To ask the Scottish Government what evidence it received in relation to the decision to allow the continued use of electrofishing for razor clams beyond January 2025, when the trial that started in February 2018 was due to end. (S6O-05139)
Official Report · Chamber
Electrofishing Trial
General Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Mairi Gougeon SNP 3
- Edward Mountain Con 2
- Dr Alasdair Allan SNP 1
The record
6 contributionsThe razor clam scientific trial has yielded promising results that point to the potential for a sustainable commercial fishery, with appropriate management measures in place. A progress report was published in 2024 that presents those findings in detail, including completed stock assessments for two locations—the Firth of Clyde and Firth of Forth trial areas. The trial was extended for a further two years to gather data to update those stock assessments and enable completion of assessments for additional areas, giving us confidence that fishing for razor clams with that technique can be achieved sustainably across Scotland’s seas.
The seven-year pseudoscientific and inconclusive experiment, which the Government said will now end in 2027, seems to be more about protecting a commercial fishery that is worth more than £5.5 million to just over 20 boats. The minister knows that electrofishing for spoots is banned in the European Union. Surely, then, in 2027, the Scottish Government, under the UK Withdrawal from the European Union (Continuity) (Scotland) Act 2021, will need to keep pace with the EU and ban electrofishing of spoots, or will it continue the farce of a scientific experiment?
As with many other areas when it comes to our fisheries, we like to lead by example. An example of that work is the roll-out of our remote electronic monitoring. However, it is important that we consider issues relating to why we had the trial in the first place and the type of fishing that we were attempting to stop. We want to make sure that it is sustainable, and it is important that we gather all the evidence for that, which is why the trial was initiated in the first place and why it has been extended. We want to ensure that we have as robust an evidence base as possible for any future considerations.
Will the minister give an indication of the importance that the Scottish Government places on further developing a razor clam fishery in future, specifically in areas such as the Western Isles?
I assure the member that we put a great deal of importance on supporting our fishers in rural and island locations. As I have outlined, the trial that we have undertaken on razor clams was extended to ensure that we have a strong evidence base and that a sustainable and economically viable fishery for razor clams is possible in many areas around Scotland, including the Western Isles.
I am keen—as I know other members will be—to see the trial culminate in a commercial fishery, if the evidence supports that. The science and regulatory background to that is very complex, but it is important that we arrive at the right decision by using the best available knowledge.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 13 Nov 2025 →- Electrofishing Trial Questions · 6
- Regeneration (South-west) Questions · 6
- Glasgow Airport (Rail Link) Questions · 4
- Transport (Edinburgh Pentlands) Questions · 4
- International Ferry Route (Rosyth) Questions · 6
- Income Tax Questions · 8
- ScotWind (Investigation) Questions · 5
- Grooming Gangs Inquiry First Minister’s Questions · 10
- National Health Service (Winter Preparedness) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Primary Schools (Class Contact Time) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- “Independent Report on Regional Economic Development in Scotland” First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Income Tax First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Peatland Restoration First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Housing Provision (Motor Neurone Disease) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Supreme Court Judgment (Sexual Offences Trials) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Supreme Court Judgment (Sexual Offences Trials) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Energy Bills (Social Tariffs) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Killer of Keith Rollinson (Early Release) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Ferry Disruption (Isle of Lewis) First Minister’s Questions · 3
- Economy and Employment First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Violence in Schools First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Tourette Syndrome Members’ business · 11
- Education and Skills Questions · 1
- University Tuition Fees Questions · 6
- Curriculum (Artificial Intelligence) Questions · 7
- School Buildings (Asbestos) Questions · 7
- Higher and Further Education and Apprenticeships (Funding) Questions · 8
- Poverty-related Attainment Gap (Local Authority Support) Questions · 4
- School Provision (Robroyston) Questions · 7
- Point of Order Procedure · 2
- Winter Preparedness (Health and Social Care) Statement · 28
- Scottish Parliament (Recall and Removal of Members) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 91
- Decision Time Decision time · 10
- Point of Order Procedure · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.