This January marks five years since the United Kingdom left the European Union—five fraught and turbulent years for Scotland’s manufacturers, exporters, service providers, artists and musicians.
Deputy Presiding Officer,
“We announced that we would leave the European Union before we had a plan for growth outside the EU.”
Those are not my words, but the words of Kemi Badenoch. For once—for what is probably the only time—I agree with her. However, I would argue that there was a lack of not only a plan for growth, but a plan, full stop. Nonetheless, it was nice to hear a rare bit of honesty from a Tory leader on Brexit.
Let us hear from three more Brexiteers. Michael Gove opined:
“The day after we vote to leave, we hold all the cards and we can choose the path we want”.
However, we now have fewer jobs; food prices at an all-time high; and less trade.
Dominic Cummings had to concede that the figure of £350 million for the national health service that was plastered on a bus was a lie. Nigel Farage vowed to tear up the EU red tape holding Britain back. Well, our exporters now bemoan the new arrangements. The National Farmers Union Scotland told us that the trading relationship under
“the TCA ... might be ... tariff free and quota free, but it is certainly not friction free.”—[Official Report, Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee, 7 March 2024; c 2.]
Many small and medium-sized enterprises are simply giving up their EU market share because trying to navigate the new exporting regime is not worth the cost, time and project wastage.
I do not have a fourth Brexiteer quote, as the young trainee could not access Erasmus+ and so was unable to take part this evening.
The people in Scotland sensibly voted to remain in the EU. There was a majority vote for remain in every one of Scotland’s local authorities, but Scotland was removed from the EU against the democratic wishes of the Scottish people. Brexit has caused, and continues to cause, substantial harm to the Scottish and UK economies.
Recently, the National Institute of Economic and Social Research think tank said that UK exports from the service sectors could be cut by up to 60 per cent. For Scotland, that would be equivalent to a £2.3 billion hit because of Brexit. The Office for Budget Responsibility has reported an estimate that Brexit will reduce the overall trade intensity of the UK economy by 15 per cent in the longer term. I understand that a study from the centre for economic performance at the London School of Economics found that, in 2022 alone, goods exports from the UK dropped by £27 billion as a result of Brexit. The Chartered Institute of Procurement and Supply revealed that problems with supply chains and trade routes, exacerbated by Brexit, will see imports cost between 5 and 20 per cent more, fuelling a new cost of living crisis.
Brexit continues to pose significant barriers to people coming to live and work in Scotland, including in our vital public services. Over 10 years ago, Scotland was told that the only way for us to stay in the EU was to remain part of the UK and vote no. Brexit has been a disaster for Scotland. It has made us poorer; it has diminished our international standing; and it has cut us off from the world’s largest economic market. It is a disaster that has denied people in Scotland a wealth of opportunity, rich cultural exchanges, academic collaboration and the right to work, study and live in 27 other nations. A generation of people in my Motherwell and Wishaw constituency have had rights that I enjoyed for most of my adult life ripped away from them against their expressed will.
Brexit is manifestly harming our present and future. I am not speaking this evening as convener of the Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee, but during the committee’s work on the impact of Brexit and its review of the trade and co-operation agreement, we have heard witness after witness tell of the detrimental impacts of Brexit.
Sky News reported findings that
“by 2035, the UK is anticipated to have three million fewer jobs, 32% lower investment, 5% lower exports and 16% lower imports, than it would have had if the UK had not left the EU.”
Brexit is also a tale of two countries: it is certainly the best of times for Ireland and the worst of times for us. In 2024, the Republic of Ireland, as a small nation in Europe with a similar population, economy and cultural links to those of Scotland, enjoyed a significant budget surplus, at around 8 per cent of its gross national income. It is a small country in surplus, while we are dragged down by a £2.77 trillion debt.
According to the centre for economic performance, Brexit has cost each household
“£250 when only considering the impacts on food since December 2019 ... This aggregates up to £6.95bn overall for UK households.”
Last week, the Musicians Union, having already acknowledged the impact of cabotage and visas on touring artists and musicians, had to issue guidance to artists on the general product safety regulations. It has been
“noted that the introduction of these regulations, which required certifiable safety checks and labels on goods such as CDs, vinyl, T shirts, mugs and other merchandise exported to the EU and Northern Ireland, had not been foreseen by most people in the music business.”
Ewan Robertson gave evidence to our committee on those areas and spoke of how much more difficult it is now for artists to tour and work in Europe.
There is a litany of quotes that I could have brought to the chamber—for example, from Aldomak, the company that has saved the Scottish ice-cream nougat wafer. It previously traded frequently with Europe, but it gave evidence to our committee that it is no longer even trying to export to Europe. We also heard from our fishing industry about stock that was ruined. We know that Brexit just keeps giving us more bad news.