link
Sorry, can you ask the question again?
Official Report · Committee
Common Organisation of the Markets in Agricultural Products (Fruit and Vegetables) (Miscellaneous Amendment) (Scotland) Regulations 2026 [Draft]
link
Sorry, can you ask the question again?
The budgetary impact of not passing the SSI and the pressures elsewhere in your budget—would that have an impact on other parts of the sector?
link
I am sorry, but I am being a bit dense. Can you rephrase that question?
You mentioned before that, if the SSI were not to pass, that would have a budgetary implication for how you use the rest of your agriculture budget.
link
As it stands, we could not stop other POs joining the Scottish system. Depending on how many of them there were, we have no mechanism to stop them. Whatever plans they put in, there would be no mechanism for us to say no to them. We would be legally obliged to fund them. Whatever that happens to be, we would have an obligation to fund it. The implications of that are dependent on the size of the POs that come in and how much money they take out of the budget. We would be unable to say no.
link
Do you have an indication of how many POs may be minded to join the Scottish scheme?
Not of how many are minded to join the scheme, no. In England, there were around 29, and quite a large budget, but I do not know how much interest there is in coming up to Scotland.
link
We are going round and round on this, but this is quite an important point, is it not? I was desperately searching the EU regulations, and the original regulations say:
“In order to control Union expenditure, there should be a cap on assistance granted to producer organisations and their associations that establish operational funds.”
I found something else that suggests that it was possible to set an overall cap. It seems quite odd, does it not, that you can have a fund that loads of people can join? I will go away and ask a whole load of questions afterwards, and I am not saying that what I have read is right. However, just for absolute clarity, as you understand it, the budget could be exponential in size, and there is nothing that you can do to stop that—is that right?
link
Yes, that is correct.
We have powers under the Agriculture (Retained EU Law and Data) (Scotland) Act 2020 to change the cap, but if the SSI does not pass, we would have to come back and look at the cap, which would have an impact on the amount of funding that is being accessed at the moment by Scottish producers.
link
Six months ago, you granted to three organisations a funding package for the next two years. Is that correct?
We agreed at the start of the year how much the next programme would be. The applications window for that was September. Producers had to apply in September, with confirmation in December.
link
In theory, if we did not pass the SSI today, would you have time to come back with a new SSI, or whatever the mechanism would be, to introduce a cap before any new funding period?
No. The statutory deadline to confirm to producer organisations whether they had their funding was Monday 15 December.
link
I know that we have been around this before, but I ask for absolute clarity. This needs to be on record because, I suspect, it will get heavily checked in the background. Despite the fact that three existing recipients have had their funding offers confirmed for the next two years, starting six months ago, it is still possible that English producers could come into any one of these POs and maintain that its turnover is more than £1 million, so that they get access to the scheme, and the Scottish Government budget would have to pay for that.
Yes. That could not begin in January 2026; it would have to begin in January 2027. They have missed the 2026 window, but they could start in 2027.
10:45
link
But that is more than a year away. What would prevent us from coming back with a cap on the budget, as has just been suggested by Mr Hamilton?
The next scheme starts in January 2026, so, initially, the existing caps would apply. We would not be able to change that.
link
Did you not think about that before? Did it never crop up in conversations behind the scenes?
That is why we consulted, back in the summer, on this set of changes. We could see the—
link
We are speaking two days after the deadline. A solution to most of the issues that have been raised today was put in place just two days before we considered this. It feels as though some of the options that it might have been open to the committee to ask you to explore have been taken out of our hands.
link
It is 17 December, minister. Today, you are coming to me, as a member of this committee, and saying, “Hey, agree this—and if you don’t, we’re really scuppered.” I have got no option. I am being forced into approving a scheme that I do not think is right, with a load of stuff that—as Ariane Burgess has presented—we do not even think is right for the market, but there is nothing that we can do about that because it is too late in the day. It does not sound as though it has been discussed behind the scenes that there might be a huge impact on the Scottish budget if we do not approve the SSI. You are forcing my hand.
link
You are saying that it was not discussed behind the scenes, but there was a consultation. It was consulted on.
link
I am talking about what has been discussed within Mr Burgess’s department. We have got our hands tied behind our backs here.
Okay. We are going round in circles.
link
I will bring in the last contribution, from Ariane Burgess. Very briefly, please, Ariane.
link
That was revelatory. It also added more confusion, in a way. There is possibly something else going on here as well. There are a couple of different needs for the agricultural budget. There are people who want to produce food that feeds people in Scotland—to produce it locally and direct to sale and all that—and there are producer organisations. My research shows that a small percentage of what those organisations grow feeds people in Scotland—the rest goes for export south of the border and, potentially, elsewhere.
