Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Alexander Dennis

Thursday 26 June 2025 Economy and Fair Work Committee About 09:30–11:00 Committee business 257 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

257 contributions · showing 201–257
Debbie McCreath Alexander Dennis
link

I can absolutely understand the feeling, but I would like to restate the fact that, if required, we will pay the grant back. It is not as though we are moving and not paying it back. I would just like to clarify that point.

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

I am sure that we will find out about the remedies later on.

Continuing on the matter of the Scarborough site, I note, Mr Davies, that you said that you have a long-term lease there. How long is the lease, and when was it entered into?

Paul Davies Alexander Dennis
link

I think that, potentially, it goes out to 2033. I imagine that it will be a 10-year lease, and it started a couple of years ago. I can check and come back to you on that, but I think that that is correct.

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

I understand that some warehousing in Scarborough has come into your possession in recent times—I do not know whether it is leased or what. Will you tell us about the decision making in that respect? Why did you decide to enter into that deal, and what leasing is going on there?

Paul Davies Alexander Dennis
link

Again, I can come back to the committee on the specifics of the logistics facility. The decision was taken after a rather unfortunate event that we had in Scarborough, when a mini-tornado tore part of the roof off our buildings and caused significant issues and challenges with regard to where we could house materials. We had nine temporary tents on site, and the adoption of the off-site kitting and logistics warehouse was a way of assisting our recovery from that unfortunate event.

10:45

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

You said earlier that the decision to move production to Scarborough, where you have a leased plant, had nothing to do with asset liquidation of the plants that you own in Scotland.

Paul Davies Alexander Dennis
link

Correct.

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

Okay. What would your decision to stick with a site with a long-term lease and to possibly get rid of your sites in Scotland do to your balance sheet?

Paul Davies Alexander Dennis
link

We are not getting rid of both our sites in Scotland. To be clear, we are suspending production at Larbert; we are not intending to do anything else with that site, although we will take away and consider the deputy convener’s question whether other options exist around chassis manufacturing. As you heard from the union members yesterday, we have been on a journey to extract ourselves from the Falkirk site, hence the investment in the Larbert facility.

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

You said earlier that none of the decisions had to do with NFI Group refinancing. Is that correct?

Paul Davies Alexander Dennis
link

Correct.

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

You said earlier that the decisions around Larbert and Camelon were reached in February of this year. Is that correct?

Paul Davies Alexander Dennis
link

That is correct.

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

Would you be willing to provide the committee with the timelines and the decision-making processes of the Alexander Dennis board and the NFI Group board on some of those decisions—that is, the ones that were taken in 2019 on refinancing and the timelines of your decision on Camelon and Larbert versus Scarborough?

Paul Davies Alexander Dennis
link

Absolutely.

Paul Davies Alexander Dennis
link

We can show you exactly the timeline and the backdrop to the decision-making process.

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

That would be useful for the committee and, of course, both Governments.

As you well know, Mr Davies, I have been around the Larbert site with your good self. You said earlier that it was decided that the site should be used for the production of double-deck buses but that you canna do the entire throughput there, because there is no paint shop. Why was it decided not to add certain parts of production to that site when it was developed?

Paul Davies Alexander Dennis
link

We had a phase 1 and a phase 2 approach. Phase 1 was to redevelop the site—you would not recognise it since your visit—to build the buses to a pre-paint condition and then move the vehicles to Falkirk for painting and finishing. There was an outline plan and a discussion with Scottish Enterprise about the opportunities and potentials to expand the site to put the painting and finishing capability into it.

It was always going to be a staged approach. However, as I have said, things have changed and, therefore, phase 2 has never been proposed, signed off or really expanded and developed, because we are not in a position to do that now.

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

I want to turn to international competition. You mentioned some of the difficulties that you face and the employer national insurance contributions hike. How much is that costing the company?

Paul Davies Alexander Dennis
link

On an annualised basis, the additional element is £2 million.

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

That is not an insignificant number.

The additional costs that you would face compared to competitors were skipped over earlier on. Would you say that the energy costs for your company in the UK—which will be the same in Scarborough as they will be in Falkirk—are probably around about four times higher than those of some of your international competitors?

