The next agenda item is an evidence session with the Minister for Public Finance on the Scottish Landfill Tax (Standard Rate and Lower Rate) Order 2025. The minister is joined today by Jonathan Waite, the Aggregates Tax and Devolved Taxes Administration (Scotland) Bill team leader at the Scottish Government. I welcome them both and invite the minister to make a short opening statement.
Ivan McKeeSNPThe Minister for Public Finance · Glasgow Provan
The Scottish Landfill Tax (Standard Rate and Lower Rate) Order 2025 specifies the standard and lower rates for the Scottish landfill tax, which will apply from 1 April 2025 and are consistent with the rates set out in the Scottish budget for 2025-26, as published on 4 December last year. The order sets out that the standard rate will increase from £103.70 to £126.15 per tonne and that the lower rate, which applies to less polluting, inert materials, will increase from £3.30 to £4.05 per tonne. Members may wish to note that those rates match the United Kingdom landfill tax rates for the 2025-26 financial year, as confirmed in the October 2024 UK budget.
The Scottish Government has continued acting to avoid any potential for what is referred to as “waste tourism” emerging as a result of material differences between tax rates north and south of the border. The increased rates are intended to provide appropriate financial incentives to support the delivery of the Scottish Government’s circular economy, climate and sustainable resource goals.
Thank you for that opening statement. Do you really think that, if you were to put the tax on inert waste up by £1 you would have vast numbers of lorries charging over the border in order to avoid tax? Given what it costs to ship such material, including the cost of fuel, payment for the driver and depreciation of the value of the lorry, that is kind of nonsense, is it not? I can understand the argument about non-inert waste, but it seems a bit bizarre that this tax has been devolved for umpteen years without there being a penny differential and that we still get a ludicrous statement every year about inert waste tourism. Surely we can think up our own tax for that. If it cost a fiver, we could make an extra few bob for the Scottish Government and there would not be a queue of trucks at Berwick trying to dump waste in Northumberland.
We will look at how the Welsh policy operates. If there were potential for waste tourism, that would be geographically easier to do from Wales into England than from Scotland into England. We will see how that works, take a sense of it and consider it in our deliberations on the tax for the next year.
We have had the landfill tax for a while now, as have Wales and England. Why has the Scottish Government not looked into the potential for a differential rate before this point?
The principle has always been that we do not want to get into an environment where we would be concerned about waste tourism—if you want to call it that. The whole intention is to drive behavioural change through the tax and other policy measures. The trends are clearly moving in a downward direction for both inert and non-inert waste. That is the primary policy intention.
However, there is scope for us to look at what differential rates could do. We need to assess how much additional income that would raise. In the context of the revenue that is being raised reducing significantly anyway as a consequence of the behavioural change that the tax is driving, I am not sure that any increase would make a significant difference.
I would certainly welcome that additional work happening. It seems that the single deciding factor in setting the rate in Scotland is the rate in England. However, we have our own climate targets and waste reduction targets. What regard has been given to the impact that setting the landfill tax rate at an equivalent level to the English rate would have on the targets that we have set in Scotland?
On all those targets—climate emissions, waste reduction, circular economy and so on—our targets are either more ambitious than England’s or we have targets in areas that they simply do not have. It seems that there is a dichotomy, because the tax is one of the key drivers for meeting those targets. The rate that we have set it at does not seem to be based on what we would need to do to hit those targets; it seems to be based entirely on the rate that the UK Government has set in England.
You would need to have an evidential base for doing something differently. I suppose that we are working in three dimensions. We are first looking at—as the convener said—how much money an increase would raise. I am looking at the data that is in front of me. Officials will correct me if I am wrong, but there seems to be about 110,000 tonnes at the lower rate, so a £1 increase would bring in an extra £100,000. That would be welcome, but it would not shift the dial on the budget.
If you start to increase that rate by too much and the differential grows, is there the potential for waste tourism? That is the last thing we want, because it makes everything more difficult.
Then there is the question how the current rates are driving behavioural change. With the numbers coming down year on year, it looks as though the tax is having the intended policy impact of driving such behavioural change. However, I would be happy to look at the evidence and to do some modelling as best we can with the information that we have to see what making some changes in future years might deliver.
I would certainly welcome that. I entirely understand the risk of waste tourism—none of us wants to see that. My concern is that, as is so often the case, we are not hitting the targets that have been set in legislation by the Parliament in relation to emissions reduction, waste reduction, recycling and so on. It seems that one of our key levers is not based on the targets that have been set by the Parliament; it is based on a very risk-averse response to what the UK Government’s policy making is for England. I would certainly welcome that work being done ahead of the next budget.
Sorry, convener—I just want to correct the record, I have just noticed in my notes that there were about 600,000 tonnes at the lower rate, and 110,000 tonnes of that was soil. There was other material in that figure as well, so
it is more significant, although not in the big scheme of things.
If the figure were to be 600,000 tonnes and you put the tax rate up by a fiver, there would be an additional £3 million in revenue for the Scottish Government. Folk will not drive across the border from Motherwell or Aberdeen to save a fiver per tonne—they just will not. It seems sensible to be somewhat bolder on this, and I hope that the Government will look at the rate next year.
Agenda item 3 is formal consideration of motion S6M-16546. I invite the minister to speak to and move the motion.
Motion moved,
That the Finance and Public Administration Committee recommends that the Scottish Landfill Tax (Standard Rate and Lower Rate) Order 2025 (SSI 2025/41) be approved.—Ivan McKee
The committee will publish a short report setting out our decision on the instrument following the meeting. I briefly suspend the meeting to allow officials to change position.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.