To ask the Scottish Government what its response is to warnings issued by the Institute for Fiscal Studies on 27 May 2026 that, if earnings in Scotland grow in line with the rest of the United Kingdom, Scotland could face a deficit of over £6 billion by 2030. (S7O-00032)
Jenny GilruthSNPThe Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Local Government · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
Governments across these islands face significant pressures on public finances. Those challenges have intensified in recent months due to global instability.
Last summer, we published the medium-term financial strategy, which sets out the scale of the challenge and the action that is required. That was reinforced through the spending review and portfolio efficiency and reform plans, which were agreed in January, led by cabinet secretaries across the Scottish Government.
In addition, last week, I met the IFS to discuss its report and findings in more detail, including the learnings for the Scottish Government, to inform our next steps.
The interventions that the Deputy First Minister references were made when we thought that the budget deficit would be £5 billion. If the projections for earnings growth turn out to have been more optimistic than what actually transpires, it is likely that that deficit will increase by a further £1 billion. The Scottish Government has a budget of around £60 billion, and that would be a deficit of £6 billion—around 10 per cent of the entire Scottish budget.
The IFS has said that Scotland
“faces a fiscal reckoning—with spending cuts or tax rises on the way”.
I hope that Ms Young knows that I am taking a keen interest in those matters, given my responsibilities as Deputy First Minister. However, I have to work in partnership with the Cabinet Secretary for Public Service Reform. That is exactly why the event that we held on Monday was so important to that end. The Government has to work to meet and balance our budget every year—Ms Young will well understand that we do not have borrowing powers that exist in other parts of the United Kingdom. The discussion that I had with the IFS was important, as was the engagement that we have already had with the Scottish Fiscal Commission.
It goes back to the work that Ivan McKee is leading in relation to public service reform. I want to engage cross party on that, which is why I have been in contact with all parties to set up initial meetings in that space. I know that Michael Marra is keen to engage on those steps, and I would be more than happy to engage with Ms Young, too. We must work collaboratively to respond to the situation. That is the most appropriate and responsible action that a Government can take.
Last week, when I asked in the chamber how the black hole would be filled, the Cabinet Secretary for Public Service Reform replied that it would be public service reform that would fill the gap. At the same time, he said that public service reform was not about reducing the overall spend on public services. Those two statements cannot be true at the same time. Which is it? [Interruption.]
I can hear Mr McKee disagreeing with Murdo Fraser’s description of his contribution last week.
As I said to the member previously, we need to work on the issue on a cross-party basis. I am more than happy to hear any suggestions that Murdo Fraser might have. Of course, the budget-setting process in Scotland would be a lot better had we not had Liz Truss’s mini-budget, which made things far more challenging. Had we adhered to some of the tax cuts that Ms Truss was advocating for some time ago, we would have been poorer to the tune of £1.8 billion.
However, I repeat that I am more than happy to take any further learning that Mr Fraser can offer the Scottish Government on these matters.
The Deputy First Minister said that she met the Institute for Fiscal Studies last week to understand what learnings the Government might take. Will she tell us what those learnings are?
We will have a follow-up meeting on that over the summer recess. There are a number of learnings in relation to health and social care, the use of technology and our use of capital across Government. We had an introductory meeting of around 30 minutes. I would be more than happy to come back to the member with further detail in that regard, because I want to continue that dialogue with the IFS. It is hugely important that we listen to it and that we act accordingly, given the extent of the challenge that members across the chamber recognise exists in relation to our budget.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.