Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Public Services Reform (Scotland) Act 2010 (Part 2 Further Extension) Order 2025 [Draft]

Tuesday 11 March 2025 Finance and Public Administration Committee About 11:00–11:15 Subordinate legislation 40 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

40 contributions
Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

The next item on our agenda is evidence from the Minister for Public Finance on the draft Public Services Reform (Scotland) Act 2010 (Part 2 Further Extension) Order 2025. The minister is joined by Angus Macleod, head of the public bodies support unit for the Scottish Government. I invite the minister to make a short opening statement.

Ivan McKee SNP Glasgow Provan
link

Public service reform is a huge challenge, but a proper and appropriate use of the correct levers can directly support the Government’s priority of delivering effective and sustainable public services. In turn, strong public services are better placed to deliver our key priorities of growing the economy, eradicating child poverty and tackling the climate crisis. The powers that are contained in the order are one such lever. They offer important tools to drive public service reform and can be used to adjust the configuration of the public bodies landscape in order to release funds for front-line services and better meet future needs. In some cases, they can also be used to unlock barriers to reform. At a time when resources are stretched and demands on public services are increasing, public sector bodies need to ensure that services remain affordable and sustainable in the longer term, while continuing to support better outcomes for people across Scotland. In many cases, that will require reform and changes to the way that public sector bodies operate.

The order-making powers will enable small-scale changes to be made in a more proportionate and flexible way than would be possible if we had to find a place in the parliamentary legislative programme to introduce and progress primary legislation. I stress that the use of the orders is restricted to two situations: first, to improve the effectiveness, efficiency and economy of public service functions—for example, by establishing the Poverty and Inequality Commission as a statutory public body—and, secondly, to reduce or remove burdens on any public or private sector organisation. Section 17 of the 2010 act has been used to reduce burdens on businesses. For example, orders have been used to amend requirements relating to agricultural tenancies and to streamline and simplify the planning system. Those powers are subject to safeguards in the 2010 act, under which any proposed changes to primary legislation through the order-making powers are subject to rigorous examination and scrutiny. A strict super-affirmative procedure applies to any order that is made using those powers. The responsibility remains with public bodies to address and to try to resolve any issues by other means before turning to the order-making powers.

The public consultation on the powers went live on 16 December last year and ran until 10 February this year. It received 21 responses, mainly from organisations. Sixteen of those responses agreed to extend the powers by a further five years, four opposed the extension and one was neutral. Reasons that were given in favour of the extension included supporting more effective and efficient operations and providing the flexibility to effect change. The small number of responses that opposed the extension of the powers mainly focused on the potential for abuse of the powers or the potential for the Government to reduce the authority of public bodies. I believe that those concerns are addressed by the safeguards in the 2010 act.

I conclude by reminding the committee that, unless the Parliament renews the order-making powers every five years, they are lost forever. The Parliament last renewed the powers in June 2020, so they must be signed off by the Parliament by 2 May this year if they are to continue from June 2025. I look forward to answering the committee’s questions.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

They will be “lost forever”? You are saying that there is no pressure on the committee, then.

One thing that is said under your policy objectives is that the order will make things

“more streamlined and flexible than primary legislation”.

Has the Scottish Government considered at any point trying to make the process of primary legislation more streamlined and flexible?

Ivan McKee SNP Glasgow Provan
link

That is a good question. I am sure that my colleague the Minister for Parliamentary Business would be delighted to come to the committee and comment on that. However, I will say that we are always striving to make processes within Government more effective and efficient. I am sure that any thoughts on how we can do that in the legislative process would be very welcome.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

It is interesting that, in point 3 of the letter from the finance and resilience directorate of the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body, there is a thing called “Ministerial salary sacrifice”. You look reasonably comfortable, despite your hair shirt today, minister. You will be glad to know that the committee had a whip-round for you before you arrived this morning, given the 15-year voluntary—I would put “voluntary” in inverted commas—freeze on ministerial salaries. The letter also says that there is no intention of changing that freeze. In my view, it is hard to see how the public will continue to value the work of ministers if they do not seem to value it themselves.

