In my view, four key determinants are affecting the pressures on, and the delivery of, health and social care in Scotland today.
Covid disrupted the delivery of health services for two years. It brought a direct impact through deferred diagnoses, increases in mental health issues and long Covid. Covid meant that cancer was diagnosed at a later and more critical stage; many health services were paused during lockdown, which had an impact on health inequalities; and mental health was impacted. Therefore, the delivery of health and social care today has been profoundly altered. The idea that Covid is done and dusted is for the birds. That page has not been turned.
Brexit, too, had and is having a long-term impact on recruitment and retention across the health and care sectors. That has been well documented.
The next issue is Scotland’s demographics. With our population getting older, there are now more than a million people aged 65 or over in Scotland—20 per cent of the population. That is more than a quarter of a million higher than the number of people under 15. Pressures on the NHS and the care sector grow with ageing, as I know, as I am having to use NHS services more often.
The final issue relates to inflation, austerity and poverty. Inflation has an impact on energy, food and building costs, just for starters, and it has led to an increase in the number of people falling into poverty. Thankfully, the Scottish child payment—£26.70 for each child under 16 in a family that qualifies for certain benefits—is helping. For the coming winter, there is the £100 winter fuel payment for all pensioners who are not on pension credit. Getting rid of the two-child benefit cap will also help, because poverty, at whatever age, inevitably leads to both physical and mental ill health.
The Labour Secretary of State for Health and Social Care, Wes Streeting, admitted that, when it comes to NHS funding, Westminster is damaging Scotland’s NHS because of the austerity that we have suffered for 14 years. That page has not been turned; Wes can add the impact of the hike in employer national insurance contributions, which will have an impact across the health and care sector. I know that there are GP practices that are not taking on GPs because of the national insurance hike.
Those are the four things that have affected health and social care in Scotland: Covid fallout, Brexit, demographics, and inflation and austerity.
Each and every member of our health and care workforce became a hero during Covid. The Scottish Government values them, and so do I. Scotland remains the only country in the UK to have successfully averted NHS strikes over pay, and the pay deals that were offered by the Scottish Government played a crucial role in retaining Scotland’s NHS workforce, recognising their value and improving their wellbeing.
In September, unions voted unanimously to accept the pay uplift of 5.5 per cent for 2024-25. That is investment of more than £448 million and takes the total investment in pay over the past two years to over £1 billion. The Scottish Government puts its money where its mouth is.
Contrast that with Labour-run Wales, where, in January 2024, junior doctor strikes led to the cancellation of 6,500 outpatient appointments and 4,000 planned operations, which undoubtedly impacted on waiting times. That was dwarfed by the situation in England, where over 1.5 million medical appointments have been cancelled due to strike action since March 2023, at an estimated cost of over £3 billion.
I began by stating that, since Covid, the delivery of healthcare has changed—sometimes for the better and sometimes not. Increasing demands have led to innovatory improvements such as hospital at home, which was piloted in the Scottish Borders—where £600,000, the bulk of the national funding pot for the programme, has been allocated. Hospital at home does what it says on the tin and is delivered depending on clinical suitability and—of course—on the consent of the patients, most of whom are elderly. Over 90 per cent of patients who opted for it thought that it was grand to be treated in their own home and, of course, it freed up much-needed beds.
Pharmacy first is another innovation, and it will be expanded where there is an appropriately-qualified pharmacist, which can allow community pharmacies to give people expert help for treating conditions like sore throats, earaches and cold sores. That will divert them away from GPs and A and E. Thirty-two per cent of the Scottish population used pharmacy first in the most recent 12 months that were reported on—April 2023 to March 2024. It is early days, but those are good signs.
On the downside, the pandemic exposed the inequalities across the care sector, despite the dedication of the care workers who delivered care above and beyond expectations, and often did not even go home. We need to tackle that inequality and I would rather that the national care service had been labelled “national care standards”, because the issue is about standards.
I find that the accessibility of some GP practices is not the best. It is not uncommon to be required to phone for an appointment between, say, 8 am and 10 am, and then to have a phone call from the GP rather than a face-to-face appointment. Of course, that is a matter for GP practices, which are, in the main, contracted to the NHS. It is not a matter for the NHS and it is not a matter for the Scottish Government; it is a matter for GP practices. I hope that, if we can shift the balance to pharmacies, opticians and other allied health professionals, more GPs will revert to the personal touch.
I welcome this debate, but let us not ignore context, whether that is the pandemic, Brexit, an ageing population, inflation eating into NHS budgets, the national insurance tax hike on GP practices and allied professionals, and increasing poverty. All of that matters and cannot just be ignored in this debate.
15:49