I look forward to hearing the contributions from Mr Whitfield and his colleagues. We will see whether Mr Leonard has changed his mind since he sat on the committee. Mr Leonard is shaking his head. It is clear that Labour representatives on not just one but two parliamentary committees were happy to sign up to the recommendations. Clearly, Labour has had a rethink. No doubt that will be explained.
As we have been told by the convener, the committee was established following a recommendation by the Finance and Public Administration Committee, which had already raised concerns about the number of proposals that were coming forward to create new commissioner bodies. The committee concluded that
“continuing the trend for creating new advocacy-type SPCB supported bodies is not sustainable”
and it sought a new structure and set of guidelines. That was the task that our committee was given to consider.
It was very much at the front of our minds when we started to consider the issues that there are different types of commissioners. Some provide a primarily regulatory function, such as the Ethical Standards Commissioner, the SPSO or the Scottish Information Commissioner. Others perform primarily advocacy roles, such as the Scottish Commissioner for Children and Young People, although that commissioner also has regulatory functions.
The committee’s general view was that there is, of course, a place for commissioners that deal primarily with regulation, although we considered whether there might be some consolidation of those roles. On consideration, we did not see significant opportunities in that space. We also acknowledged that there might be a need for new commissioners in the future to deal with the regulation of matters that we cannot foresee. For example, the Scottish Biometrics Commissioner was a relatively new office that would not have been contemplated when the Parliament was formed, because the matters that it considers were not regarded as significant at that point. However, the committee had to draw a distinction between commissioners that perform regulatory functions and those being proposed purely, or mainly, to perform an advocacy role.
We were entirely sympathetic to members, some of whom are in the chamber for the debate, who have lodged members’ bills to create new commissioners to perform an advocacy role. That reflects perceived failures in the delivery of public services for particular groups. The question that the committee had to wrestle with is whether introducing such new commissioners, with all the expense of setting them up, would be the best way to address those gaps in provision.
Scotland is not an undergoverned country. We have 129 MSPs, 56 MPs, 32 local authorities, more than 1,000 local councillors, and a plethora of public organisations from health boards to quangos. If there are failures in the delivery of public services, to my mind, the answer is not to create yet another set of public appointees to try to address the problem. Surely the answer is to try to address the problem at source, and to better enable all the people who are currently paid to, and are in a position to, solve those problems and ensure that individuals are getting a fair deal.
The committee came to the conclusion that, although the calls for the creation of new advocacy commissioners are understandable, they do not represent good value for the public purse. Although it was not our primary consideration, public expenditure is important, because commissioners cost money. There is a risk of mission creep—that, once a commissioner has been established, it will seek to expand its functions and offices and demand more and more cash—which we need to be conscious of in times when public finances are constrained.
I was struck by the Minister for Public Finance’s evidence to the committee. I asked him what he regards as having the most impact: a report from a commissioner, a report from a cross-party committee of the Parliament, or a report from an external body. If I remember rightly, he answered that they were all one voice among others. The impact of a commissioner’s report is no more significant than that of a parliamentary committee. That was a significant piece of evidence.
I know that the committee’s conclusions will be a disappointment to those outwith the Parliament who are campaigning for new commissioners and to some MSPs, but resources are finite, and, if we accept the case for new advocacy commissioners, we must acknowledge that people could argue for an almost limitless number of new commissioners to be appointed.
When we took evidence from Jeremy Balfour, who is not with us today, on his proposal for a new commissioner for the disabled, he said that he accepted that argument, but he asked why we should pull up the drawbridge now. With all due respect to Mr Balfour, I think that that rather misses the point, because we do not have any pure advocacy commissioners right now, apart, possibly, from the Children and Young People’s Commissioner, and we could argue that children are in a different category to others, because they do not have votes and, therefore, do not have the direct voice in the democratic process that other groups have.
It was for those reasons that we came to the conclusions that we did in relation to the creation of new commissioners. I do not have time to cover all the other points that we discussed around the need for improved accountability and scrutiny of existing commissioners and the need for a dedicated committee—not necessarily a stand-alone committee—of this Parliament to scrutinise the work of commissioners. That is all covered in our detailed report. I commend it to members, and I also commend the convener’s motion, which I am pleased to support.
16:10