Ivan McKee SNP Glasgow Provan
link

That is a matter for the First Minister, and I do not want to say any more on that.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

Are you suggesting that I should put that directly to the First Minister when he comes to the Conveners Group in a week or two?

Ivan McKee SNP Glasgow Provan
link

I would not want to make any such suggestions. I am sure that the committee will make up its own mind on what matters it wants to put forward. I would say that it is genuinely a privilege to serve as a minister in the Scottish Government, regardless of any issues around salary sacrifice.

Liz Smith Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Minister, I do not have any issues with the order that you have set out. However, it raises issues that we have been wrestling with in the committee for a long time, and our predecessor committee—the Finance and Constitution Committee—in the previous session of Parliament was doing exactly the same. We are all struggling to get a handle on what the criteria are for measuring public sector reform.

I have heard you and Shona Robison say in the chamber several times that there has been quite a lot of improvement in the efficiency of public services. It is not easy to see that, and I think that you would probably agree. Do you have any way of helping the committee to know what criteria we should be looking for to see how well we are advancing with public sector reform?

Ivan McKee SNP Glasgow Provan
link

That is a good question. Because it is a complex system, it is not simply a case of one policy intervention making one difference that you can then measure.

We talked earlier about the landfill tax, and there you have a much cleaner line of sight when we make an intervention: we can see the behavioural change, the tax numbers and how that flows through. On the more general policy ambition, it is the nature of public service reform to have to deal with many interlocking bodies, policies and objectives at different levels.

There is a measure in the amount of money that we can demonstrably save by driving more efficiency across the system. That is one hard measure, and we are focused on measuring savings. There are also measures around what you might call the top line or the ultimate priorities of the Government’s agenda, of reducing poverty, growing the economy and tackling the climate crisis. We have top-line measures, but, as I said, there are clearly many different policy objectives that drive into and can influence those.

I suppose that it is a question of looking for more intermediate measures, many of which are covered in the national performance framework. Again, when it comes to a clear line of sight, many policies and bodies will be impacting that. In some places, it is clearer—for example, in the health service, there is throughput and the number of operations or procedures that are carried out and so on. In other areas, there is a lengthier process before we get feedback on policy interventions. In other areas, it might be easier to measure productivity—within Social Security Scotland, for example.

There is a range of different measures, and we are very open to quantifying some of those if it helps the committee and us to understand them.

Liz Smith Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

It is a big question, because we are responsible for scrutinising public money. If aspects of public sector reform are working particularly well in saving public money and delivering better outcomes, it is important to the Parliament and the committee to demonstrate that. I am interested in how Scottish ministers or civil servants can provide some of the data that we need to scrutinise that a bit more, because, if we could do that, it could go a long way towards improving how the Parliament works and giving the public some confidence that public sector reform is working.

11:15

Ivan McKee SNP Glasgow Provan
link

If we take those harder efficiency measures, we published data on what public bodies spend and the back-office cuts last year, and we will update it this year. That gives us numbers on the total spend on estates in the public sector, on maintenance of those estates, on procurement, on corporate finance, human resources functions, and so on. That data is now available for the first time across the public body landscape.

In parallel with that, we regularly publish data on how much money we are saving in the estates, and that number is £36 million up to now.

Ivan McKee SNP Glasgow Provan
link

It is already available. It was published last November.

Liz Smith Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

You said that an update was coming.

Ivan McKee SNP Glasgow Provan
link

We are working on that now. We are going back out to public bodies at the moment to get data for their 2025-26 budgets. We are working with public sector leaders to understand the best time to do that, but it will be in the next few weeks. We will go out for the next trawl of data, and it will be published towards the middle of this year.

Liz Smith Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

It will be published later this year.

