Deputy Presiding Officer,
“Being on the streets almost destroyed me. Walking, walking, with no sleep.”
“I’d just sit on the bench by the river. It was minus 6, then minus 2 in the morning when the sun shone ... I’m not safe here.”
“I can’t sleep, because ... tomorrow, what is coming?”
Those are the words of Sofija, Kunal and Tsehay: three people who came to Scotland looking for a better life and who suffered violent abuse, hunger, ill health and destitution. It is for Sofija, Kunal and Tsehay, and for far too many other people like them, that I speak today.
I am honoured and grateful to have the opportunity to bring this issue, which is literally a matter of life and death and which involves one of the most foundational human rights, to the chamber. I thank all those who have worked so generously, meticulously and courageously, including I-SPHERE—the institute for social policy, housing, equalities research—the Joseph Rowntree Foundation, other members of the fair way Scotland partnership and, of course, Professor Jen Ang. It is thanks to her that we are debating the subject today, and I hope that we can do justice to her integrity, expertise and vision. I also thank colleagues from across the chamber for supporting the motion and the debate, and for our discussion at yesterday’s meeting of the cross-party group on migration.
When we say that someone is destitute, we mean that they are shut out from the simplest things that make human lives possible, usually from food and clothing, and often from shelter and home. When we think of destitution, we think of distance—places that are torn by conflict or disaster, and histories of dispossession and famine. However, there are people living in Scotland today who are destitute. There are people dying in destitution here, in Scotland, right now.
What do we call that reality? If there was nothing that we could do, we would call it a tragedy. However, if we could make change but we do not, and if we could open those doors to basic food, clothes and shelter but we keep them shut, what do we call it? We call it injustice. We call it, as it is, a breach of fundamental human rights. We call it, I believe, collective shame.
The Scottish Government has acted, and I commend the work that it has begun, following the work of the Equality, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee—on which I am proud to serve—and through its work with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities in producing the “Ending Destitution Together” strategy. That strategy has enabled the life-saving work of the fair way Scotland partnership in Aberdeen, Glasgow and Edinburgh.
It is not enough—too many doors are still closed and still locked. However, we now have the keys. Jen Ang’s legal briefing, “Ending Destitution in Scotland—A Road Map for Policymakers”, is clear and challenging. It sets out the ways in which people in Scotland are denied access to basic provisions through intentional and direct exclusion, indirect mechanisms and a lack of information, education, courage and care. It shows how the Scottish Government, supported by all of us as critical friends, can act to open those locked doors and to make real the rights of our destitute neighbours.
I ask the Scottish Government to commit to five tangible actions, all of which are within devolved competence. The first is to widen access to universal services and benefits, with a systematic review to ascertain exactly where and how that can be done. The word “universal” should mean just that—initiatives that are meant to reduce inequality and poverty must include people who are stranded by the widest inequality and struck by the deepest destitution. That includes people with no recourse to public funds or with restricted or uncertain eligibility, or NRPF/RE.
The second action is to resource the fair way Scotland partnership sufficiently so that it can respond to the real level of need across Scotland. We know that that model is working and is opening doors to support, accommodation, advice and cash payments for essential needs. At present, however, the partnership simply does not have the capacity to help everyone who needs it.
The third action is to create a new Scottish crisis, or hardship, grant, using powers that the Scottish Government has under the Scotland Act 2016. That could fill the widest gaps and give emergency help to those who are in desperate need when no other financial or practical support is out there. When people slip between the provisions of existing law, the fall can be fast and fatal.
The fourth action is to increase funding urgently for housing, immigration and asylum legal aid. The United Kingdom Government has said that it will do that in England and Wales, so we have no excuse not to do the same here. Much of Scotland is a legal aid desert, especially for people whose lives and futures depend on being able to access justice.
The fifth action is to engage positively and robustly with the UK Government on the NRPF system. We want that system to be abolished altogether. It does not do what its makers intended—it does not reduce immigration, it does not reflect what most people would consider to be fair, and it does not save money. It is a brutal weapon of the hostile environment, raining blows of hunger, cold, fear and isolation on those with least to protect them. Until that system is gone, however, Scotland must minimise its harm. That means advocating clarity, transparency and the removal of Scottish benefits and assistance from its scope.
We are not in the chamber for this debate simply as representatives of our parties. We are here as human beings—as representatives of a Scotland that cares, that welcomes and that remembers shared histories of destitution. It is a Scotland that knows of the utter poverty that takes away agency, choice and hope before it takes people’s lives, years before their time. Hearts starve as well as bodies, as all feminists and socialists know.
This is a joint endeavour—a shared opportunity to do something that will make a direct difference to those in the bitterest of need. We can all play our part. We can all speak more loudly in urging the UK Government to make the transformational change that we know is needed, in working with our allies in the UK and devolved Parliaments to make that case and in working with our councillors to maximise support and services at local authority level.
Most of all, here and now, we call on the Scottish Government to act on the recommendations in Jen Ang’s briefing. We have a road map to show the way ahead, but do we have the integrity to follow it? For Tsehay, Sofija and Kunal, and for all the other people who are facing destitution in Scotland, we must.