It is fair to raise that point, because I ran out of time in the chamber and did not address it fully, if at all. If you recall, we consulted on long-term prisoners. I am trying to remember whether that was last summer or the summer before—Interruption. It was in 2024. We consulted because we wanted to consider the issue and seek views from victim support organisations and from those who work in the field.
You will be well aware that long-term prisoners are subject to the parole process, so there is a complexity to any change to their release arrangements. As someone who used to work with long-term prisoners and write parole reports, I am more than aware of the risk profile that is associated with long-term prisoners.
There is a question—and it is a question on which I have an open mind—whether, if the prison population were to be reduced further and there were fewer short-term prisoners, thus enabling more rehabilitative work to be done with long-term prisoners, we would have the balance right for long-term prisoners who have determinate sentences, by which I mean those people who are returning to our community at some point. Is there a question in there about better progression and better step-down facilities, and about the balance of how much of their sentence they spend in custody and how much they spend under strict licence conditions—perhaps even electronic monitoring—and under the threat of recall?
There are concerns about prisoners who do not qualify for parole and are released automatically six months before the end of their sentence. They could have served several years. Does that serve the public well, in terms of testing, managing and preparing for release people who are eventually going to return to our communities? That is an argument on which we should have an open mind, at least.
10:00
The consultation definitely showed us that, because of the risk profile, any change to how long-term prisoners are managed cannot be made in the short term. It is not something to be done as an emergency measure. It needs to be consulted on and planned for, and additional investment would need to be made in community justice social work, for example. The increase in the number of those in the long-term population—that part of the population who require statutory social work input—means that community justice social work is facing considerable demand, given the statutory work that it has to do for the Parole Board for Scotland and so on. It therefore cannot be an emergency measure.
We will have to wait and see what the sentencing and penal policy commission comes back with. I am merely saying that I am aware of the potential benefits, but I am also aware of the risks and the investment that would need to be coupled with any change to how long-term prisoners are managed.
The short answer is that I have an open mind. I know what I am in favour of: community justice, home detention curfews and expanded use of electronic monitoring for those who are on community disposals and, indeed, those who are leaving prison. I am also very much in favour of making best use of the estate, and we have increased its capacity. I want to replace old and crumbling buildings and ensure that HMP Highland and HMP Glasgow are delivered.
Beyond the prisons that we are committed to building and beyond modernising the estate, I am not in favour of building our way out of this, because if we build, they will come. We already have a prison population of 8,400, and the challenge is to get to a more sustainable population, because that is in the interests of public safety.