To ask the Scottish Government, following the recently closed public consultation into the future of the Woodside viaducts, which support a section of the M8 in Glasgow, what further consultation has taken place with key stakeholders regarding preferred options and associated costs for the delivery of this major project. (S7O-00100)
Tom ArthurSNPThe Minister for Business and Fair Work · Renfrewshire West and Levern Valley
The early public consultation on strategic options for the M8 Woodside viaducts permanent works project concluded on 25 March 2026. As part of the Scottish transport appraisal guidance process for identification and appraisal of transport interventions, three strategic approaches were presented: repair, replace and remove. Since then, engagement has continued—with key stakeholders including Glasgow City Council, Strathclyde Partnership for Transport, community councils, the Road Haulage Association and the Glasgow Chamber of Commerce—to inform the appraisal of potential options and associated costs. The work is ongoing and no final decisions have been taken.
The minister will be aware that heavy goods vehicles have been directed to the M74, to the south of Glasgow, and that local residents are concerned about traffic congestion via the on-boarding and off-boarding ramps at Rutherglen and Cambuslang. Was there any liaison with Glasgow City Council regarding a traffic impact assessment?
I do not have at hand the details to answer the member’s question, but I am happy to ask officials to write to the member, to provide her with an update.
Does the minister find it surprising—as I do—that, while the options remain on the table, some people seem determined to argue for the most expensive and time-consuming options rather than the quickest and cheapest option, which is removal? Does the minister agree that there needs to be an environmental assessment of the longer-term impacts and not only of the construction phase of the options—which has not so far taken place?
The member’s question illustrates that there are a range of views on the issue. I want to provide assurance to Parliament that no decisions have been taken. There has been an initial public consultation, and there will be detailed consideration of that before any further consultation. The Government is committed to fully engaging throughout the process, ensuring that all voices have the opportunity to make representations—including on the points that Mr Harvie has articulated.
The Woodside viaducts are an oversized relic of a bygone era, and they were built far wider and taller than the traffic flow requires, as Glasgow Corporation rightly stepped in to cancel the planned Maryhill motorway in 1975. Rather than accepting a false binary of either spending a fortune to maintain a 1970s concrete scar or completely severing the trunk route, we need a solution suited to modern inner-city urbanism.
Will the minister ask Transport Scotland to formally evaluate a compromise approach to replace the obsolete viaducts with a surface-level urban boulevard, taking direct inspiration from international precedents such as San Francisco’s Embarcadero and New York’s Sheridan Boulevard?
The member’s supplementary question further highlights the range of views that exist on the issue. It has been important to have a process of public engagement. I provide assurance to the Parliament that full and detailed consideration will be given to all the opinions that have been expressed to date, including the views that have been articulated by the member, before further action is taken.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.