link
I apologise for my late arrival in the chamber. To ask the Scottish Government what engagement it has had with stakeholders to support the maintenance of banking services in rural areas. (S7O-00101)
Official Report · Chamber
General Question Time
This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.
link
I apologise for my late arrival in the chamber. To ask the Scottish Government what engagement it has had with stakeholders to support the maintenance of banking services in rural areas. (S7O-00101)
link
Although regulation of financial services is reserved, Scottish Government ministers and officials regularly engage with the sector and the regulator on the issue. Officials have raised Scottish-specific concerns with the Financial Conduct Authority, including Scotland’s rural and remote geography, topography and demographics, as well as the methodology used by Link to assess communities and make decisions about banking hubs. We await the upcoming reviews by the FCA on access to cash and HM Treasury on access to banking services, which we will use to represent Scotland’s interests. We continue to urge all financial services providers to hear and address customer concerns.
link
Given the recent closure of the last remaining bank in Kirkcudbrightshire, does the minister recognise that access to in-person banking services remains essential for many of my constituents, particularly older residents and smaller businesses, who rely on banking but do not have reliable digital access? The minister rightly said that the development of banking hubs is reserved. What support can the Scottish Government provide to ensure that banking hubs deliver a full range of face-to-face banking services, not just access to cash? What specific steps can it take to help to secure a hub or equivalent provision in areas such as Kirkcudbrightshire?
link
I thank the member for his important question, which certainly reflects my experience as a constituency member. Over my time in elected office, there have been numerous instances of a bank branch closing in my constituency to the detriment of my constituents, so I recognise the important role that the branches play. There is broad agreement on that across Parliament. As a minister, I am committed to engaging constructively with members on such matters.
Although we recognise the reserved nature of the issue, the Scottish Government is committed to engaging constructively. That is why we have made representations as part of the ongoing review process. I am committed to ensuring that all members have the opportunity to make representations to me, so that I can articulate that case to the UK Government. Beyond that, I am keen to work with members across the Parliament, in recognition of the fact that the issue impacts right across Scotland. With banking hubs, we have a model that has proven to be very effective, and I think that we all agree that we want it to grow and develop.
link
The recent bank closures in the Highlands have been widespread. In Sutherland, not a single bank remains open. Too many of my constituents are being asked to travel hours on end, which is impacting vulnerable customers and businesses alike.
Does the minister agree that although protecting access to cash is important, it is not enough on its own? The minister mentioned access to banking. Will he undertake to write to the United Kingdom Government in support of access to banks, with regard to a provision in the Financial Services and Markets Act 2023, to ensure that rural communities are not left behind?
link
The member makes a series of important points, particularly in highlighting the significant impact in more rural parts of Scotland. However, it should be understood that bank closures also have a profound impact in more urban parts of Scotland, as I have seen at first hand in my constituency in the central belt. This is a pan-Scotland issue.
I would be happy to follow up with Mr Green on the points that he has raised, and, if other members wish to make representations to me on the matter, I will be more than happy to pass them on to the UK Government.
link
In Fife, the Kingdom Community Bank has been a breath of fresh air for many of my constituents. It provides access to physical branches and a personalised service, often manned by volunteers, at a time when big banks are shutting up shop and cutting jobs.
Does the Scottish Government have any plans to support or encourage the creation of community banks as a possible alternative for rural communities across Scotland?
link
I thank the member for highlighting the positive impact of the example that she cited in her area. Although, as I said, I recognise the reserved nature of the issue, I want to work constructively on it. I am happy to engage with members to identify any opportunities where the Scottish Government can work constructively with local authorities, community organisations, the regulators and, indeed, the UK Government to ensure that we maximise access to banking services across Scotland, recognising the vital role that they play.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.