I thank the Scottish National Party and Green MSPs who signed my motion to enable the debate to happen, and I thank Age Scotland and Close the Gap for their briefings.
Deputy Presiding Officer,
“Members are shocked and disgusted by what can only be seen as a betrayal of everything the Labour Party MPs & MSPs have told us while they were in opposition.
Instead of going after all those who fraudulently claimed money for inadequate PPE for example, they decide to target the vulnerable and already penalised WASPI women.
Lying, untrustworthy hypocrites is the best description of how we feel about the Labour Party now!”
Those are not my words but the words of the Ayrshire WASPI group, as reported last month in the Ardrossan & Saltcoats Herald. Women were understandably angry and frustrated at the decision by Liz Kendall MP, the Secretary of State for Work and Pensions, not to compensate them.
For a decade, women against state pension inequality campaigners and their supporters have demanded justice. This is the fifth WASPI debate that we have had at Holyrood. At Westminster, it was the last issue that was debated before the United Kingdom general election, on a motion that was tabled by the former SNP member of Parliament for North Ayrshire and Arran, Patricia Gibson, who spoke about WASPI in the House of Commons 46 times.
For those who are unaware, I note that the Pensions Act 1995 and the Pensions Act 2011 resulted in the state pension age for women who were born in the 1950s changing from 60 to 65 and then to 66, but 3.8 million women across the UK—including 336,000 in Scotland and 26,430 in Ayrshire—who were impacted by the changes were not given proper notice. Many women received a letter advising them of the changes only within one year or less of their expected state pension age of 60. Some found themselves retiring from employment on a Friday, only to find that they could not claim their pension the following Monday and would have to wait up to six more years.
Most older women were already at greater risk of poverty as a result of earning lower pay during their working lives, having interrupted their careers to raise families. Many also had caring responsibilities. Last year, the Pensions Policy Institute found that women’s pension wealth, by their late 50s, is less than two thirds that of men as a result of their being paid less than the national insurance lower earnings limit.
All MSPs will have heard from constituents about the devastating impact that raising women’s pension age without due notice has had on their lives. That impact has led to women abandoning plans to care for elderly or infirm relatives, being forced into low-paid and insecure work, and being pushed into poverty as what savings they had have dwindled away.
I highlight a case that was previously raised in the chamber by Neil Bibby. In 2012, his constituent was told by the Department for Work and Pensions that her state pension age had not changed. It subsequently did change, to 63 and a half and then to 65 and three months. She was given no notice to prepare.
Another woman, who contacted Pauline McNeill, became unwell at 58, after working all her life, and discovered by accident that the age at which she had expected to receive her pension—60—had increased to 66.
It is undeniable that successive UK Governments failed to grasp the detrimental impact on millions of women. The former Minister of State for Pensions, Baroness Ros Altmann, said that the then Secretary of State for Work and Pensions, Iain Duncan Smith MP, had allegedly refused to engage with affected women, saying that they
“would go away sooner or later.”
Well, those women are still here—in our public gallery, in fact—and their voices are still being heard. [Applause.]
After one of the most tenacious and determined grass-roots campaigns in recent memory, WASPI women believed that they were slowly winning against Whitehall intransigence. In March 2024, a comprehensive investigation by the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman damned the DWP and vindicated WASPI campaigners. The DWP was found guilty of “maladministration” and the ombudsman made clear that affected women “should be compensated”. A major factor in the ombudsman’s conclusions came from the DWP’s failure to react appropriately to research findings and recommendations.
An internal DWP memorandum references a survey that found that half of women whose state pension age had risen thought that it was still 60. The memo proposed
“A direct mail to this group … as the most appropriate way of minimising the risk of future criticism that the Department has not been sufficiently proactive in communicating to those women affected by the change in State Pension age.”
Research showed the target audience
“Has a strong preference for printed material, being generally positive towards direct mail and particularly its presentation.”
Therefore, in December, when Ms Kendall, the Secretary of State for Work and Pensions, said that 90 per cent of WASPI women knew about the change to their pension age and then flatly rejected compensation, the shock, anger and sense of duplicity that WASPI women felt were all too real. However, even if Ms Kendall was right—she is not—that 90 per cent of women did know, that would still leave 380,000 women in the UK, 33,000 in Scotland and hundreds in my constituency to be compensated.
The UK Labour Government is offering nothing—it is no wonder that emotions are so raw. For years, Labour politicians, including Sir Keir Starmer and the Chancellor of the Exchequer, Rachel Reeves, happily stood alongside WASPI women and their campaign placards demanding fair and fast compensation. To add insult to injury, Ms Kendall openly campaigned for WASPI and was photographed signing WASPI pledges and affirming her support. To go from that to her statement on 17 December shows an astonishing political metamorphosis.
However, the Labour Government is not just ruling out compensation in any form, as awful as that is. Ms Kendall argued that giving women proper notice of the changes would not have made a difference, thereby shamefully seeking to repudiate the entire premise of the WASPI campaign. In shrugging off an SNP MP’s question, the secretary of state echoed a suggestion that was previously made by Jackie Baillie, Labour’s deputy leader in this Parliament: if you do not like it, mitigate it yourselves. Such comments show wilful ignorance of section 28 of the Scotland Act 2016, which prohibits the Scottish Parliament from such action, as the “Report of the Smith Commission for further devolution of powers to the Scottish Parliament” stated specifically that
“All aspects of ... pension”
provision should
“remain ... reserved”.
The DWP knew that a massive cohort of women were unaware of changes to their pensions, knew that it should write to them and knew that that would make a difference. Ms Kendall’s attempt to rewrite history and blame the WASPI women for being unaware of the changes deserves only our contempt.
The Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman’s conclusions resulted from a rigorous and impartial investigation that unequivocally confirmed DWP failings—they are not advisory suggestions to be conveniently ignored. Governments have a duty to act with fairness and integrity, to acknowledge mistakes and to rectify them once they are discovered. When that duty is abdicated, as we see in this case, it erodes trust not just in the political party involved but in Government institutions more widely. Failure to uphold ombudsman recommendations sets a terrible precedent that the UK Government can disregard its own failings and that those who have been wronged can be dismissed and ignored.
WASPI women deserve better. It is estimated that more than 300,000 have died since the campaign began, and another dies every 13 minutes. I urge members on all sides of the chamber to unite in demanding justice—which means compensation, without delay.
To WASPI women who are listening to this debate, I say: the SNP stands with you, and we will ensure that your voices are heard until you receive the justice and compensation that you deserve.