The Conservatives will support the motion lodged by Jamie Hepburn, but we do so with some reluctance. I will explain why.
Although we are not opposing this particular set of budget revisions, we have significant concerns about the practices at play here. There are questions to be asked about Government transparency and about whether the Parliament has been able properly to scrutinise the final details of major in-year budget changes. The Scottish Fiscal Commission, Audit Scotland and independent analysts all agree that greater transparency is needed regarding the Scottish Government’s budget revisions, because significant proportions of the original Scottish budget are being transferred in-year between portfolios.
I understand that some in-year revisions were required because of United Kingdom events such as the general election and the timing of the budget. However, the Scottish Government itself also made many changes, and those shifts, mostly from the health and education budgets, are now being propped up by a quick-fix funding boost at the heart of the Government’s finances.
That practice is problematic for two key reasons. It does not allow for sufficient and accurate parliamentary scrutiny of Government spending and it means that this Government appears to be flying by the seat of its pants in funding our public services. Relying on massive in-year transfers means that the figures presented to Parliament in each year’s budget could be construed as being a façade because they do not represent the actual plans, policies and spending intentions of the principal portfolios.
That can mislead the Parliament and the public about the scale and focus of the Government’s plans and priorities. For example, a portfolio such as health and social care can be promoted as having received a big funding uplift while the Government has every intention of re-routing the funding elsewhere.
In summary, we will support the SSI, but questions remain about transparency, scrutiny and the sustainability of the process by which funding is delivered. We have to question whether it is acceptable to move around such significant proportions of public money using only the vehicle of a statutory instrument. We need such questions to be discussed in a wider debate in the Parliament, and I encourage the Government to engage with that process.
16:30