Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Data Centres (Cumulative Impact Assessment)

Portfolio Question Time

Wednesday 24 June 2026 Meeting of the Parliament About 13:00 Questions 17 contributions · 9 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

17 contributions
Alan Brown SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

To ask the Scottish Government whether it plans to carry out a cumulative impact assessment of the number of planning applications proposed for artificial intelligence data centres, including the power and water resources required and the impact on climate emissions. (S7O-00115)

Gillian Martin SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Climate Action and Rural Affairs · Aberdeenshire East
link

Alan Brown will have heard my answers to previous questions on the issue of a cumulative assessment. We are taking a whole-system approach to understanding the full implications of data centre developments, including, as Alan Brown mentioned, the consideration of energy and water demands, potential economic benefits and the views of communities and local stakeholders.

Through continued engagement with the National Energy System Operator, the Scottish Environment Protection Agency and Scottish Water, we will look to ensure that data centre investment takes place in a resource-considerate manner, mitigating negative impacts and maximising positive impacts wherever possible—I mentioned some of those impacts in my answer to Mark Ruskell.

Although the Scottish Government is not currently undertaking a formal national assessment, we are working with partners to assess the impact of AI data centres and to look at whether current planning conditions are appropriate.

Alan Brown SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Rufus AI data centre, which was proposed at Hurlford in my constituency, will use the equivalent power output of the United Kingdom’s largest wind farm, Whitelee. Twenty-four data centres are proposed across Scotland, which is why there is a call for a centralised impact assessment. Can the cabinet secretary explain how the assessments that are being undertaken will feed into individual planning assessments?

Is she aware that my local authority of East Ayrshire is seeking clarification on what constitutes green data centres? Indeed, it is looking for guidance on assessing planning applications, which are applications only in principle and do not have enough detail from developers who are looking to get approvals and to flog those centres for a quick buck.

Gillian Martin SNP Aberdeenshire East
link

I am aware that local authorities and planning departments are calling for a little more clarity. In the AI strategy, we already committed to publishing guidance on what factors are prevalent in a green data centre. Planning authorities might use a range of factors when considering those matters. I do not think that Alan Brown would expect me to comment on a particular development, as that would not be helpful at all.

We are looking to consider matters around whether the data centre is powered from renewable energy sources, whether it makes use of energy-efficient technologies, whether it seeks to minimise water consumption by using a closed-loop system and whether it supports the reuse of excess heat for applications such as the ones that I have mentioned. Planning consideration could also be given as to where data centres are sited in order to allow industrial decarbonisation opportunities.

Laura Moodie Green South Scotland
link

Six of the current proposed 24 data centres are in my region. The amount of detail for each one and the planning stage that they are at vary hugely. The very favourable policy for addressing that, the national planning framework, came out four years ago but it feels as if no work has taken place in the interim on nailing down that detail. We have had a series of very muddled answers, which does not help my constituents from the Lammermuirs, some of whom are in the gallery, to feel that they are on a level playing field with landowners and developers. Will the cabinet secretary support the Scottish Greens’ call for a moratorium so that that detail can be ironed out and we can start afresh with clarity on what a green data centre actually is?

Gillian Martin SNP Aberdeenshire East
link

I will be honest: I will not support a moratorium on that, because we feel that planning regulations are already in place for any development, whether it is a data centre or another development, and that a lot of work is ongoing in relation to the particular conditions around data centres.

The member has pointed to the fact that there is an awful lot of speculation in that area. Of course, I cannot comment on particular planning applications but, as I have said in the answers that I have given, we are working with local authorities to see whether any additional regulation is required in that area. That work will continue. The volume of questions that I have had, particularly on data centres, means that we might have to expedite that work.

Adam Harley LD Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

I thank members for asking questions on this topic. There are plans to build one such data centre near Bishopbriggs in my constituency, and a number of local residents have contacted me with concerns about the potential impact. It is really important that people who could be affected have the chance to be heard and to understand the potential impact of such centres. Does the cabinet secretary agree that every effort should be made to ensure proper consultation with local residents?

Gillian Martin SNP Aberdeenshire East
link

It is essential that proper consultation is undertaken with residents, regardless of the development.

There has been a lot of speculation on data centres, particularly since the UK Government announced Scotland’s AI growth zone in Lanarkshire. Indeed, there are similar pressures in the north of England, where conditions have been made favourable for investment. We need to be alive to the need to site the data centres in the right place and with the explicit consent of nearby communities.

As I have said, there are a lot of opportunities for data centres to be sited in places where other developments can make use of the excess heat. I would like planning officers to take that into account.

As I have said to many members before, we are looking at environmental impact assessments to see whether they are fit for purpose for our data centres. However, regardless of the development, there must be public consultation.

Steven Bonnar SNP Uddingston and Bellshill
link

I thank the cabinet secretary for her previous and extensive answers on the topic. Will she outline how the Scottish Government will ensure that any future developments deliver local economic benefits, while also ensuring that planning authorities have the capacity and support that is required to properly assess these large-scale projects and protect Scotland’s climate ambitions?

Gillian Martin SNP Aberdeenshire East
link

The answer is, in general, yes. Data centres and developments that bring employment opportunities and investment to Scotland are welcome, but they must dovetail with our other national priorities. If the associated environmental impact does not meet our guidelines, that would clearly be a problem.

