To ask the Scottish Government what assessment it has made of any implications of the European Union’s carbon border adjustment mechanism for Scotland’s economy, including what representations it has made to the United Kingdom Government regarding the mitigation of any potential threats for Scotland’s exports. (S7O-00028)
Tom ArthurSNPThe Minister for Business and Fair Work · Renfrewshire West and Levern Valley
The Scottish Government supports the aim of the carbon border adjustment mechanisms, or CBAMs, to reduce carbon leakage. However, we recognise that the mechanisms, whether in the UK or the EU, present challenges for businesses. We have therefore met businesses in affected sectors to understand their concerns, which include compliance costs and competitive disadvantages in exporting to the EU, despite efforts to cut emissions. We have written to UK ministers to share the concerns and have consistently urged the UK Government to link UK and EU emissions trading schemes, which should provide EU CBAM exemptions for Scottish businesses.
I thank the minister for his answer, but surely he shares my frustration that the UK finds itself between a rock and a hard place on CBAM and everything else, and that it has very little influence on how CBAM has come to be. Does he agree that Scotland’s best future is as an independent state within the European framework?
I agree absolutely with Alyn Smith and welcome him bringing his tremendous experience and expertise to this chamber, given his previous roles.
We are certainly committed to engaging constructively with the UK Government, and I will meet my UK ministerial counterpart in the coming weeks. However, he is absolutely right to highlight the catastrophic damage that Brexit has inflicted on not just the Scottish but the UK economy, and that, of course, the best future for Scotland is as an independent member of the European Union.
I note from the ongoing CBAM discussions that fertiliser is going to be caught up in some of the border adjustments. That is likely to massively increase the cost of fertiliser, which is a key input for our farmers. Has the minister reviewed that particular input, and what measures will the Scottish Government use to help to resolve the issue of those costs for farmers?
Duncan Massey raises an important point. The Scottish Government convened a round-table meeting with businesses and affected sectors earlier this year. My predecessor wrote to the UK Government prior to dissolution. He did not receive a reply so, this morning, I wrote to the minister of state, and I hope to meet him in the coming weeks. I give the undertaking to the Parliament that, when I do, I will raise not just the issues that have been brought to the chamber this afternoon but the many other representations that I have received on the matter. I am happy to keep Duncan Massey up to date in that regard.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.