future Priorities) Evidence session · 204
- 09:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 216
- 09:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 42
- 09:00 Correction Committee business · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.