I thank members who signed my motion for debate and my business manager for allowing the time for it.
I have been consistent in my view that if we are to secure the future of Scotland’s economy, we must be laser focused on ensuring access to education and training in the skills that we need for the future. As policy continues in the direction of a just transition towards a greener economy, investing in the skills and education of the future has never been more relevant.
Scottish Engineering chief executive Paul Sheerin recently described the current outlook for the Scottish economy as an “industrial revolution-sized opportunity”. I agree, but that description came with a stark warning that Scotland was at risk of missing out on the opportunity due to a lack of a skills pipeline.
The comments came after the publication at the start of the month of Scottish Engineering’s “Engineering Skills Gap Analysis for Scotland”. I believe that we need to seriously consider the report’s findings and the implications for the future of engineering and its impact on our economy.
The results are the output of a survey of 70 engineering companies from a broad range of sectors, based on their operations in Scotland. Scottish Engineering reported that
“The skills pipeline gaps for these roles are an immediately stark situation”.
Indeed, a look at the average demand across 31 engineering roles showed that industry will require an additional 33 per cent of the volume that is currently in role by the end of 2025, rising to 46 per cent by the end of 2026 and again to 58 per cent by the end of 2027.
If those figures are concerning, the conclusions are cause for further concern, as it should be noted that the gaps are only for existing industry. That means that there is “no allowance” for the additional demand of offshore wind, grid infrastructure investment, decarbonising heat energy or green hydrogen production—sectors that are essential to Scotland’s stated aims of achieving net zero. The report concludes:
“Where that demand is for the opportunity for inward investment, unless there is a rapid change in the required skills investment there is a considerable risk of damage to incumbent industry.”
Scottish Engineering also estimates that 20 per cent of demand for apprentice training programmes has
“been unmet due to real terms funding cuts to apprenticeships in Scotland.”
When I speak to employers of skilled workers across the Mid Scotland and Fife region, one issue that comes up time and again is that due to a lack of the skilled workers that are needed to meet industry demand, the whole of the United Kingdom is having to share pools of workers for each skill. An example of that is the Hinkley Point nuclear power station project in Somerset, England, which is attracting workers from Scotland, due to the high demand for skills and the higher pay on offer.
That is why it is crucial that we look at this issue from a UK-wide point of view. The Open University’s “Business Barometer 2024” found that,
“Despite tiny green shoots of improvement, the skills gap in the UK remains stubbornly high across sectors, regions and all four nations.”
Across the UK, 62 per cent of organisations are facing skills shortages; in Scotland, the figure is 56 per cent; and a concerning 52 per cent of organisations do not have specific recruitment, retention or training initiatives for targeted groups.
As a result, my motion calls for two things. First, the Scottish and UK Governments must work together to encourage the next generation of skilled workers by making available the funding and resources that are needed
“to provide the apprenticeships of today for the jobs of tomorrow”.
There is a clear and desperate need for that. I urge both of Scotland’s Governments to recognise the urgency of the situation that we are in and act accordingly.
Furthermore, I believe that the Scottish Government must
“take action to foster a new partnership between schools, colleges, universities and industry to ensure that young people are aware and able to take advantage of the opportunities available in Scotland’s industrial sector”.
An academic to whom I spoke recently told me that we must do more to build the relationships between schools, colleges and industry. He was very clear that that should start in primary 6 and primary 7, not in secondary 3 and secondary 4.
I know that there is a lot of on-going work by the Scottish Government and its agencies, and I do not want to undermine any of that, but much more has to be done if we are to give every child the chance to gain the education and skills for the jobs of today and tomorrow. We need a revolution in skills from primary schools to secondary schools and colleges, all working in partnership with industry. We need a regional skills strategy for every region of Scotland, along with regional funding to deliver a regional workforce plan.
Government at every level must work in partnership with industry. We must listen to the concerns of industry on the apprenticeship levy and the calls for reform, the concerns at the intention to wind up the Scottish apprenticeship advisory board, and the concerns expressed by business about the decision to remove Skills Development Scotland from post-school funding.
The future for jobs in Scotland can, and should, be very bright, but it requires a stronger partnership and a new approach that puts education, training and skills at its very heart, and it should be driven by education and industry working together in partnership. Scotland deserves nothing less.