Ivan McKee SNP Glasgow Provan
link

Yes, absolutely. Last year, we did it on historical data, and we are now doing it on budgeted data. We are getting ahead of the curve and we will establish an efficient process. We do not want collection of another big load of data to be put on public bodies. We will update that.

The 2022-23 data is available, and the savings that we have delivered on estates and procurement and other aspects of the hard savings are already there.

Liz Smith Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Convener, that might be something that we want to scrutinise.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

Yes, why not? That is something that we should look at.

Craig Hoy Con South Scotland
link

The act that we are looking at dates from 2010, so this is the third extension to it. I accept that we need to do something, as having some process is better than having no process, so can you give us some assurance to convince us that this is not just a holy grail and that we are not going to keep renewing it while seeing no material change?

In 2011, the Christie report said:

“It is estimated that as much as 40 per cent of all spending on public services is accounted for by interventions that could have been avoided by prioritising a preventative approach.”

You are now talking again about the need for a preventative approach when the Christie report, which was commissioned by John Swinney, came to that estimate of 40 per cent back in 2011. Roll forward 14 years, do you have any basis on which to assess what that percentage is now? Have you made any positive impact in relation to that?

Ivan McKee SNP Glasgow Provan
link

It would be difficult to do a true like-for-like comparison, in the sense that a lot of things will have changed in the nature of public services that we are providing and how we provide them. It would be a difficult comparison, because you are comparing the world as it is now with what it was back then in terms of the range and nature of public services that we provide or, indeed, the demand on them. I am happy to look at and assess the process that was gone through to arrive at that 40 per cent and see whether there is any way that we can update that.

I remember that exact wording in Christie’s report. It referred to a previous piece of work that was done—I cannot recall by who—and “up to” 40 per cent was the terminology that they used. I do not think that it was a hard and fast number, but it certainly gives an indication of the scale of the opportunity.

Craig Hoy Con South Scotland
link

Given that we are again talking about preventative spending, it would probably be good to see on what basis it was assessed and whether any progress has been made.

Jumping forward to last autumn, Audit Scotland took up a similar position, in which it said that there is still

“no evidence of large-scale change on the ground”

and that the Government

“does not know what additional funding is required to support reform”.

You have put £30 million in the budget this year for invest to save. Can you give the Auditor General some assurance that you are working towards getting an actual figure that you will work towards to leverage in the reforms that ultimately might meet the initial objectives of the act?

Ivan McKee SNP Glasgow Provan
link

A number of things are happening there. The invest to save fund is one lever, the orders are another and we have other levers on-going. We have talked about the estates programme, the procurement frameworks, digitisation and the automation programme that has already saved a significant amount of money, and those programmes continue. The invest to save fund is targeted specifically at the harder-to-crack challenges, such as the cross-portfolio co-operation that is required, and there are improvements that might take a period of time to generate savings.

To directly answer your question on the invest to save fund, that process has opened. We have already received the first trawl back of those submissions. Officials are looking at those now, and I will see them in the next week or two. Then, before the end of this month, we will identify the projects that we are taking forward with regard to investment of that £30 million.

Those projects will identify how much investment they want, what savings they will deliver as a consequence and in what timescale. As we select those projects and aggregate them, we will be able to answer the question directly and monitor how they are delivered.

Craig Hoy Con South Scotland
link

Finally, the Auditor General said in the same report that the Government

“has not provided enough leadership to help public sector bodies deliver change.”

You had the summit recently, and you are leading the charge, so is your neck on the line in relation to delivering that holy grail?

Ivan McKee SNP Glasgow Provan
link

In terms of providing the leadership, absolutely, but you have to recognise that—this is not an excuse; it is just the reality—public bodies are not subsidiaries of ministers. They are operationally independent to varying degrees. Although we control the amount of funding that we allocate to them, the effectiveness with which they adopt efficiency measures can be variable, frankly. That is why it is important that we continue to work with public sector leaders.

