To ask the Scottish Government what assessment it has made of any regional variability in the availability of apprenticeships. (S6O-04862)
Official Report · Chamber
Apprenticeships (Availability)
Portfolio Question Time Education and Skills
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Graeme Dey SNP 5
- Evelyn Tweed SNP 2
- Annabelle Ewing SNP 2
- Kenneth Gibson SNP 1
- Stephen Kerr Con 1
- Carol Mochan Lab 1
The record
12 contributionsSkills Development Scotland has operational responsibility for apprenticeships in Scotland. SDS acknowledges that regional variability in apprenticeship availability is influenced by the geographic distribution and recruitment activity of employers across key sectors of the economy. As apprenticeships are demand led and aligned with employer needs, the number and type of opportunities naturally differ across regions.
To manage this situation, SDS undertakes continuous labour market analysis and produces annual regional skills assessments. These assessments inform the strategic management of apprenticeship starts at both national and regional levels, which ensures alignment with industry priorities and local economic conditions.
My Stirling constituency covers a vast area, but the majority of apprenticeships are centred in Stirling city. How is the minister engaging with stakeholders to ensure the wide availability of apprenticeships, especially in more rural areas?
A key priority for the Scottish Government is to encourage apprenticeship delivery in island and rural communities. As part of that, we introduced a rural uplift for modern apprenticeship delivery, which is an increased payment for training providers, to encourage provision in island and rural areas. In addition, travel and subsistence support, including accommodation funding, is also available to support apprentices where they have to attend formal off-the-job training outwith normal daily travel, if required as part of the MA framework.
The member’s constituency is home to one of the most celebrated rural apprenticeship successes in the shape of Marc Ingram, who works at Blair Drummond Smiddy. Marc was the 2024 Scottish apprentice of the year and is an amazing young man whose journey highlights the incredible transformative impact that an apprenticeship can have on someone’s life.
I have received requests for supplementary questions from three members. I intend to take all three.
link
Concerns remain that some schools allegedly advise as many young people as possible to go to university, even when an apprenticeship or graduate apprenticeship would provide better prospects.
Given the chronic shortage of construction and engineering workers, for example, what steps are being taken, in partnership with schools, to encourage more young people to take up an apprenticeship?
There is no doubt that the problem that Kenny Gibson highlights exists. I have visited many schools where the culture is very much as we would want it to be when it comes to promoting the full range of career paths, but that is not always the case, as I have heard directly from young people.
The work that is under way in the careers space through the careers collaborative is designed to ensure that, in all our education settings—not only schools but colleges and universities as well—there is a full and complete offering to young people of opportunities to pursue careers.
We have an issue around construction, which Kenny Gibson mentioned. There is, for example, a disconnect between the number of young people who go to college to do construction-related courses and the number who then go into the construction sector. I offer Kenny Gibson the reassurance that we are very much alive to that issue.
link
On the same theme, yesterday, Alan Wilson of Scotland’s electrical trade body, SELECT, warned that
“Scotland absolutely must not be left behind when it comes to apprenticeship funding.”
That is how he feels. He highlighted the emergence of a two-tier system. Funding for electrical apprentices in England stands at £23,000, and in Scotland it is £8,000. It is three times more in England. He is right to say that we need electricians here and now, that we will need electricians in the future, and that a two-tier system is totally unacceptable.
With a 30 per cent real-terms cut over seven years—by his calculation—and no increase in funding in that time, does the minister accept that those warnings are real, and will he now act to close that unacceptable gap?
I am very much alive to the competing arguments for funding in the post-16 education space. I regularly hear asks for an increase in the payment rates, but I also hear asks for increases in all sorts of other spend in that area. Through the reform work, we are trying to look very closely at the needs of the economy and to prioritise those sectors. As part of that work, we will, in due course, look at the payment rates, but I cannot stand here today and say that we will suddenly magic up a pot of money to address the issue, although I take the point on board.
link
Construction apprenticeships are essential and there is demand for them. However, in my South Scotland region there are two areas that we must work on. The first is to better link employers and colleges to agree numbers in order to meet the skills gap. Secondly, local qualification courses are a real barrier in rural areas, and long distances mean that we lose apprentices early on because of the difficulty in accessing courses. What can be done to address those issues?
I would always encourage the training providers, whether in the private or public sector, to have a relationship with employers and trade bodies in order to understand demand. However, I say gently that one of the issues is an expectation that courses will be provided in every locality, when those who seek the courses cannot provide the critical mass of students to go to that college, or a pipeline that allows the college to create and sustain an offering.
Therefore, I encourage an open dialogue between those sectors and the local colleges in particular. However, there must be a realistic starting point, with the numbers required to create and sustain the courses.
I note that the member who lodged question 2 is not here. I expect an explanation and an apology.
For question 3, I call Katy Clark.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 26 Jun 2025 →- General Question Time Questions · 1
- Wild Goats (Protection) Questions · 4
- Student Accommodation Questions · 6
- Local Road User Charging Schemes Questions · 4
- Planning Appeals Process (Reform) Questions · 4
- “Housing to 2040” (Adaptations System) Questions · 4
- NHS Forth Valley (Bus Links) Questions · 6
- Neurodevelopment of Children Born Prematurely (Support) Questions · 4
- ADHD and Autism Assessments (NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde) Questions · 4
- Cancer Treatment (Waiting Times) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- National Health Service First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cancer Treatment (Waiting Times) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- “Unique Among Cancers” First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Visitor Levy (Reported Delays) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Office for National Statistics (Inflation Statistics) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Healthcare Services (Highlands) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Radio Teleswitch Service Switch-off First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Sexual Violence First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Free School Meals First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Transvaginal Mesh (Reports) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Amey (Redundancies) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Rural Nurseries First Minister’s Questions · 2
- The Usual Place (Funding) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Private Jets (Charge) First Minister’s Questions · 3
- Gull Control Members’ business · 60
- Business Motion Business motions · 1
- Education and Skills Questions · 1
- Apprenticeships (Number of Places) Questions · 4
- Apprenticeships (Availability) Questions · 12
- Children in Care (Exclusion from School) Questions · 9
- Children with Disabilities and Additional Support Needs (Holiday Hub Provision) Questions · 8
- People with Hearing and Sight Difficulties (Awareness in Schools) Questions · 4
- College Funding (Business Needs) Questions · 10
- Young People’s Neurodivergence, Mental Health and Wellbeing Statement · 35
- Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Bill Bill debate · 18
- Product Regulation and Metrology Bill Bill debate · 16
- Employment Rights Bill Bill debate · 8
- Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Bill Bill debate · 15
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 2
- Motion without Notice Business motions · 1
- Decision Time Decision time · 23
- Glasgow’s Bus Services Members’ business · 63
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.