I thank colleagues hugely for their constructive comments on part 1 of the bill. I truly believe that this debate shows how the Parliament can work. I am also grateful for the suggestions for improvements to the bill that members have made, and I reiterate the request that I made at the beginning of the debate to members who have suggestions. My door remains open and I will work collaboratively with them.
The bill was born from cross-chamber concerns, and it should benefit from cross-chamber input from all parties. I will respond to a few of the points that have been made in the debate and, assuming that we get support for the bill at decision time, I would like to continue these discussions in the lead-up to stage 2.
I am grateful to everyone who raised the issue of the impact on businesses, and I hope that it was clear from my earlier comments that I do not take the impact lightly. I am very happy to explore ways in which businesses can access help to adapt their models before the bill comes into force. I repeat what I said to the committee: I currently propose to commence the offences in the bill in September 2027, giving a reasonable lead-in time to all concerned. However, I cannot support any measures that would dilute the key safety measures of the bill, and I remain mindful of the support that the bill has received so far and of the feedback from some stakeholders that we should go further.
I want to be clear: the bill will make procedures safer for everyone. It will ensure that procedures take place in appropriate and hygienic settings where healthcare professionals are involved in the provision or management of services and can assist if there are complications. The bill followed a consultation that was carried out in 2020, which found that 98 per cent of respondents supported the principle of further regulation of procedures that are led by those who are not qualified healthcare professionals. A further public consultation that was undertaken in early 2025 showed broad support for action to make the sector safer; it allowed us to refine our proposals, the result of which is included in the bill.
A number of members made the point that the public think that non-surgical procedures are already regulated in some way, and what Katy Clark, Clare Haughey and other members said about ensuring that we get information out there about that is incredibly important.
Throughout the bill process, we have worked with a range of stakeholders, including business owners, beauty industry representatives, healthcare professionals, environmental health officers—that is really important—and professional regulators, to develop and refine our process.
In response to Maurice Golden’s points, I note that there are some skilled non-medical practitioners who are trained in this space. However, in order to ensure safety, those skills need to be complemented by the skills that healthcare professionals bring. I have asked my officials to consider the HIS regulation of independent clinics and to ensure that the existing requirements are not disproportionate.
That brings me to the issue of training and supervision. The importance of training and of the requirements for supervision in a setting were clear from the contribution of the convener of the Health, Social Care and Sport Committee, and in the contributions of Carol Mochan and others. In evidence to the committee, I set out why we were not able to put such provisions in the bill. I am committed to the principle that, as well as the provisions in the bill, we need to have standards for training and to set expectations for the oversight and supervision of procedures. Training standards will be established following consultation with those who have to meet them, with experts and training providers and with the UK Government, so that we can take a consistent approach.
The Scottish Government has met many healthcare professionals and non-healthcare aesthetic practitioners and has listened to their views, including on training standards. We know that there are existing training options for practitioners, which we will consider carefully. As Colin Beattie noted, I have written to my counterparts in the UK Government to secure formal agreement to co-operate on some of those matters.
I note the points that were made about implementing a route map and about a public information campaign. I am content to review those further.
Many members highlighted the issue of penalties. Following the committee’s report, I understand why people are looking at that issue. For the time being, I reassure members that that message has been heard clearly. I will consider how we can go further and I would welcome any specific recommendations on an appropriate level of penalty.
Stuart McMillan commented on rural businesses. As an MSP for a rural constituency, I recognise very well the particular challenges for businesses in rural areas. On the other hand, it is important that we have balance to ensure that people in rural areas are as well protected as their urban counterparts. Yesterday afternoon, I met a group of practitioners from rural constituencies. I will consider their concerns and suggestions and I am happy to discuss the issue further with members.
Dr Gulhane referred to the capacity of Healthcare Improvement Scotland to take on new areas of work. My view remains that HIS is the correct regulator for these procedures, building on its experience to date of regulating independent healthcare. I am sure that HIS staff will have taken note of the comments about capacity and current working practices. As Stuart McMillan noted, I am committed to working with HIS to ensure that it can meet all our expectations.
I turn to Colin Beattie’s suggestion for a new professional body in the sector. I know that there are existing groups and I would welcome greater levels of organisation that would allow practitioners to speak with one voice and help to support safer standards. The Scottish Government would certainly be happy to work with such a body.
All the issues that have been raised this afternoon have been carefully considered. I will examine further the comments that have been made and the recommendations that were made by the committee. I reiterate that I am happy to work with members on potential amendments that could strengthen the bill and I look forward to doing so.
On the principles of part 1 of the bill, I return to the committee’s report. Intervention to regulate a growing and changing sector is not easy and I am committed to doing the work to make the right decisions in the coming weeks. I agree with the committee’s view, which has also been stated in the chamber this afternoon, that public safety must be the primary priority. That will be my main consideration.
I am aware that, for understandable reasons, part 2 of the bill has not received as much attention as part 1. Nonetheless, I remain grateful for the interest in that important issue. The provisions in part 2 reaffirm our commitment to ensuring clarity, transparency and public confidence in the death certification system. They will strengthen the safeguards that support families and professionals and ensure that our legislation reflects the robust checks that are already in place.
I urge the Parliament to support the general principles of the bill in respect of both parts.