Every MSP recognises the economic impact that the oil and gas sector has had on the wider economy since the 1970s. Clearly, there has also been an environmental impact. Although the sector is based in the north-east, it involves workers from across the country, in addition to companies in the supply chain. Therefore, the debate on the oil and gas sector and the energy sector as a whole is for every MSP.
I have family who work in the sector or who have previously worked in it, and I have friends who work in the sector. I have long since heard their concerns about the sector’s future. I recognise that their views on renewable energy are not that positive, but that is not the case for every worker in the oil and gas sector. It is essential that the just transition happens. Douglas Lumsden stated earlier that Scotland needs a transition based on reality, and I very much agree.
The cabinet secretary has previously highlighted her family background as coming from Clydebank. She was right to highlight the absolute carnage that was wrought on the communities along the banks of the Clyde when the shipbuilding industry was decimated by the Conservatives in the 1980s.
Communities such as mine are still struggling to fully deal with that. There has been 44 years of population decline because industry was shut down. Thousands of jobs were lost and yards were torn down, with retail units, fast food outlets, some offices and flats being built in their place. Those facilities are cleaner than the shipyards and heavy engineering that once stood there, but there was no concept of a just transition at that time. The enterprise zone that was installed delivered some successes, but very little was of long standing.
My community suffered as a consequence of a Conservative Administration that was hellbent on destroying working-class communities. I do not want that to be replicated in the north-east of Scotland—where some of my family now live, as they were forced to get on their bikes as per the demands of Norman Tebbit.
The energy profits levy was useful in the short term, but the fact that the past Conservative Government never replaced it with something more sustainable is yet another example of the utter chaos that was emblematic of the Conservatives’ time in government. The SNP amendment states:
“and recognises that communities in Scotland are now paying the price of the UK Conservative administration’s levy on Scottish industry.”
My only challenge to my party on that amendment is that the energy profits levy is the present-day equivalent of what the Tories do to Scotland any time that they are in power. The systematic demolition of industry and communities, or the raking in of finance from cash-cow communities when it suits them, will always be fair game to the Conservatives.
Whether under the Conservatives or Labour, Westminster has failed to provide the oil and gas industry with certainty or stability. That approach is in direct opposition to supporting jobs and the just transition, which would safeguard energy security and lower bills.
Fundamentally, the energy profits levy should be scrapped and a proportionate tax regime should be established. There was a time when oil and gas giants were making windfall profits in the UK, but that is not the case now. They are global companies, and the vast majority of their profits are made outwith the UK. All that the windfall tax is doing is costing jobs and driving a more rapid decline in the North Sea. In a nation that is as energy rich as Scotland is, it should be a disgrace that so many of our citizens are so energy poor—and every single MSP should be appalled at that.
Although Labour promised to cut energy bills by up to £300 per year, the reality is that bills have risen and the blame lies squarely at Westminster’s door. Key powers over industry, trade, industrial relations, employment law and energy are all in Labour’s hands. That is why it is vital that we remain steadfastly behind the renewable energy revolution and maximise the investment and opportunities that it will bring.
If Westminster repeats the mistakes of the past and allows Scotland’s immense natural resources to be mismanaged, we will all risk the same fate. I do not want other communities to suffer 44 years of decline and—