Scotland has a proud history of invention and innovation, from the telephone to the television, and from the pneumatic tyre to penicillin. That legacy lives on today in the entrepreneurs and innovators across our country who are working hard to build businesses, generate ideas and create jobs in every community. However, if we are serious about empowering those entrepreneurs—not just celebrating them—we need more than press releases or appointments; we need a plan that delivers.
While I welcome Ana Stewart’s appointment as chief entrepreneur—and I thank Mark Logan for his valuable work—the motion before us paints a picture that simply does not reflect the reality that is experienced by many businesses. As Daniel Johnston highlighted, the rate of innovation-active businesses in Scotland has fallen from 50 per cent to just 32 per cent, putting us behind every English region and Wales. Despite a small improvement in the number of high-growth firms, Scotland ranks 11th out of 12 UK regions on the Government’s own innovation scorecard. Other key indicators are going in the wrong direction: business R and D investment is low, patent grants have dropped sharply and academic income from business collaboration has fallen in real terms.
Entrepreneurs do not need another ambition from Government; they need practical support. They need the investment to scale, the capital to grow and the skills pipeline that meets their needs. On all three fronts, the Government is falling short. Let us be clear: this is not just about tech start-ups in our cities. Innovation must be inclusive; it must reach rural communities, social enterprises and sectors that have often been overlooked. That includes support for more women and minority entrepreneurs—something that Ana Stewart has rightly championed through the pathways work that she co-authored. Good ideas need more than good intentions, however; they need funding, access and consistent support.
On investment, the number of risk capital deals under £10 million fell last year. Larger deals collapsed, with the total value down by 69 per cent. There is a chronic lack of long-term capital, particularly for capital-intensive sectors such as manufacturing and life sciences.
We face a growing digital gap when it comes to skills. As Foysol Choudhury rightly said, we are creating far more digital jobs than we are producing qualified graduates. The number of computer science teachers is falling, and employers are struggling to recruit people with even basic IT skills.
When it comes to in-work training, which is critical for both new entrants and workers who are looking to reskill or upskill, many businesses have told the Economy and Fair Work Committee recently that they are deeply concerned about the funding mechanism changes that the Scottish Government is proposing in the Tertiary Education and Training (Funding and Governance) (Scotland) Bill. There is a real risk, and a fear, that those changes will undermine the ability of training providers to meet the needs of businesses, just so that, rather than simply funding our colleges better, the Government can shore up its bad decision to cut college funding by 17 per cent since 2021. Our colleges are facing growing demand, with long waiting lists for skills-shortage subjects and falling apprenticeship numbers—all while they are being asked to do more with less.
The Government is doing the same with our enterprise agencies. South of Scotland Enterprise had its budget slashed by more than 25 per cent—£8.7 million has gone from the organisation that is responsible for supporting SMEs, fostering innovation and creating jobs. Nevertheless, SOSE continues to deliver, from the Techscaler hub in Dumfries to support for innovative, sustainable manufacturing businesses such as the Eco Group in Annan. Ambition needs to be backed by resources, however.
The Government claims that it wants to build a world-class entrepreneurial culture—that is a central goal in the national strategy for economic transformation. However, two years on, Audit Scotland has, rightly, questioned the lack of clear investment plans and noted weak transparency in how the NSET is being delivered. The most recent progress report offers generalised updates but little clarity on what is working and what is not, or why.
We cannot afford a strategy that continues to overpromise and underdeliver. We need a different approach—one in which our enterprise agencies pivot, as Lorna Slater said, and are empowered to provide long-term strategic support for entrepreneurship; in which colleges are properly funded to deliver the skills that businesses need; in which in-work training and digital education are seen as national priorities; and in which the Scottish Government uses its influence to bring together industry, academia and communities to drive innovation and to share its rewards. That is why Labour is asking the Parliament to support our amendment. Although early stage support matters, it is scale-ups, skills and sustained investment that will deliver lasting impact.
Scotland has the talent. We have the ideas. However, unless we match ambition with action and get the basics right, innovation will remain concentrated in too few sectors and too few places. Let us deliver a truly inclusive, entrepreneurial Scotland, where innovation thrives in every community, rural and urban, and where those who drive our economy forward are backed every step of the way on that important journey.
16:41