The governance board, which will have its first meeting by the end of this month, will contain public sector leaders and private sector-experienced individuals with experience in the area. We are seeking to roll out more measures for monitoring workforce and recruitment in public bodies. We continue to collect more data on how public bodies choose to spend the money that the Scottish Government allocates to them. All of that is about moving us in the right direction on having better data, more coherent policy and strategy, more engagement and, frankly, more empowerment of public body leaders, so that we can work together to seize those opportunities.

Craig Hoy Con South Scotland
link

Finally, finally—sorry, convener—you identified the concept of the single authority model in relation to health boards and councils. Is that a lesson that you should roll out through Government more widely, given that you say that it is quite difficult for you as the minister in charge to drive reform? Do you need to consider coherence in relation to the number of public bodies that are out there?

Ivan McKee SNP Glasgow Provan
link

The number of bodies is one thing, but if that was the only objective—we talked earlier about objectives—we could miss the point there. We consolidate public bodies where it makes sense to do so. We have started work to look at the number of public bodies in each portfolio and whether there is scope for them to work more closely together in clusters. We are already organically creating those clusters, and some are further along that road than others in sharing resources.

Where there is a clear case that consolidation of public bodies makes sense because it will deliver a cost-effective solution and better services, that is very much on the cards.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

We talked about zero-based budgeting in the committee after our visit to Estonia, where the Government is doing that at a departmental level. Of course, it is done quite a lot in many areas of the private sector. Might you take that approach to some of those public bodies? It seems that some of them are there because they have always been there, but you could look at them and ask what their core activity is and whether it has to be that organisation that delivers that activity. Could you look at public bodies in that way?

Ivan McKee SNP Glasgow Provan
link

Absolutely, but we need to be careful about what we mean by zero-based budgeting.

Ivan McKee SNP Glasgow Provan
link

To flip that, one of the big criticisms that we rightly get from the third sector and many other organisations is that we do not have multiyear funding, and that affects zero-based budgeting. We go back every year with a blank piece of paper and decide who is going to get the money. Rolling that uncertainty out more widely across the public sector could cause more challenges than it solves problems, so we need to be careful about what we mean by zero-based budgeting.

That said, this is about taking a step back to consider the purpose and deliverables of a group of public bodies in a particular part of the landscape and whether the current configuration is the most effective one or whether we should do things differently. At that point, you would start with a blank piece of paper when considering the minimum number of bodies that would be needed to deliver what you wanted and whether it would be cost effective to make a transformation.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

That approach would not have to be taken every year, but it would be useful for organisations that have been around for decades.

Ivan McKee SNP Glasgow Provan
link

It would be a multiyear approach, because, by its nature, it would take a longer period. You would not do that wholesale; you would look for the low-hanging fruit. To be honest, we have done that in relation to the police and colleges, and we have cited other, minor examples in which the functions of bodies have been brought together. We will continue to look for ways to do that.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

Incidentally, to jump back a bit, I worked out, while we were having this discussion, that the £490,000 that will be saved by ministerial salary sacrifice in the next financial year is less than the money from putting £1 on 600,000 tonnes of inert waste for a year. I just want to provide that perspective.

Ivan McKee SNP Glasgow Provan
link

I will try to get my head around that.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

Agenda item 5 involves formal consideration of the motion on the instrument. I invite the minister to move motion S6M-16547.

Motion moved,

That the Finance and Public Administration Committee recommends that the Public Services Reform (Scotland) Act 2010 (Part 2 Further Extension) Order 2025 draft be approved.—Ivan McKee

Motion agreed to.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

I thank the minister and Mr Macleod for their evidence. We will publish a short report that sets out our decision on the draft instrument.

11:27 Meeting continued in private until 11:55.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 09:30 Right to Addiction Recovery (Scotland) Bill: Financial Memorandum Bill debate · 118
  2. 10:45 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 16
  3. 11:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 40

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.