The First Minister has taken his attempts to establish a relationship with Donald Trump all the way to the Oval office, yet he still has nothing to show for it. Scots law has been breached by the US military, which clearly could not give a damn about the UK’s sovereignty or the laws of this country. The cabinet secretary could not even answer my question about whether the Government actually believes that the current US Administration shares our values.
I have to say that, although there was a lot that I found that I could agree with in speeches by other SNP members, the cabinet secretary’s speech could have been made by a unionist. That was what I took from it. He was entirely factually wrong when he said that the only party that can make a decision about flights in and out of these airports is the UK Government, because, despite the fact that the UK Government is a supporter of Israel, Prestwick airport has already banned Israeli military flights. That means that there is a precedent for what we are asking for. Our proposal is based on the risk of international law being breached, and there is no doubt that the US is also a state that is in breach of international law.
I have found it surreal in this debate to hear British unionist colleagues defend a foreign military breaching the sovereignty of the UK. It was surreal to hear from colleagues who talk a lot in this chamber about the rule of law and the importance of law and order in this country, but who seem to be quite happy that there was absolutely no respect for the rule of law when it came to the abduction of the two individuals from that tanker in our waters—two individuals who were subject to our jurisdiction. That is not just subservience to Westminster, but subservience to the White House, which I find absolutely bizarre.
A lot was said by many members about Russia’s war on Ukraine. I will again quote Professor Phillips O’Brien, because I know that many members in this chamber of various persuasions have a huge amount of respect for him. He said:
“People need to understand what happened strategically in 2025. The US switched sides, helped Putin a great deal”.
That is the state that is using an airport that this Government owns as a de facto military base for more than 500 flights in the past year—a state that has, for all intents and purposes, switched sides.
Alex Cole-Hamilton made a number of fair points about the shadow fleet. Like a handful of other MSPs, I have been sanctioned by the Kremlin specifically for my campaigning to get the shadow fleet shut down and to end its operations in the UK, including here in Scotland. Again, the issue comes back to the point that Murdo Fraser made about other countries. The Greens do not pick and choose when we believe that international law should be respected or when we believe that human rights should be respected. We believe that every nation should uphold international law and respect human rights. In particular, we should hold our allies to a higher standard than our opponents. If the US is an ally of the UK, why do we not hold it to the same standard that we should apparently hold ourselves to?
Some people in this Parliament are happy to excuse any behaviour and any breach of not just international law but our domestic Scots law for the sake of economic benefits, but I ask them whether they would still take that position if the US had followed through on its threats against Greenland and if Prestwick, Wick or Benbecula had been used as staging points for military operations against one of our other NATO allies. I do not think that they would be saying that; I imagine that they would be saying very little out of shame at the position that they had previously taken.
What I find frustrating is that the Scottish Government knows that this is wrong. I do not expect my Tory or Labour colleagues to say anything different to what they have said, but Scottish Government colleagues know that what is going on is wrong, so I genuinely cannot understand this utterly subservient behaviour.
With regard to what unionist colleagues have said, I note that Murdo Fraser is a lawyer. I would have thought that he would have had respect for the rule of law, but, just a matter of weeks ago, the US military breached Scots law, breached an order of the Court of Session, disrespected our Lord Advocate and breached UK sovereignty, and the Tories did not even turn up to hear about it. They had nothing to say about one of the most significant breaches of Scots law in decades.
Neil Bibby said that foreign militaries must abide by our law, but, once again, just a matter of weeks ago, a foreign military breached our law and the Labour Party had nothing to say about it—there was not even a suggestion that there should be any consequences for that. I simply cannot understand this behaviour. It stinks. It reeks of double standards.
I would call on SNP colleagues to reconsider their positions. We have heard unionists this afternoon deny the legitimacy of even debating the operations of an airport that an SNP Scottish Government owns. That is totally unacceptable, but it is what we have come to expect from our unionist colleagues. SNP colleagues, however, should take the opportunity to stand up for Scotland, Scots law and international law. So much of what they said during the debate about the actions of Trump’s Administration was absolutely correct. What should the consequences be? What is our moral obligation when our ally uses our assets to breach international law, abuse human rights and rob people of due process within our territory? What should be the consequences of such behaviour?
The Scottish Government has the opportunity to stand with the Greens today, to stand up for Scotland and to show the Trump Administration that there are consequences to breaching not just international law but Scots law. Any Government that claims to stand up for Scotland should take that action, to show that there are consequences and to respect not just the sovereignty of the UK as a whole but Scots law and the importance that this Parliament places on it.