We have had 14 years of clear evidence that the Tories certainly do not have the answers, particularly given the chaos that they left the economy in when they squirrelled out of office early in July.
This is one of those days on which the Opposition declares the SNP Government’s draft budget to be tantamount to the end of civilisation as we know it, while Scottish ministers view it as a vital step on the road to a land of milk and honey. Of course, the reality is somewhere in between, which is why it is important for each party to be open-minded about what can be achieved in the weeks ahead and about where compromise can be reached and a balance can be struck. Grandstanding has no place in these deliberations. Therefore, it was disappointing to read Russell Findlay’s rather terse letter of 18 November to the First Minister, in which he huffily declared:
“We don’t agree with your spending commitments, so we expect you will look elsewhere for a budget deal.”
Regardless of what the 2025-26 budget might contain, the Tories, who are constantly looking over their shoulders as their votes, members and councillors drift to Reform, will not play ball. Therefore, the demands that they make in their motion are meaningless. If the Tories have the fully costed proposals that Mr Findlay promised, where are they? Today’s motion has more holes than a Swiss cheese. It is interesting that, in the debate that will follow this one, Jeremy Balfour will call for £10 million for changing places toilets. Why is that cost not included in the Tory motion?
The Tories now talk about outcomes. That will come as a surprise to many, because the Tories have demanded more money for free school meals, winter heating, the ScotRail peak fare subsidy and a plethora of other areas that would have cost more than £2 billion since early September alone. We have heard about some of those areas today. Dr Gulhane talked about Hindi translation services. I do not know whether they have worked out what the cost of those services would come to, but it seems to be just another Tory addition that they never actually give us the cost for.
Russell Findlay has called for the social security budget to be looked at, whatever that means. I doubt that that is the view of Jeremy Balfour, who, earlier this year, called for social security spending to be the Scottish Government’s “number 1 priority”.
Jeremy, Miles Briggs and Roz McCall all supported Paul Sweeney’s parliamentary motion last year on free bus travel for people seeking asylum. I trust that, today, they will have the courage of their convictions and will not support the Tories’ reprehensible motion.
As one might expect of a disciple of the discredited Liz Truss—Prime Minister only two years ago, let us not forget—Mr Findlay has no clue about the numbers. To be fair, he has only got so many fingers and toes.
The Tories’ ostrich approach of closing Scotland’s international offices shows that they do not want to attract investment and jobs to Scotland. Those offices strongly contribute to Scotland’s position as the top destination for foreign direct investment out of the UK’s 12 nations and regions outside of London, according to EY’s annual attractiveness survey. The Canada office has supported more than £120 million in planned capital investment, while the office in Washington DC has supported more than 360 companies. The Tories want to put that at risk. Closing the offices seems to me to be more about marginalising the Scottish Parliament than about common sense.
Are the Tories keen on low taxation? If so, why did they vote against this year’s council tax freeze, or deliver the highest UK tax burden since the war? Tory-led Aberdeenshire Council is considering a 17 per cent council tax rise, compared to a rise of 5 per cent for SNP-led North Ayrshire Council and one of 3 per cent for SNP-run Dundee City Council. The Tories demand that Scottish ministers cut income tax to 19 per cent for those earning up to £43,662—a rate lower than they set in any of the 14 years when they formed the UK Government. Of course, doing that would easily cost more than half a billion pounds, based on the 2022-23 Scottish income tax outturn statistics. Where would they find that money?
Old lags will recall when, in 2009, Labour came to the then finance secretary John Swinney with a list of demands that he would have to meet to secure their votes for the budget. After Mr Swinney met their demands in full, Labour reneged on the deal and, when it was first presented, the budget fell. A week later, the budget was re-presented without a single word being changed, and a curmudgeonly Labour Party voted for it to avoid an election in which its defeat looked certain. Such antics take us nowhere.
Since July, with its big brother now in office at Westminster, Scottish Labour has been more cautious. First, it backed the UK’s decision to deprive most of Scotland’s pensioners of their winter fuel payments, before it clumsily reversed gear a few weeks later. We now hear fewer demands for the Scottish child payment to increase to £40 a week, given that the equivalent payment in England and Wales under Labour is precisely zero. It is now less about inputs than it is about outputs for Labour, too. We will see. According to the Scottish Fiscal Commission, resource spending will be only £400 million higher in real terms, and that is before we consider the impact of increases to national insurance contributions.
There are many aspects of last week’s budget that we can and should support, regardless of party affiliation. Spending for the Scottish Police Authority is increasing by 4.5 per cent; housing investment is up by more than 57 per cent to £768 million, which will support the delivery of 8,000 new affordable homes; and the education and skills budget is increasing by 3 per cent over and above inflation. Locally, for me, funding for NHS Ayrshire and Arran is up by a whopping £123.1 million—13.9 per cent—taking it to more than £1 billion. Across Scotland, more than 95 per cent of non-domestic properties will pay less tax than they would anywhere else in the UK, with more than 100,000 properties being taken out of paying rates altogether.
The UK Labour Government’s decision to raise employer national insurance contributions adds £549 million to the cost of delivering Scotland’s public services, while bodies such as independent care homes, charities and universities must find £210 million to meet rising national insurance costs.
While Labour and the Tories play politics, funding for essential services such as healthcare, education and infrastructure is being held hostage. Meanwhile, the SNP Government is backing the people’s priorities: eradicating child poverty, growing the economy, improving public services and tackling the climate emergency.
It is clear that today’s hand-knitted Tory motion is incoherent as well as shameless. By contrast, if the budget passes, it will deliver for Scotland’s communities and businesses by supporting a wide range of services, many of which are not provided elsewhere in the UK, including free prescriptions and free higher education. The Scottish people expect their elected representatives to set our differences aside and deliver on the priorities of people across Scotland. That will happen only by supporting the budget.
15:39