To ask the Scottish Government what assessment it has made of Scotland’s energy security, including any consequent action it plans to take in the light of heightened global tensions, particularly in the middle east and Ukraine. (S7O-00042)
Stephen GethinsSNPThe Minister for Europe, External Affairs and Energy · Dundee City East
The ongoing conflict in the middle east and Russia’s war in Ukraine have brought Scotland’s energy security into sharp focus. Our assessment remains that, on the information that is currently available to us, Scotland’s position in relation to energy security remains robust. However, despite that, as a responsible Government, we continue to monitor the current situation and prepare for any disruption. We are also continuing to pursue engagement with the United Kingdom Government to assess risks and share intelligence, to ensure that Scotland’s energy security remains resilient and to inform our planning.
I would like to help the minister in that regard. It is reported today that, if the largest undeveloped oil and gas field in the UK, Rosebank, is given the go-ahead, it will generate £8.5 billion-worth of direct investment, £6.6 billion of which will be spent on UK businesses; it will support 2,000 jobs during its development alone; and it will help our energy security. The Scottish National Party has maintained a presumption against new oil and gas for years, and it was confirmed again by the Scottish Government on Politico this week. However, for the sake of energy security, for thousands of Scottish jobs, for the environment and for the economy, will the minister join me in demanding that Ed Miliband give Rosebank the green light?
The issue is, as the member knows, reserved to the Westminster Parliament. However, I am glad that we are able to discuss reserved issues in this place as well.
The question of energy security is one of the tests that we apply, as well as the climate, when considering the options. However, I have to say that it takes something of a brass neck for the Conservatives to come to the chamber and lecture anybody about the oil and gas industry, given the thousands of jobs that were lost on their watch.
The minister will, no doubt, agree that our energy security must be considered alongside our climate obligations. That is why I urge the Scottish Government to recognise the advice of the Climate Change Committee, which says that nuclear is essential to the UK’s decarbonised electricity mix. I also urge the minister to recognise that decommissioning in Scotland, including at Dounreay, in my constituency, depends on retaining those skills in the long term. Will he therefore agree to visit Dounreay, meet our nuclear workforce and address the concern that his Government’s opposition to new nuclear sends them a message that their future lies elsewhere?
First, I would be delighted to visit the member in his constituency, for which he is obviously a champion.
Scotland is an energy exporter with excellence in renewables and other industries. Nuclear has been proven to be a very expensive technology. That being said, I will commit, as I said at the start, to engaging with members and will speak to them, as we can always learn something from one another.
Grangemouth provided aviation fuel and could have been used to develop sustainable aviation fuel for the future. Does the cabinet secretary share my concern that, by letting it close and now pandering to Putin by allowing the importation of aviation fuel, the UK Labour Government has actively chosen to weaken energy security in the UK and has lost opportunities to strengthen our domestic capabilities for the future?
Alan Brown is absolutely right to raise this issue. Labour committed itself, during the 2024 election campaign, to saving the Grangemouth refinery. Alan Brown and I agree that Scotland has a huge role to play in not only Scotland’s energy security but pan-European energy security, which Labour, along with its colleagues in Reform, has been turning its back on. Eighteen months ago, the UK Government committed to providing £200 million-worth of targeted support to Grangemouth, which has not been forthcoming. We will continue to pursue that.
On the question of sanctions, Alan Brown is absolutely right that we should have the maximum sanctions on Russia. I was deeply concerned by the UK Government’s recent action in that regard.
Is it not absolutely extraordinary that some people respond to a fossil fuel crisis that is sending prices spiralling through the roof by demanding that we double down and make ourselves even more dependent on fossil fuels and even more exposed to the next energy crisis that fossil fuels cause?
I am a great believer in the energy mix. As we make a just transition and invest in it, that will involve a huge range of skills. However, we are, as Mr Harvie knows, a massive exporter of renewables, and we can also be a massive exporter of renewables to the whole of Europe. Scotland has an awful lot to offer when it comes not just to our own energy security but to that of our whole continent.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.