The applications themselves, and the types of technology that they use—for example, to limit water consumption and to partner with other companies that might act as off-takers for excess heat—could provide an almost closed-loop system.

We must look not only at the economic opportunities. We must also be mindful of where developments are located—there needs to be an economic benefit for the areas that they serve.

Graham Simpson Reform Central Scot and Lothians West
link

We have a deluge of speculative applications for AI data centres across the country. We have heard already that the area that I represent, North Lanarkshire, is designated an AI growth zone. Is not the truth that we need national guidance from the Scottish Government on where those data centres should be and on how many the country requires? That work needs to be expedited at pace over the summer.

Gillian Martin SNP Aberdeenshire East
link

Graham Simpson is right that the UK Government announcing the AI growth zone in Lanarkshire has meant that there is an awful lot of speculation at the moment. Many of the speculative projects will not even make it to the planning stage.

The member is absolutely right that the work is continuing. I have outlined some of the work that is under way with the national planning hub in order to inform decision making. If anything additional is needed—such as regulatory changes—as a result of this emerging technology, we need to be alive to that as well. I have been in post for three weeks in this area, but I want to ensure that this is taken forward.

There is a great deal of interest in the issue across rural portfolios. I will ensure that the work is expedited so that planning officers are not placed in a position where they lack the information that is needed to proceed.

Julie MacDougall Reform Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Last year, the UK Government announced plans to introduce AI growth zones, which would involve giving data centres a £24 per megawatt-hour discount in Scotland, starting from April 2027.

Given the enormous opposition that local communities such as mine in Auchtertool have to these data centres, and their rightful concern about demand on local water and power, which has been mentioned, does the Scottish Government have an updated stance on the AI growth zones in Scotland?

Gillian Martin SNP Aberdeenshire East
link

As Julie MacDougall said, the AI growth zone is a UK Government initiative, and that initiative has resulted in speculation in the areas that were designated as growth zones, as in Lanarkshire. Our stance on the growth zone initiative is that, obviously, we recognise that, where a data centre development is proposed, it must have strict environmental impact assessments associated with it, and we must have an idea of the number of data centres that are likely to go through planning. We also need to ensure that our regulations are fit for purpose.

There are opportunities that arise if data centres are sited in the right locations, and I have mentioned a few of those opportunities. We have an enormous amount of constrained renewable electricity that cannot make its way into the grid and which is being wasted—indeed, constraint payments are given to the generators. Data centres can provide an outlet to use that renewable electricity, but they cannot come at the expense of other environmental concerns.

Katy Clark Lab The Deputy Presiding Officer · West Scotland
link

A number of members have indicated that they wish to ask a question on this issue. I will take one further question, which will be from Claire Baker, although I ask her to keep it brief.

Claire Baker Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

The UK Government has updated its planning policy, and there is a clear strategic approach to where data centres are sited, which is what members are calling for in Scotland. On the question around environmental impact assessments, at the moment, it is not mandatory for local authorities to carry out such assessments. Will the Scottish Government consider changing that to ensure that environmental impact assessments are part of the process?

Gillian Martin SNP Aberdeenshire East
link

Obviously, that question strays into Mr McKee’s domain. I will take some of the members’ questions on planning regulations to Mr McKee, and he will see in the Official Report what members have been asking for today. I will play my part with regard to environmental impact assessments and giving advice to the cabinet secretary with responsibility for planning.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. 13:00 Climate Action and Rural Affairs Questions · 1
  2. 13:00 Food Production Systems Questions · 8
  3. 13:00 Animal Welfare (Farrowing Crates) Questions · 5
  4. 13:00 Marine Protected Areas and Priority Marine Features (Management) Questions · 9
  5. 13:00 Hyperscale Data Centres (Climate Impact Assessment) Questions · 4
  6. 13:00 Hyperscale Data Centres (Environmental Impact Assessment) Questions · 7
  7. 13:00 Data Centres (Cumulative Impact Assessment) Questions · 17
  8. 13:00 Farming (Species Management) Questions · 4
  9. 13:00 Wildfires and Vegetation Fires (Management) Questions · 4
  10. 13:00 Wildfires (Prevention) Questions · 5
  11. 14:34 Education, Culture and Gaelic Questions · 2
  12. 14:34 Breakfast Clubs (Primary and Special Schools) Questions · 9
  13. 14:34 Post-school Skills Pathways Questions · 6
  14. 14:34 Skills Development (Young People) Questions · 11
  15. 14:34 Learning Priorities (Primary Schools) Questions · 4
  16. 14:34 Learning Estate Investment Programme (School Buildings) Questions · 4
  17. 14:34 Care Leaver Payment (Kinship Care) Questions · 4
  18. 14:34 Island Communities (Support for Festivals) Questions · 6
  19. 14:34 Teachers (Workforce Planning) Questions · 4
  20. 14:34 School Leavers (Positive Destinations) Questions · 13
  21. 15:06 Reform UK Priorities Debate · 204
  22. 17:30 National Security (State Threats) Bill Bill debate · 13
  23. 17:45 Business Motions Business motions · 3
  24. 17:46 Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 3
  25. 17:46 Motion without Notice Business motions · 2
  26. 17:46 Decision Time Decision time · 22
  27. 17:59 Nuclear Power in Scotland Members’ business · 39
  28. 18:39 Correction Procedure · 2

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.