I thank the MSPs who signed my motion to enable us to have the debate, and I thank my business manager for allocating time for what I believe is an important issue that the Parliament and the Government must do more to address.
I brought the debate to the chamber as a result of being contacted, time and again, by constituents who have been struggling to access a national health service dentist and, more recently, by constituents who are being told that their dentist has decided to withdraw from NHS provision and who are being given a choice to either sign up to a monthly payment plan or leave the practice.
An example comes from an email that I received from a lady in Cowdenbeath some months ago. She stated:
“Dear Mr Rowley,
I am emailing you to see if there’s any advice or help you can give me as I am stressing out. I received an email from a local dentist saying they are no longer doing NHS only private and must decide by beginning of June or I will be put off list altogether—won’t have a dentist.
Mr Rowley I was with Breeze for 45 yrs. I am a pensioner in June. Tried six dentists in”
Dunfermline,
“even went in to them in person not taking any new NHS!!! This is absolutely shocking! Finally went down to Cowdenbeath dentist Stenhouse Street—not taking anyone on NHS just now.
Why can’t I get a dentist it’s a disgrace!!! Breeze offering private payment plan monthly, that’s not counting the treatment you might need and can’t afford.
Really upset me very much. Why can’t I get into a dentist what’s the problem!? This is a shocking disgrace. Hope to hear from you.”
Another lady, from south-west Fife, said:
“My current dentist has informed me that they are no longer offering NHS treatment. I have tried and exhausted all possible means of finding a new dentist. I am not in pain and am willing to go on a waiting list. Even the waiting lists are closed!!! So I find myself at a complete loss. I am usually reluctant to use the word ‘entitled’—but in this country, currently, NHS dental care is my entitlement. Yet there is absolutely no provision. What do you suggest I do?”
When I raised the matter directly with NHS Fife, its chief executive officer responded:
“There is a national shortage of qualified dentists currently and this remains a significant issue impacting NHS dentistry across Scotland, including here in Fife.
Health Boards like NHS Fife have no means of compelling practices to provide NHS dental services, and with the shift over recent years from smaller NHS-run practices to larger corporate entities, we have very limited influence over practice decisions.
We are, however, committed to supporting practices to improve access to NHS dentistry within our control and remit.”
I acknowledge that the Government is trying to address the issues with a 15 per cent increase in this year’s dental services budget, and I welcome the additional investment, including the establishment of the Scottish dental access initiative grant. That new grant has, in part, led to a new six-surgery facility opening in Dunfermline, which has registered its first 3,000 NHS patients since July.
That is very welcome, but much more will need to be done. A total of 3,000 people signing up so far shows the sheer volume of those who are not able to access NHS dentistry; the numbers across Scotland are in the tens of thousands.
When I found out about the welcome new developments, I wrote to people who had contacted me, including the two ladies I quoted earlier. One thanked me and said that she had been able to sign up with the new dentist in Dunfermline. The other lady responded that she had tried to register, but the lists were closed. When I looked on the website of the new practice, it said:
“We have been overwhelmed by the response from those who have signed up already. We have decided to pause sign ups for now to cater to those who have signed up already.”
As I said, it is very welcome that the Government now recognises that action is desperately required, but much more will be required to address the underinvestment, for a decade and more, that has led to the unacceptable situation in which tens of thousands of people find themselves unable to access NHS dentistry.
I will outline why that is important. NHS Fife has always emphasised that emergency care remains available. However, preventive dental care is significantly less expensive than the cost of treating advanced dental disease. In addition, maintaining good oral hygiene helps to prevent common problems such as tooth decay and gum disease, which can lead to tooth loss, bad breath and more serious health conditions such as heart disease, diabetes and respiratory infections, and which are linked to some forms of cancer.
It is therefore crucial that, in a developed country such as Scotland, the population is able to access dental care. As one constituent put it to me, being able to access a dentist must be a requirement that every citizen can expect.
I welcome the steps that the Government has taken this year, but much more must be done. If larger corporate entities are taking over smaller practices and removing NHS provision, we must be clear that alternative provision will be put in place. Dentistry is far too important to allow communities to be left beholden to such large corporate entities, which put profit before people.
We have to recognise that, while the Government has started to take action, much more has to be done. Every individual in the country should be able to access an NHS dentist, and if they cannot, the costs of that will be massive for people and their health and for the Government.