I have to be honest: when I first saw that we were to have this debate, I thought to myself, “Wow, that’s brave!”. During the same week that we heard about another massive delay to and the spiralling costs of the Glen Rosa, and on top of concerns that I was already aware of about school campuses, healthcare and rural depopulation, we learned—to my great surprise—that we were to have a debate, led by the SNP, on how we empower Scottish islands.
It is true that our islands contain many wonderful people—islanders are often very resilient and engaging—and there is much good work that goes on in our islands. I share the Government’s desire—it is probably the only desire that I share with the SNP—to ensure that our island communities are empowered, but are we really empowering them?
The cabinet secretary talked about the new carbon-neutral project on the islands and the successes of the national islands plan. I note, too, that the motion from the SNP admits that
“further action to tackle island challenges”
is needed, but that is quite the understatement, in my opinion. A lot can be said in a plan, but a plan is not the provider. Where we choose to invest and what we choose to support make a difference to the lives of our islanders.
I have yet to go to an island where the issue of ferries is not raised, yet—as Douglas Ross rightly pointed out—the SNP motion does not mention ferries at all. On ferry delays, the First Minister and the Deputy First Minister both admitted last week that it is not good enough—and indeed it is not. To be honest, I do not think that it is good enough that the First Minister and the Deputy First Minister said that line. It is their job to ensure that delays do not happen, but, time and again, they do.
Island community impact assessments offer an opportunity to ensure that the implementation of new policy makes practical sense for the islands, but the message that I too often hear is that it does not. Many people feel that authorities do those assessments because they have to, rather than because they see value in them.
It was interesting to listen to the wide range of views in the debate. Jamie Halcro Johnston and Pam Gosal mentioned ferries, the future of services on the islands, job prospects and tourism. Rhoda Grant gave a well-rounded speech in which she covered a wide range of issues that matter to our islands, including the point that I just made about island community impact assessments.
Kenneth Gibson told us, quoting Arthur Conan Doyle, that the islands are
“the epitome of the whole of Scotland”,
and he is right. It is elementary, my dear cabinet secretary, that the islands are the epitome of Scotland, and we should be serving them well—they are a microcosm of Scotland.
Beatrice Wishart talked about innovative solutions for islands, such as tunnels, and the requirement for more housing, and she gave a bit of a telling-off about the spelling of Up Helly Aa. Ariane Burgess talked about the uniqueness of our islands and the importance of devolving power to our councils in island communities. She also talked about Scotland’s islands being at a critical point in their 5,000-year history.
Fergus Ewing said that islanders should be at the heart of operations that affect them. We should not have to wait for the next session of Parliament for islanders to be on the boards of groups that take decisions that affect their daily lives. He also talked about the book “The Blunders of Our Governments”, which I have read part of. I heard that the authors were going to do an update to the book on the Scottish Government, but it was going to be too heavy to lift, so they had to stop.
I am not greatly surprised that the SNP did not like what Douglas Ross had to say, but he is right. When I go to the islands, and I have been to quite a few recently, this is what they are talking about. Not surprisingly, what we heard from the SNP in the debate was Brexit, Brexit and more Brexit, but Brexit is not causing the problems on our islands. The ferry delays and the housing delays are caused by the Scottish Government; they are not caused by Brexit.
The only person who talks more about having something to blame is Richard Leonard when he blames the rich for always being at fault. However, I say to him that I respect that.
I, too, welcome residents from the island of Mull to the gallery. It is wonderful that they have managed to get a ferry across, and I hope that they can manage to get the ferry back home today.
The Mull school project is a classic example of things going wrong when we do not truly listen to and empower our island communities. However, it is not too late; in all seriousness, I say that there is something that we can do about that.
During the debate and discussion about the Mull school project, I tried very hard not to form an opinion on what the right location was for a new school campus, because I felt quite strongly that, ultimately, the location of a new school should be the community’s decision. I fundamentally believe that. However, I was conscious that there would be families in Tobermory that would prefer the school to be rebuilt there, reducing the need for their children to travel. I could not help but recognise—I think that Ariane Burgess and Rhoda Grant touched on this—that for the whole island to be successful, it is vital that all are listened to. I have been contacted time and again by people across the island raising concerns about the consultation process. In my opinion, the financial impact on the council was, ultimately, a much bigger consideration for councillors in Argyll and Bute than the views of the residents of Mull themselves. That is the problem.
Ninety-eight per cent of Scotland is rural, and 17 per cent of the population of Scotland lives in rural areas, but it is not just about numbers. Rural life is built into our very cultural heritage, and the traditions, languages and history of rural areas are baked into our national identity. Rural service delivery comes with a higher cost, and if we want rural areas and islands to thrive, we must accept that.
In communities such as those on Mull, education that relies on the ferries, the weather and the separation of families is never a good thing. Mull required a bespoke arrangement. It needed community, Government and council to come together to agree a funding package for primary and secondary education that delivered for the island and provided equity in education provision. The specific nature of the debate for a fragile community such as Mull necessitated the involvement of the Government in order for the right decision to be made. I still believe that there is time for the Government to act to support those in the gallery and the whole community of Mull, and I urge the cabinet secretary to take that point away.
Big changes will not happen overnight, but more and more we discuss depopulation and how to stem it. I wonder whether the lack of any real empowerment is the driver that leads to further depopulation of our islands, as in the case of Mull.
There might be a handful of successes that I could agree with the cabinet secretary on, and a few pieces of work that are welcomed by the islands, but are they really empowered?
I say to the minister that he should go to the islands without an agenda. He should sit down and have a coffee or go into the pub or the local shop and talk to people. He should talk to islanders about education and health, the visitor levy and fisheries. If he is really brave, he could talk to them about ferries. Then, he should come back to Parliament and stand up and tell us whether he really believes that our island communities are empowered.
My own feeling is that—just as we heard from Kate Forbes and John Swinney on ferries last week—what the Government is doing is not nearly good enough.
16:50