Paul Davies Alexander Dennis
link

Correct.

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

So, that is a real difficulty for the company when it comes to sustainability. With regard to the international supply chain, are battery costs pretty significant?

Paul Davies Alexander Dennis
link

Yes, they are. We estimate that we are probably paying double for our batteries per kilowatt than Chinese manufacturers.

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

Indeed, Chinese manufacturers have a huge amount of Chinese lithium to call upon. Do you think that a UK industrial strategy should really delve into how we can overcome what some folk would say are unfair advantages in competition?

Paul Davies Alexander Dennis
link

My personal view is yes. However, the issue needs to be considered quite carefully in the context of valuing local content. Britishvolt, for example, perhaps went too big too soon and was not sustainable. I heard reference made yesterday to the Faraday battery challenge, which we are part of and which explores opportunities to do that type of work in the UK. We are happily supporting that project, because we think that there is value there.

From a bus industry standpoint, given the amount of public money that is going into our sector, doing something on a more boutique or smaller-scale level, such as bus manufacturing, would make a lot of sense. I have said to the UK bus manufacturing expert panel that we must be really careful with such a process, because we cannot afford to do something else that makes us even more uncompetitive. I agree with the principle as a sensible and logical way forward, but it must be carefully considered. Otherwise, it might make a difficult situation worse.

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

Okay. On other aspects of the international scenario, would you like to highlight to the committee areas where additional subsidy for other manufacturers exists elsewhere, or elements in which you cannot be competitive, because of the level of subsidy?

Paul Davies Alexander Dennis
link

I do not have the specifics of that. As I think that I answered earlier, I can point only to the European Commission investigation and some of the actions that have come out of that. I have not read its report in detail, but I know that it uncovered state help, because it resulted in tariffs being applied. In general, tariffs would just apply if you did not furnish the inquiry with information.

Battery costs, the cost of energy for manufacturing and the cost of employment are the key elements that make it challenging, when you compare Alexander Dennis against a domestic Chinese manufacturer.

Debbie McCreath Alexander Dennis
link

Last year, we contemplated taking forward an investigation with the UK trade remedies authority in light of the European Commission investigation into automotive practices. However, when we investigated that, we found that the onus was on industry, and we were told, too, that after paying all the legal fees associated with putting an application together to unearth all those challenges, we might not get the information that we were requiring. You might spend seven figures on a legal retainer and come out of the process 18 months later without anything.

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

So, basically, the costs of getting investigations done should be much lower if we are to get to grips with some of those things. Is that what you are saying?

Debbie McCreath Alexander Dennis
link

That would be helpful, particularly for us. As the committee is aware, we restructured last year, too. If your company is in a challenging financial position, having to find additional funding for an investigation is really quite tricky.

Paul Davies Alexander Dennis
link

There is another important element to consider. We were advised that such activity would have to be industry-wide and not something that we did independently. Our primary UK competitor, with whom we work on subsidy control and local content, has links to another manufacturing and equipment business that embarked on such an action, and it did not get anything out of it. Therefore, it does not make sense that it would have any appetite to join us in our action.

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

Thank you very much for coming here today. I am sure that you understand why some of the lines of questioning have been pursued. It is immensely frustrating for folk to hear that Scotland has invested in a company and that the Government south of the border has not, and now that company is moving south of the border. That said, I welcome your comment today that Alexander Dennis and NFI Group will be completely and utterly open book about some of the decisions that you have taken.

Paul Davies Alexander Dennis
link

Can I clarify one point that I made to you earlier? The business review that we undertook was in February, but we did not go through a board approval process until later, in May.

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

I am sure that that will all come out through the open-book approach.

Colin Smyth Lab The Convener · South Scotland
link

You mentioned the working group that has been set up between the UK Government and Scottish Government, and which you are not part of. Is there any ask that the company has made of the UK and Scottish Governments that you have not put on the record today? We have touched on the orders related to the Subsidy Control Act 2022. Is there anything else that you have not put on the record?

Debbie McCreath Alexander Dennis
link

We have captured everything related to the consultation. We have talked about the two short-term asks: the furlough scheme and the potential creation of fresh orders. Then, when it comes to the medium to longer term, we ask that local content and subsidy control be considered and that we try to find a solution to those problems.