I wonder whether we need to acknowledge that there are two different strands: there is a commodity side to agriculture and food production that is producing for export further afield, and there is the good food nation approach whereby we need to support those local producers, so that when climate change and nature breakdown hit, people in the islands or other rural communities can get food that is locally produced.
link
In relation to the contracts that producer organisations have, it is up to supermarkets to decide where they will put those products. I find it absolutely scandalous that we can be in Perthshire and yet the berries that I am buying are still from Kent, but we cannot change that. What we can do is make sure that there is resilience in the producer organisations that are currently producing food here in Scotland—whether or not it gets exported, they are still producing food in Scotland—and give them the protection over the next three years that they have told us that they want.
You are right that there are two different strands here. I repeat again: my commitment is to supporting that small producer cohort, which will give us the biodiversity, environmental, local food resilience and local economy benefits. All those people are very much in my mind. I cannot give you a timescale for doing something about the issue, but we are actively looking at it right now.
The small producers pilot fund is not for fun. We are not doing it because it is a wheeze. The asks that came to us previously from small producers were about slaughtering and how to get slaughtering facility—that is what we did previously. This SSI is about making sure that those very professional businesses, which do a hell of a lot of good work here in Scotland, get the support that they need and deserve, so that they will continue to be able to produce food. Whether it gets exported to England or any other place is an issue for the market, not for the Government.
link
I am sorry, minister, but you have once again repeated that the SSI is about ensuring that those producers get the funding. Whether or not we pass the SSI today makes no difference—they will still get the funding. The issue is how big that budget demand might be, based on 50 per cent of producer organisations that may or may not apply to the scheme. It does not affect that unless you decide to bring in a cap.
link
As Alasdair Allan pointed out, if we do not pass the SSI and we get a large number of POs wanting to join the system in Scotland, how much money will that take out of the budget? We have no mechanism, because it was reserved by the UK Government back down to England so that it would make the decisions about what the criteria were. That would then impact our overall budget for the agricultural system.
link
That is not what you said just three seconds ago. You said that, if we did not pass the SSI today, it would effectively put pressure on the producer organisations. That is not the case.
link
It could very well be the case. If we suddenly get a huge influx of demands for funding, it may not put pressure on them immediately, but it would certainly sharpen our thinking about whether we were prepared to keep funding producer organisations if they were coming up from England to get that funding.
link
You have no indication of how many might join, so it is just speculation.
link
Right now, I am not prepared to take that risk.
link
I am sorry, Ariane—I interrupted you. Did you have any further points?
link
I did have a point, but it has gone out of my head now, so it is fine.
link
We will now move to the formal consideration of the motion to approve the instrument. I invite the minister to speak to and move motion S6M-19989.
Motion moved,
That the Rural Affairs and Islands Committee recommends that the Common Organisation of the Markets in Agricultural Products (Fruit and Vegetables) (Miscellaneous Amendment) (Scotland) Regulations 2026 draft be approved.—Jim Fairlie
link
Does any member wish to debate the motion?
link
Can I make a point? I feel that I have a hand tied behind my back. I am going to vote no to the motion today, although I recognise that I will probably have to change my mind and vote yes in the chamber. I will want to speak to this in the chamber, because I have serious concerns about what we have heard this morning. I will have to go away and find a whole load of answers in order to give me enough confidence to vote for the instrument in the chamber, presumably after Christmas.
link
I concur with Tim Eagle’s points. I am going to vote no in this case and try to bottom out more information and more understanding. However, between now and the SSI coming to the chamber, I would like to get assurances from the minister on action that supports other people. We are talking about small producers, but, in this context, we are talking about vegetable and fruit producers. They are all professional and very capable of producing food.
link
Since no other members wish to comment, is the committee content to recommend approval of the instrument?
Members: No.
link
We are not content. Okay. We are not content—Interruption. There will be a division. Thank you, Emma Johnston. I should know this off by heart.
For
Allan, Alasdair (Na h-Eileanan an Iar) (SNP)
Harper, Emma (South Scotland) (SNP)
Roddick, Emma (Highlands and Islands) (SNP)
Tweed, Evelyn (Stirling) (SNP)
Against
Burgess, Ariane (Highlands and Islands) (Green)
Carson, Finlay (Galloway and West Dumfries) (Con)
Eagle, Tim (Highlands and Islands) (Con)
Grant, Rhoda (Highlands and Islands) (Lab)
Wishart, Beatrice (Shetland Islands) (LD)
link
The result of the division is: For 4, Against 5, Abstentions 0.
Motion disagreed to.
link
Finally, is the committee content to delegate authority to me to sign off our report on this instrument?
Members indicated agreement.
link
That completes our consideration of the instrument and concludes our business in public for 2025. I wish everybody a merry Christmas.
10:53 Meeting continued in private until 11:51.
No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.