To ask the First Minister what steps the Scottish Government is taking to address the performance of NHS 24, in light of reports that nearly one in five calls to the service went unanswered last year. (S6F-04075)
Official Report · Chamber
NHS 24 (Performance)
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- John Swinney SNP 4
- Sandesh Gulhane Con 2
- Alison Johnstone 1
- Jackie Dunbar SNP 1
- Jackie Baillie Lab 1
The record
9 contributions
link
NHS 24 continues to strive to improve its call-handling times. However, I apologise to anyone who has experienced an extended wait.
Calls to NHS 24 can be recorded as unanswered for a variety of reasons, not all of which are related to waiting times. Callers are offered a range of options, including signposting to NHS Inform for self-care advice or to other services that might be more clinically appropriate to meet their needs.
NHS 24’s workforce has increased by almost 50 per cent since 2014, with a record number of call handlers and clinical advisers in place, and we have increased NHS 24’s budget to a record £118.3 million this year.
I declare an interest as a practising national health service general practitioner.
First Minister, I have worked in out-of-hours services. The staff are working flat out, and the patients I saw were distressed and desperate for help. However, last year, more than 300,000 calls to NHS 24 were abandoned, with one person left waiting more than four hours just to get through. Those are not just statistics; they are real people left without urgent health advice when they need it most. No manager has been held accountable for that debacle, yet the Scottish Government is spending £118.3 million on NHS 24 this year.
First Minister, stop talking about money and start talking about outcomes. For that level of spending, the public deserve much better. Will the First Minister guarantee that, next year, we will see significant improvements for desperate patients?
Always speak through the chair.
link
I repeat a point that I made earlier, which is that calls can be abandoned for a variety of reasons, not all of which are related to waiting times. The message menu that members of the public hear includes a range of signposting options that encourage people to seek advice elsewhere, particularly when the service is under pressure. Dr Gulhane will be familiar with those options from his professional background. He will also know that not all callers need to get through to NHS 24, as some might be able to get advice from NHS Inform that addresses their concerns.
Having spent time with NHS call handlers, as the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Social Care has done, and having listened to the professional advice that they give, I would say two things. First, I commend the quality and strength of the advice available through the telephone service, which is of a high clinical level. Secondly, I believe that the signposting to face-to-face services is undertaken very effectively.
I am concerned about the data that Dr Gulhane refers to, because I cannot quite understand how a call could be waiting for four hours to be answered. I will interrogate that data further, as the extremity of that situation causes me concern, and I will look more closely at the long waits that Dr Gulhane raises.
On the whole, I believe that NHS 24 serves us well. However, I acknowledge that, during periods of high demand, people might wait longer than they would wish.
link
Can the First Minister outline how the Scottish Government is working to implement the recommendations in its report on the redesign of urgent care, which was published in January? Specifically, is the Government targeting current staffing levels at NHS 24?
link
A key issue—which relates to Dr Gulhane’s question—is that of capacity. Over time, the Government has been expanding capacity in NHS 24. As a consequence of the redesign of urgent care, we invested an additional £4 million to enable NHS 24 to recruit more staff and reduce call waiting times. That investment also supports public awareness about when to contact 111 and how to access other services.
link
The First Minister will know that, when NHS 24 triages a call, the caller can be phoned back by a nurse or doctor—often more than once. The caller is then triaged again by the health board, and it can take hours before they are seen. Thomas Rodger, who was 27 years old and from Falkirk, phoned NHS 24 several times before dying in hospital because he was struggling to breathe. Will the First Minister publish data on the time from the initial call to the point of treatment?
link
I will explore that point. However, it might be difficult to provide a complete picture other than in an individual case. I understand that, in the case that Jackie Baillie raises, that would undoubtedly be possible. I stress that I am not a clinician, but, from what Jackie Baillie said about that case, it sounds like a call that should have gone directly to the Scottish Ambulance Service, because, if someone has difficulty breathing, that raises some pretty acute issues. I simply offer that as an observation, and I am very sorry to hear the circumstances that Jackie Baillie puts to me.
We could consider Jackie Baillie’s suggestion in relation to individual cases, as there would be merit in exploring the journey that individuals have to go through, and it would be possible to do so. Many of us will have had the experience of having to tell our story multiple times. If that process can be made smoother, we should absolutely aim to do so. However, at a systemic level, it would be difficult to collect or assemble the kind of data that Jackie Baillie is asking for.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 15 May 2025 →- General Question Time Questions · 1
- Gypsy Traveller Community (Public Apology) Questions · 7
- National Health Service (Delayed Discharges) Questions · 6
- Railway Infrastructure (East Kilbride Enhancement Project) Questions · 8
- Stroke Thrombectomy Services Questions · 4
- Non-domestic Rates (Self-catering Operators) Questions · 4
- Legislation to End Conversion Therapy Practices Questions · 5
- Ferries First Minister’s Questions · 19
- Ferries First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Social Care (Availability of Care Homes) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Disability Benefits (Reductions) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- NHS 24 (Performance) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- United Kingdom-United States of America Trade Deal (Implications for Businesses) First Minister’s Questions · 7
- Nature Restoration Fund First Minister’s Questions · 2
- UHI Perth First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Childhood Cancer Diagnosis (Financial Support) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Wave Energy (Orkney) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Accessible Housing (Clackmannan) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- British Horse Society “Dead Slow” Campaign First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Glasgow’s Pride (Political Party Participation) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Ninewells Hospital (Maternity Services) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Second Home Ownership Members’ business · 38
- Portfolio Question Time Questions · 1
- Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills (Responsibilities) Questions · 21
- Forced Adoption Questions · 7
- Vocational Skills Training (Onshore Wind and Solar Industries) Questions · 4
- Education (Funding and Staff Retention in Island Communities) Questions · 4
- Dyslexia (Information on Reasonable Workplace Adjustments for School Leavers) Questions · 8
- Schools (Computing Science) Questions · 8
- Violence against Teachers and School Staff (South Ayrshire) Questions · 9
- Secure Care and the Wider Care System Statement · 30
- Scotland in Today’s Europe Debate · 108
- Appointment of Patient Safety Commissioner for Scotland Debate · 8
- Decision Time Decision time · 11
- Corrections Procedure · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.