In our submission to the UK comprehensive spending review, we asked through our joint group—as Paul Davies has said, we have down at Westminster an all-party group in which we work with our UK competitor—for buses to be considered as critical national infrastructure. We wanted that to be able to protect and safeguard the industry, and we wanted the industry to be seen as something that we need to nourish and protect. We are keen to make the committee aware that we previously asked for that.

Colin Smyth Lab The Convener · South Scotland
link

The decision will have a massive social and economic impact, particularly in the Falkirk and Larbert areas. What will be the scale of that impact? We know that 400 direct jobs will be lost as a result of the decision. What will be the impact on supply chain jobs? I have seen 1,600 mentioned, but I am not sure where that figure came from. What assessment have you made of the impact of the decision on those communities and of the number of jobs that will be lost in those communities?

Debbie McCreath Alexander Dennis
link

I am happy to share our economic impact analysis with the committee. Based on current modelling, the estimation is that 370 jobs will be affected in the wider supply chain, which is part of the challenge that we would face.

As for the effect on communities, the only communities about which I can give you some clarity at this time are in those areas of Scotland where Alexander Dennis people are employed. The majority of people are Falkirk-based, and North Lanarkshire is the next largest area where we have people, so it is predominantly in those two community regions that we would expect to see the largest impact, if what is proposed in the consultation comes to pass.

Colin Smyth Lab The Convener · South Scotland
link

Based on those figures, the impact will obviously be very substantial.

Daniel Johnson has a final supplementary question.

Daniel Johnson Lab Edinburgh Southern
link

I would just like to get clarification on a couple of points that arise from weaving together the analysis and some of the numbers that we have. Obviously, we are clear about total capacity, which is 1,600 orders, with 400 in Scotland. You say that you will need an additional number of orders—around 300—on an on-going basis, which would mean that a total output of about 1,400 would be required across all sites to keep the Scottish sites open. Is that roughly right?

Paul Davies Alexander Dennis
link

Yes. Scarborough’s capacity is about 1,200, but, as I said earlier, that assumes a level load and everything coming in at the right time.

Daniel Johnson Lab Edinburgh Southern
link

So, the total order book would amount to approximately 1,400.

Paul Davies Alexander Dennis
link

Yes, 1,400 or 1,500—something like that.

Daniel Johnson Lab Edinburgh Southern
link

When was the last time you had an annual output of 1,400?

Paul Davies Alexander Dennis
link

Last year. We delivered 1,400 buses to the market in 2024.

11:00

Daniel Johnson Lab Edinburgh Southern
link

That split suggests that about a quarter of your capacity is in Scotland and three quarters is in Scarborough. Is that roughly it?

Paul Davies Alexander Dennis
link

Yes, but it is complex.

Daniel Johnson Lab Edinburgh Southern
link

Is it difficult, because of the different product lines?

Paul Davies Alexander Dennis
link

The issue is not the product lines. It is complex because, in recent years, we have been carrying a level of non-productive time in which we have not been making buses. We have been retaining skills deliberately.

Daniel Johnson Lab Edinburgh Southern
link

So, it is capacity rather than throughput. I get that.

Before the various stages of investment, was the split always the same, or has there been a tilt towards Scarborough in the balance of capacity?

Paul Davies Alexander Dennis
link

I do not think that the split will have changed much, but I am happy to look back in time and give you the split in the volumes from both sites.

Daniel Johnson Lab Edinburgh Southern
link

Please do so, especially the split before the £8 million investment—or whatever it was. I am sorry—I forget the figure. What did that investment do to the split between Scarborough and Scotland?

Paul Davies Alexander Dennis
link

I do not think that it made a massive impact. It was negligible.

Daniel Johnson Lab Edinburgh Southern
link

That is great—that was all I wanted to clarify. Thank you very much.

Colin Smyth Lab The Convener · South Scotland
link

I very much thank both our witnesses for taking the time to come to the committee this morning.

That brings us to the end of the evidence session, and we will now move into private session.

11:02 Meeting continued in private until 11:24.

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:30 Alexander Dennis Committee business · 257

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.