I do not have that information, but the member is quite right that that is information that we need to have. What is clear, though, is that the park is being used as a through route by people travelling not to the park to enjoy it but through the park as a way of, presumably, avoiding Edinburgh traffic.
There are two themes to my speech today, on which I hope to hear from other members and the minister. The first is about improvements that can and should be made to the park as soon as possible to improve the experience and safety of park users and visitors. The second is a plea to Scottish ministers to put in place the intention and resources to implement a long-term plan for the park. That includes the provision of sufficient human and financial resources to undertake the further work that is proposed in the Holyrood park strategic plan in a timely and effective manner.
I think that that work must include an update to the primary legislation concerning the park, and I think that it should involve a consideration of whether care of the park should be placed with a dedicated local organisation with the remit and resources to take care of it properly. I will come back to that point.
On immediate and pressing matters in the park, I was grateful to the 150 local residents who joined me at a community meeting on Monday evening to set out their concerns and priorities for the park. I also thank Sarah Boyack for coming along to that, as well as several Edinburgh councillors. One person who attended that meeting said to me:
“It’s the first time someone has asked me what I think.”
I will write up the feedback more formally for Historic Environment Scotland, but, at the meeting, the top priorities were suggestions to improve nature in the park and to improve active travel. There were many people calling for cars to be slowed down, traffic to be reduced, or for cars to be banned altogether except for disabled access. There was an enthusiasm to support activities in the park—everything from football to boating, marathon running to dog walking and cycling—and many people were concerned about the tension between visitor numbers and activities and their effects on wildlife and nature. There were repeated requests for pedestrian crossings, dropped curbs, improved signage and other measures for safety and accessibility, and there was a widely held desire for better public transport to and within the park, with connections to the city and Lothians.
Those are all sensible and reasonable concerns. All of those matters will require consultation and they will require funding. Will the Scottish Government resource this project properly, especially with regard to quickly establishing a credible business plan for the park, so that work can get started?
The most loudly voiced concern at Monday’s meeting was about the restrictions that are currently in place on the Radical Road and how they are in conflict with the Scottish people’s right to roam.
That brings me to my second point. Is the legislation covering the park fit for purpose and is Historic Environment Scotland the right organisation to be managing it? Is it right that the entire park is a scheduled monument, putting it out of sync with the right to roam and with how a public park might reasonably be expected to operate?
The HES employees and rangers whom I have met are truly excellent professionals and I commend their work. However, I fear that they have an impossible job. They are stretched much too thin and do not have the resources that are needed to tackle Holyrood park’s challenges properly. We do not know exactly how many people visit Holyrood park in a year, but estimates are in the millions—maybe even 5 million. Compare that to the Loch Lomond and the Trossachs national park, which hosts about 4 million visitors a year and has an annual budget from the Scottish Government of £13.9 million, or the Cairngorms national park, which hosts 2 million visitors and has a budget of £8 million. I was not able to find information on exactly how much HES spends on Holyrood park in a year, but with £74 million from the Scottish Government, it has to manage over 300 properties. That averages out to less than £250,000 per property.
The strategic plan for Holyrood park mentions 21 HES employees who support the park, but those same 21 also look after other properties in Scotland. Compare that with a staff of 110 for the Cairngorms national park and 137 at the Loch Lomond and the Trossachs national park.
Reimagining Holyrood Park is a massive and complex project, involving scheduled monuments, SSSIs, a busy commuter route and a tourist venue, starting from a state of eroded paths and very damaged nature. The slow response to issues such as the closure of the Radical Road and the delays to publishing the strategic plan, however welcome that plan is, give the impression that HES is hopelessly under-resourced to take on that work.
Holyrood Park, with its millions of visitors, its complex landscape and its variety of users, needs resources and democratic governance that are much more comparable with those of a national park.
We have an opportunity to reimagine Holyrood park, and I hope that the Scottish Government will step up to the challenge.
I look forward to hearing from other members this evening.
17:18