I completely agree with Daniel Johnson. That is very important. Some issues relating to the budget were even raised yesterday at our committee’s evidence session; no doubt some will also be raised at next Tuesday’s meeting.
Concerns over the clarity of Government policy feature highly in this year’s committee reports, with many requesting further work to be carried out to evidence the impact and sustainability of policies such as a growing social security budget. Other reports suggest that overlapping strategies, timelines and documents can hinder effective scrutiny. Across portfolios, committees are looking at whether prioritisation is clearly stated, justified and aligned with the Government’s stated objectives. More information is needed on the trade-offs between the spend that the Government is choosing to protect and the impact that that has on other funding areas. I note that the subjects of skills, climate change and social security have frequently been raised.
The FPA committee’s pre-budget scrutiny builds on the committee’s findings over successive years regarding the Scottish Government’s lack of strategic financial planning against a backdrop of fiscal pressures, including demographic trends. Ahead of the committee’s pre-budget scrutiny this year, the Scottish Fiscal Commission said:
“the Scottish Government will face significant challenges funding devolved public services in the future, particularly over the next twenty-five years … because the population in Scotland will age earlier than in the rest of the UK.”
In June 2025, the medium-term financial strategy confirmed that the gap between funding and resource spending would rise to £2.6 billion by 2029-30. In the shorter term, the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Local Government warned that “difficult choices” would be needed for the 2026-27 Scottish budget.
There were challenging decisions for the United Kingdom Government in its autumn statement, too. The Office for Budget Responsibility noted that
“the scale and array of risks to the UK fiscal outlook remains daunting.”
In that context, and drawing on the SFC’s April 2025 “Fiscal Sustainability Report”, scrutiny was focused on responding to long-term fiscal pressures. After calling for views over the summer, we received 28 submissions, heard evidence in the autumn and published our report in October 2025. To inform our scrutiny, we visited the advanced manufacturing innovation district Scotland—AMIDS—in Paisley, as well as Vilnius in Lithuania to hear about the excellent futures thinking approach there and about policies on economic growth.
I will highlight some key findings, how they have influenced Government budgetary decisions and where commitments have not been forthcoming. One of our main recommendations was for much greater Government emphasis on longer-term financial planning to start mitigating the impact of future trends. We urge the Scottish Government to provide a full response to the SFC’s 2025 “Fiscal Sustainability Report”, repeating a previous recommendation relating to the SFC’s first such report in 2023.
The Government pointed to specific actions, such as its population strategy and Scotland’s migration service. However, that falls short of committing to produce a full response. Common to other committees, we ask for clarity in future documents on which areas of spending are being prioritised and deprioritised. The Scottish ministers replied that they recognise the need for clarity, explaining:
“Progress is being made to further improve this in our 2026-27 Scottish Budget, including clear references to how prioritised funding delivers the Scottish Government’s four priorities”.
We were not convinced that the Scottish Government has provided sufficient evidence of social security sustainability, and we repeated our calls for a review of the fiscal sustainability of social security spending, asking for outcomes arising from universal payments and services to be reviewed. The committee is unclear from the cabinet secretary’s response whether the Government will undertake that important work, because the response pointed to a previous report, a literature review and the development of its approach to public value.
On public service reform, we asked for a detailed plan on how the Government will meet its high-level targets on efficiencies and workforce, while minimising the impact on public services. We therefore welcome publication, alongside the Scottish budget, of the integrated public sector pay and workforce policy and of portfolio efficiency and reform plans. We look forward to examining those in detail.
An update was sought on progress with work that had previously been asked for in considering the potential benefits, risks and costs of introducing a new preventative spend category of expenditure. The Government’s work in that area is welcome, including the testing of a budget-tagging method for tracking preventative spend across portfolio areas of the budget, with publication of the results planned for summer 2026. I am sure that it will benefit all committees in the next session if they can clearly see where spending on prevention is occurring and making a difference.
The Government’s announcement of an extension to the invest to save fund to support portfolios, public bodies and local government to carry out reform projects is appreciated. Its response is also reassuring in confirming that projects are required to provide six-monthly reports, that outcomes are being monitored and that successes are being shared more widely across the public sector.
Our pre-budget report looked ahead to the Scottish spending review, which was published alongside last week’s budget. During a visit to Estonia in 2024, the committee noted the implementation of zero-based budgeting and asked Scottish ministers to reflect on how such an approach could be delivered in Scotland. We recommended that a zero-based budgeting approach should be taken to the Scottish spending review, and we requested in-depth information on the process for preparing, scrutinising and delivering that. In response, the Government said it already adopts
“the principles of zero-based budgeting”,
and that spending is reviewed in detail throughout the Scottish budget process. However, the Government has not provided the in-depth review process information that was requested.
With the UK Government’s autumn statement being four weeks later than it was in 2024, the timetable for Scottish budget scrutiny has been tighter this year. As a result, our committee agreed to carry out separate sessions on the spending review and the infrastructure delivery plan in February and March, although I expect both of those to be touched on when the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Local Government gives evidence to the committee on Tuesday. I therefore urge the cabinet secretary to commit, in her closing speech, to providing that information on process in time to inform our spending review scrutiny.
The committee previously expressed concerns regarding recent funding settlements for the college sector, given its key role in developing a skilled workforce and in growing the economy. The uplift in funding for the sector in the Scottish budget is therefore encouraging, and I look forward to hearing more about the sustainability of the further education and higher education sectors from the convener of the Education, Children and Young People Committee later in the debate.
On capital funding, we asked the Government to set out the steps that it will take as part of its investment delivery plan to smooth out the “lumpy” capital budget over time. The Government suggests that
“through careful management of the pipeline, we can ensure a steady stream of investment in the infrastructure needed to deliver ministers’ priorities.”
It also continues to explore revenue finance models to expand capacity for infrastructure investment.
The spending review confirmed that a new £1.5 billion Scottish Government bond programme for infrastructure will launch in 2026-27 to support capital investment and diversify borrowing beyond the UK national loans fund. Our successor committee will want to keep a close eye on that to ensure value for money and the delivery of successful outcomes.
During our visit to Lithuania, the committee was impressed by the country’s approach to collectively developing and implementing Lithuania 2050, which is its national vision for the future. That includes buy-in from all political parties, its Parliament, public bodies and civic society, and a parliamentary committee is monitoring progress towards achieving the agreed national vision. The cabinet secretary told us that she was happy to consider that model, and we have asked for her conclusions by the end of January. We hope that she will look favourably on the approach, and we greatly anticipate receiving her response.
I commend the diligent and effective pre-budget work that has been carried out by committees.
I move,
That the Parliament notes the pre-budget scrutiny undertaken by the Finance and Public Administration Committee, and other parliamentary committees.
15:11