I thank members from across the chamber for supporting my motion so that the debate could take place.
Members will recognise that I have been known to argue that the solution to most problems in our society is to go for a run. Today, however, I will not make that argument; instead, I will set out why improving public health is the solution to many, if not most, of the intractable long-term issues that our economy faces. I will, of course, weave into my argument the importance of being physically active.
The Scottish Fiscal Commission’s 2025 “Fiscal Sustainability Report”, which was published in April this year, set out that Scotland’s annual budget gap is set to widen in the coming decades, and that that is being driven in no small part by an ageing and less healthy population. The fact that the population of Scotland is predicted to age more quickly than that of the United Kingdom as a whole means that those pressures will arrive with us more quickly.
As a society, we are living longer, which is welcome, but there is a difference between life expectancy and healthy life expectancy, which is the number of years for which someone can expect to live in good health. Scotland’s average healthy life expectancy recently fell to a near 10-year low, with women expected to have 60 years of good health and men 59.6 years. Across the country, there is huge variation in healthy life expectancy. In North Ayrshire, men and women can expect to have around 52 healthy years of life, while people in Perth and Kinross can expect to have at least 13 more healthy years than that.
As we live longer, we are likely to spend more years in poor health, which means more years with chronic illness, disability or dependence on others for care, all of which comes at a price. The demand on the national health service grows as more people need more treatment for longer. Social care and welfare costs rise as more people are unable to work or care for themselves. On the other side of that coin, economic activity, productivity and tax revenues decline as the size and health of our working-age population declines. It is a vicious cycle and, as the SFC’s report makes clear, we must act to arrest it now if we are to have any hope of avoiding crippling budget challenges in years to come.
Healthcare already accounts for a major percentage of Scotland’s total budget. If we do not take tough decisions today, we risk our successors in the Parliament having to make impossible decisions a few years from now. The biggest opportunity for change is to reduce the demand for healthcare by increasing our healthy life expectancy. There are many ways in which to achieve that aim, but any approach must include reducing obesity, promoting a healthy diet and widening opportunities for activity. It means tackling poverty, improving our housing stock, making better use of education—not only to promote a healthy lifestyle but to create new opportunities—and, of course, increasing participation in sport and physical activity.
Over the summer, working with the think tank Enlighten, I published a paper that is aimed squarely at preventing illness. It sets out how we can embed prevention within our education system and make better use of the facilities and resources that we already have to prevent illness and to ensure that members of the next generation live longer, healthier lives.
We must encourage change not only among young people. The SFC tells us that the greatest challenge for our economy will come as those who are currently in their 30s and 40s reach old age. Although those who are over 55 at the moment are most likely to drink and smoke to excess, those in the generation below them are struggling with obesity, inactivity and a more sedentary lifestyle. Even a small change in habits today can have an outsize effect on health outcomes down the line. The biggest factors by a long way in a person’s long-term health outcomes in later years are their VO2 max, which is their ability to absorb oxygen, and their muscle mass in the middle years. Those two things can be improved if relatively small actions are continued over time, which is why I am such an advocate for a concerted shift towards prevention now. The sooner we act, the better.
Why is it so hard to make that change? First, prevention is, by its very nature, hard to measure. It is far easier to say how much we are spending on treating cancer or supporting people who are dealing with addiction than it is to say how many cancers have been prevented by improving people’s diets or how many people took a different path because a community organisation got five years’ guaranteed funding. Secondly, when the health and social care sector is under so much pressure, many within it are naturally resistant to the idea of any of the money that they are spending now being diverted towards prevention.
I suggest that prioritising one element does not necessarily mean deprioritising another. Rather, it might reduce the need in certain areas. That would have to be a gradual shift and not an overnight change but, because it would be gradual, we must begin the process now if we want to maximise its impact. We must be ready to overcome the resistance to changing priorities within the NHS and must accept the need to shift the less-effective elements of the existing spend to prevention.
Almost every aspect of what the NHS does today could be argued to be essential, but the judgment that we must make is not whether something is essential but whether it is effective. That criterion of effectiveness is crucial. Too often, the most effective long-term approach loses out to the one that is more politically expedient or cheaper today, even if that means a higher cost tomorrow. Equally, those of us whose role is one of scrutiny can be guilty of having our own reasons for choosing the path of opposition over collaboration. Short-term thinking tends to result in long-term losses, and although the nature of politics means that we will not—and, indeed, should not—agree on everything, we are in danger of losing sight of anything that is not on our immediate horizon.
The Scottish Fiscal Commission’s report lays out in stark detail the consequences of continuing down that short-term path when it comes to the intersection between health and our economy. Health is far from being the only factor that will influence our future fiscal position, but many of the other factors are, for better or worse, outside our control. Healthcare and the health of our population are very much the responsibility of this Parliament. As is true of anyone’s efforts to improve their own health, improving the nation’s health is not something that we can achieve instantly with one action; it is the result of a lot of small changes that work together, over time, to achieve a cumulative effect.
That end result has the potential to be transformational. We could see improved productivity thanks to a healthier workforce, an end to the seemingly ever-growing number of people who are condemned to a life on welfare because of preventable illness, and fewer people struggling with poor mental health. We could also take the pressure off Scotland’s NHS, better allowing it to see beyond the immediate future.
Taken together, those steps would give us a genuine chance to address the fiscal threat that the Scottish Fiscal Commission has set out and would take us at least some way towards closing the looming budget gap. Even more importantly, they would enable us to help more people in Scotland to live longer, healthier lives. Ultimately, if we in this chamber cannot find a way to focus on long-term gain for the country, how can we hope to convince the public to do the same for their own health?