Good morning, and welcome to the 40th meeting in 2024 of the Criminal Justice Committee. We have no apologies this morning.
The first item of business is to take evidence on an affirmative Scottish statutory instrument and a negative SSI, namely, the draft Electronic Monitoring (Use of Devices and Information) (Scotland) Regulations 2025, and the Electronic Monitoring (Approved Devices) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2024 (SSI 2024/354).
We are joined by the Cabinet Secretary for Justice and Home Affairs. I also welcome to the meeting from the Scottish Government: Graham Robertson, head of the public protection unit; David Gallagher, from the public protection unit; and Jamie MacQueen, from the legal directorate.
I refer members to papers 1 and 2, and invite the cabinet secretary to make some opening remarks on both of the SSIs.
Angela ConstanceSNPThe Cabinet Secretary for Justice and Home Affairs · Almond Valley
Good morning. If the regulations that the committee is considering today are approved, they will enable the use of GPS monitoring devices for the first time in Scotland, for the monitoring of people as part of the criminal justice system.
We have laid the Electronic Monitoring (Approved Devices) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2024 under the negative procedure. Those regulations amend the Electronic Monitoring (Approved Devices) (Scotland) Regulations 2020 to approve GPS-enabled devices as the types of electronic devices that are designated as approved for the purpose of electronic monitoring. The Electronic Monitoring (Use of Devices and Information) (Scotland) Regulations 2025, which is an affirmative instrument, will govern the use of those devices. The regulations will work together to prescribe the terms of use of GPS devices for monitoring compliance with certain conditions of a home detention curfew licence on release from prison.
The Electronic Monitoring (Use of Devices and Information) (Scotland) Regulations 2025 limit the use of GPS to monitoring conditions imposed when Scottish ministers release an individual from custody on HDC licence. The regulations also allow for a continuity of current monitoring arrangements by allowing existing radio frequency electronic monitoring devices to continue to monitor the court disposals set out in section 3 of the Management of Offenders (Scotland) Act 2019, and the conditions imposed on an individual when they are released on licence, which are set out in section 7 of that act.
The regulations also clarify the maximum period for which information obtained through the use of radio frequency and GPS-enabled electronic monitoring devices will be retained, and the purposes for which the Scottish ministers, or those acting on their behalf, may share that information.
I invite the committee to consider the regulations.
Audrey NicollSNPThe Convener · Aberdeen South and North Kincardine
Cabinet secretary, I warmly welcome the regulations that you have brought to the committee today. As you know, Pauline McNeill and I have been calling for some time for GPS monitoring to be introduced in Scotland. The legislation was passed in 2019, and it would be helpful to understand why it has taken so long to get to this point. I appreciate that the position is far from unique, and that there are often delays between legislation being passed and the policy being implemented, but it would be helpful for the committee to get a better understanding as to why there have been such delays.
I would not describe it as a delay. However, I welcome your support for GPS technology, which adds to the tools that we have. It represents a step in the right direction in realising our ambitions to expand the use and widen the scope of electronic monitoring.
Members are probably aware that the new contract with G4S came into force in 2020. Thereafter, we wanted to ensure, as a priority, that our plans for electronic monitoring aligned with the community justice strategy. That is why, in the first instance, there was a big focus on electronic monitoring of bail and on the use of electronic monitoring in community payback orders when they are applied at first instance.
We are now moving to the introduction of GPS monitoring and the initial phase of that is focused on home detention curfew, for which the numbers are quite small. We have done that in order to test the processes, because this tool is shared between our justice agencies and our justice partners and it is important that, in engaging and operating with each other, those agencies and partners have the opportunity to learn from the initial phase before it is scaled up.
However, I appreciate that, across the political spectrum, there is an interest in different forms of electronic monitoring.
Given the problems that we have in relation to overcrowding in prisons, those kinds of tools are incredibly important. However, GPS monitoring is already used widely in England and across Europe, and has been for many years. There must be much that can be learned from that.
Cabinet secretary, could you give us an indication of the timetable? Many of us are frustrated because it has been many years that the tool has not been put into operation, so it would be helpful to know how soon such monitoring will be in place. Could you provide us with an update on that?
It is fair to reflect that GPS and other forms of electronic monitoring are used widely elsewhere on these islands and across Europe. We have certainly learned much from the pursuance of GPS in England. For example, we will not require people to be tethered to a wall to charge their devices. One of the valid lessons that we have learned is that if we do not treat people like human beings, their prospect of success diminishes. I am sure that Ms Clark appreciates that point.
The numbers in the initial phase will be quite small, because home detention curfew is a bespoke intervention. Yesterday, out of the total prison population, 138 people were out on home detention curfew. Members will be aware of the steps that we have taken in recent times to increase the use of home detention curfew. However, we anticipate that, at any one time, there will probably be up to about 20 people on GPS monitoring and home detention curfew.
We want to have an initial phase that lasts for around a year. Once we are absolutely sure that there are no issues with the operational processes of engagement, the important next stage would be to scale that up in relation to other orders. Much depends on what we learn. It is important that, due to the complexity of operational processes among justice partners, in the first instance, we use GPS with one order, as opposed to rolling it out across a range of orders.
You have covered some of my questions in your answers to Katy Clark, but I am also interested in the financial impact of GPS monitoring.
At the moment, the policy note accompanying the instrument says that there is a one-time cost of £210,000 for the roll-out of GPS monitoring and that the cost of information technology change will “fall to the Scottish Government”. It then says that G4S has GPS monitoring in its contract. It also says that only around 10 to 20 people will be monitored with GPS initially.
I want to get more detail on that. Does the cost refer to money that G4S has already been given? My concern is that that money has already been spent on other things, such as the radio frequency monitoring that G4S already does. We welcome the fact that people will be on GPS monitoring, and I am glad to see that being brought in. However, my concern is that, if G4S has already spent the money on other things, it will not do the GPS monitoring that is required. Does G4S have the capacity to do that monitoring?
We have always found that our partners are keen to expand on electronic monitoring, so I do not have any concerns in that respect.
Let me run through the costs. The GPS service will cost £210,000 per annum. There is the one-off installation cost of £139.58, which covers both the fitting and the removal of a tag, and there is a monitoring cost, which is slightly more expensive per day for GPS monitoring in comparison to radio frequency monitoring, at around £7.20 compared to £5.99.
The Government is increasing investment in electronic monitoring, and the budget has had a 10 per cent uplift, meaning that an additional £500,000 has been put into the budget. Graham Robertson may have more to say on the details of the contract.
As the cabinet secretary has said, bands are provided for both types of monitoring. The figure of £210,000 is an estimate based on expected usage—in other words, what we think it will cost. It is not money that has already been handed over but is an estimate of what will be handed over when we see the GPS numbers.
Audrey NicollSNPThe Convener · Aberdeen South and North Kincardine
As no other members have indicated that they would like to speak, we shall now consider a motion to approve the affirmative SSI on which we have just taken oral evidence. I invite the cabinet secretary to move motion S6M-15677.
Motion moved,
That the Criminal Justice Committee recommends that the Electronic Monitoring (Use of Devices and Information) (Scotland) Regulations 2025 draft be approved.—Angela Constance
Motion agreed to.
Audrey NicollSNPThe Convener · Aberdeen South and North Kincardine
As members have no comments in relation to the negative instrument, the Electronic Monitoring (Approved Devices) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2024, is the committee content to make no recommendations and for that instrument to come into force?
Members indicated agreement.
Audrey NicollSNPThe Convener · Aberdeen South and North Kincardine
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.