As a nation, Scotland is shaped by water: it is central to our landscape, our economy and our identity. The world over, lochs, rivers and long, rocky and rugged coastlines are closely identified with Scotland—as, of course, unfortunately, is the rain. However, plentiful water is not only one of our greatest assets but one of our greatest challenges, and flooding is one of the most acute environmental challenges that Scotland faces today. It is an increasing threat to communities across Scotland, both coastal and inland, and the need for effective flood defences has never been more urgent.
Flooding in Scotland is not a new problem, but it is becoming more and more frequent and severe, with an impact on people and their homes, businesses and critical infrastructure. Scientific projections suggest that Scotland can expect wetter and warmer winters in the future, along with more extreme weather events. That will place even greater pressure on existing flood defences, putting homes, businesses, farm land and infrastructure at further risk.
Across the South Scotland region, which I represent, some advances have been made in developing better flood defences. However, in communities such as Peebles and Walkerburn there are serious concerns that a continuing lack of flood protection poses a risk to people and property, along with fears that successful funding applications to install schemes in places such as Galashiels, Selkirk and Jedburgh mean that there is now little cash left for further defence schemes in the foreseeable future.
In East Lothian, for example, in Musselburgh and down the coast, a debate is raging about what sort of flood defences the town and the wider coastline area needs and how much those will cost. In other communities, plans for flood protection have not secured the necessary support of local communities—for example, that is the case with the recent proposals for a scheme in Langholm. In that instance, plans would have included the erection of walls and embankments along the River Esk and its tributaries, but those plans were shelved as a result of strong opposition from within the community, amid fears of spiralling costs.
I recognise the strength of local opinion in many instances, and I stress that it must be heeded as ministers and councils across South Scotland consider future flood defence plans. That is at the heart of what I want to say today. The need to fully consult local communities, partners, businesses, organisations and other stakeholders during the appraisal and consenting process for flood defence schemes is a crucial step, but, all too often, it has not taken place.
The most glaring example of that has been the failure to mount a meaningful consultation for the Whitesands flood defence scheme in Dumfries, which was recently given the green light by the Scottish National Party-run council. That there is a serious flooding issue at the Whitesands is not in dispute—it floods regularly, and it can cause severe disruption and damage to businesses and other properties in the area when the Nith bursts its banks. However, despite that, the proposed scheme, which is estimated to cost potentially a staggering £69 million and possibly even more, has not won the support of local people or of those in neighbouring communities—in fact, it is quite the opposite.
Over recent years, thousands of locals have signed petitions against the scheme, which would fundamentally and damagingly alter historic views along the Whitesands, as a raised walkway incorporating walls, glass panels and flood gates is planned to run from the former Dumfries & Galloway Standard offices downstream to Dock park, with additional measures over the river at Welldale and Kenmure Terrace.
Aside from the physical impact of the proposed scheme, there are widespread fears locally that it could lead to the loss of the Rood fair—one of Scotland’s longest-running festivals, which dates back to the 1500s and makes use of the Whitesands each year. There are also real concerns among local retailers about the disruption and the loss of revenues that their businesses will face during the construction phase.
There is an equally widespread view that the costly scheme will be ineffective—a £69 million white elephant on the River Nith that siphons off millions of pounds in investment that could have supported vital local services, including provisions to effectively address other flood-related issues. The funding could have gone towards tackling the flooding that affects many roads in the rural south-west or towards the proper dredging of local rivers. It could have helped to replace the Diamond Jubilee bridge and the Cuthbertson memorial bridge, which were both washed away in 2021 when water levels along the River Annan reached a 50-year high. Those are practical measures that would command support in the community, rather than £69 million being squandered on a flood scheme for Dumfries in which locals simply do not have confidence.
Flood defences are essential to Scotland’s future. They protect lives, homes and livelihoods, and they help to ensure that communities can thrive despite climate change. However, they need to be taken forward with the necessary consultation of local communities, partners, businesses, organisations and other stakeholders, particularly when it is local authority and Scottish Government money that is at risk.
Water has shaped Scotland’s history and, with the right choices and the right flood mitigation measures that enjoy public support, it does not have to threaten the future of our country and our communities.
17:35