I thank those members who have stayed a little later than expected, as well as all those who signed the motion, allowing us to debate the subject this evening.
MSPs from all sides of the chamber raise the issue of waiting times in our national health service regularly. In a search of the Official Report from the past two weeks alone, I saw members rightly expressing concern about failures to meet waiting-time targets of 12 months for some conditions, and 62 days in another case. A member raised the issue of waiting times again at portfolio question time today. There are many examples, and we all understand the impact of the problem on our constituents’ lives and the immense challenges that the NHS faces in addressing it.
However, the example that I raise today is extreme. The data from Public Health Scotland, which are mentioned in the motion and were published last month, illustrate a wholly unacceptable situation throughout Scotland, but in particular at the Sandyford in Glasgow, where the service is utterly overwhelmed. That is Scotland’s largest gender identity clinic; it is the service for eight health board areas covering almost half the Scottish population. As at March this year, in comparison with the previous year, there were three times as many people on its waiting list who had been there for more than five years. The clinic was offering first appointments to people who had been waiting for six and a half years.
A six-and-a-half-year wait for a first appointment is bad enough, but that is not what new patients today are facing. With almost 4,000 people on the waiting list and fewer than 50 first appointments being offered in the course of a year, new patients will be looking at the situation in utter despair. At that rate, it would take 80 years to reach the head of the queue. That is not even the worst estimate—independent research has put the figure far higher and shown that the situation there is by far the worst in any part of the United Kingdom.
Whether we measure a theoretical waiting time like that in decades or in centuries, it is hardly helpful. Either way, it is clear that, without transformational change, most people will simply never be seen. They will never even get a first appointment, let alone actually receive the healthcare that they need. More to the point, only those with the resources to go private will be able to do so, and even then, they will find it next to impossible to get an NHS general practitioner who will accept them and treat them.
All that stands in stark contrast to the Scottish Government’s stated commitments. In 2021, it committed to
“reform the current model of Gender Identity Services to meet the needs of the community”,
bringing the service
“within national waiting times standards.”
The “NHS gender identity services: strategic action framework 2022-2024”, which promised “transformation” of the service, was published in late 2021 and was due to be implemented between 2022 and 2024. As part of that, a commitment was made to
“test new multidisciplinary models for delivery of gender identity healthcare”,
among many other improvements.
How must the people who are waiting for year after year after year feel, knowing that such promises were made and that the situation has simply continued to fall apart? Well, many of them have told me how their lives are affected. I have heard from those who have been left with no option but to seek private treatment, including those who have been forced into debt to do so. I have heard from those who have been refused treatment from their GP or who have had to change their GP multiple times.
I have heard from those who were offered no support of any kind while waiting, and no clarity at all about how long the wait would be. I have heard from those who suffer the distress of having a complete lack of control over their own lives, not as a result of being trans, but as a result of the indefinite wait for support or treatment.
I heard from one constituent, who is herself a doctor working in the NHS. She was told that the waiting list was two years long when she joined it, only to be told, as two years passed, that the wait would be another two years. She has now been waiting for six years and fears that she may be waiting for many more.
My constituent’s description of desperation in seeking private care—as she described it,
“to bridge the gap while waiting”,
only to find that the wait would become interminable—was distressing enough to read. What I found even harder to read was her request that I quote from her experience, but not use her name. She said:
“I mostly just don’t want to be potentially harassed at my workplace if this is linked back to me.”
That is from someone who worked to provide emergency care during the Covid-19 pandemic to serve her community and her country.
We need to recognise the context in which all this is happening. Recent years have seen a continually rising tide of transphobia, generating hostility, fear and prejudice. We see legal demands for segregation. We see flat-out denial of trans and non-binary people’s identities, of their human rights and of their dignity. We see a campaign to stir up and weaponise transphobia—a campaign that is every bit as ugly and toxic as the homophobia of the 1980s and 1990s, and in the early years of the Parliament. That campaign is coming not only from the far right, but from across the political spectrum.
Turning to the subject of the motion that we are debating, we see outright attempts to abolish trans people’s healthcare altogether. I know that the Scottish Government does not intend to support that, but the position now is so severe that, without transformational action, that is what will have happened by default, and the Scottish Government will have allowed it.
We must not permit that—not the Government, and not the Parliament. Every MSP has constituents who are waiting for too long, and waiting for us to act. They have a right to expect better. They want to hear from the Minister for Public Health and Women’s Health today what is going to happen now to resolve the crisis, and so do I.
18:58