Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Budget (Scotland) Act 2024 Amendment Regulations 2024 [Draft]

Tuesday 12 November 2024 Finance and Public Administration Committee About 10:30–11:30 Subordinate legislation 227 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

227 contributions · showing 201–227
Ivan McKee SNP Glasgow Provan
link

I have not used the word “lucky”.

John Mason Ind Glasgow Shettleston
link

No, but some of my colleagues have. I think that we are lucky to get rid of the Conservatives, anyway.

I will move on to some more detail. The figure on the council tax freeze has been revised. I think that it was going to be £144 million, and an extra £3 million is going into that. Can you comment on that? Was it uncertain?

Ivan McKee SNP Glasgow Provan
link

Yes, the calculation was done, and that is where the figure ended up. Clearly, there are a lot of variables in there from across all the different councils.

John Mason Ind Glasgow Shettleston
link

Did that involve negotiations rather than being a kind of arithmetic exercise?

Craig Maidment Scottish Government
link

Yes, there were discussions with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities following the initial £144 million figure, and that reflected a roughly 5 per cent increase in council tax across Scotland, so that is where the slight refinement was made in the following months.

John Mason Ind Glasgow Shettleston
link

As I understand it, because changes were made to the £148 million allocated for the winter fuel payment by Westminster in the current year, technically, we could spend it, but we would be borrowing the money and would have to pay it back again. How does that fit into the budget? Will the money be spent this year, or will it be set aside?

Ivan McKee SNP Glasgow Provan
link

I do not know whether we have made a final announcement on our decision on that.

Claire Hughes Scottish Government
link

We have not made a final announcement. In the ABR, we have deducted it from the funding, so we have not reallocated it, but we have not officially notified the Treasury that we are handing it back. There will be a final decision on that in due course.

John Mason Ind Glasgow Shettleston
link

Will that be in the spring budget revision?

Claire Hughes Scottish Government
link

It will definitely be confirmed before the spring budget revision.

Ivan McKee SNP Glasgow Provan
link

We can either hand it back this year, in which case Mr Marra would say, “Why have you not kept it for next year?”, or we can hand it back next year, in which case, Mr Marra would say, “Why did you not spend it this year?” We are still to announce the decision.

John Mason Ind Glasgow Shettleston
link

It is a lose-lose situation from the Government’s point of view.

I will ask about a couple of other issues. Is it the case that the peak fares pilot and the asylum seekers bus fares pilot were not in the budget and that therefore no savings will be made by cancelling those, or have I misunderstood?

Ivan McKee SNP Glasgow Provan
link

Even though it is in the budget, there is still a saving from cancelling it.

Claire Hughes Scottish Government
link

The extension of the pilot scheme was not funded. The funding for the initial pilot was in the budget, but the extension of it was not, and it was decided not to extend the scheme.

John Mason Ind Glasgow Shettleston
link

So, if the scheme had been extended, that would just have added pressure to the budget.

Claire Hughes Scottish Government
link

Yes.

John Mason Ind Glasgow Shettleston
link

My final question is about financial transactions. I realise that some of this will get a bit technical. As I understand it, the financial transactions were dramatically reduced by Westminster and we are not yet certain what the figure for the current year will be. There is a suggestion that there is an overallocation of £25 million, which would have to be covered from the rest of the capital budget. Have I understood that correctly?

Ivan McKee SNP Glasgow Provan
link

Yes. There will be unknowns in there, such as slippage on programmes, and other factors that will need to be taken into account. We will make an assessment when the dust settles and make adjustments.

John Mason Ind Glasgow Shettleston
link

Has the new Government at Westminster eased off on financial transactions? In the past, that budget was quite important for house building.

Claire Hughes Scottish Government
link

We have seen a cut to our financial transactions budget. I do not know whether Craig Maidment has the exact figure.

Craig Maidment Scottish Government
link

The real impact was on the previous financial year. Late in the day, the supplementary estimates that we received confirmed that our funding was going to be reduced to the tune of £63 million. That was beyond what had been indicated, so the UK Government allowed us to defer £53 million, which is why we have effectively started the financial year with quite noticeable pressure. That has been managed down in-year, with roughly half of it being funded through income from the transport FT scheme—I have forgotten the name of it, but it is included in that.

As the minister said, we expect further slippage and possibly some refinement in the final funding figures. If that materialises, we will be able to utilise the capital funding that has been held back at the ABR. If not, we can use the capital funding to offset the overallocation. The UK autumn budget statement did not include any movement on our total FT budget, but it is materially down on what it has been previously. It looks as though £167 million will be the baseline budget but, for the few years prior, it was north of £300 million.

John Mason Ind Glasgow Shettleston
link

The minister said that the capital funding went down and has come back to roughly where we were, but the financial transactions allocation has gone down but not come back up. Is that correct?

Craig Maidment Scottish Government
link

Yes. There had been an assumption that there may not be any FT budget going forward—that would be the direction of travel. The UK Government’s autumn statement indicated that £167 million would be our baseline. That is still significantly lower than it was previously.

John Mason Ind Glasgow Shettleston
link

That was feeding into the housing budget, so the cut is continuing to put pressure on that.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

I thank colleagues for their questions.

Agenda item 2 is formal consideration of the motion on the instrument. I invite the minister to move motion S6M-14800.

Motion moved,

That the Finance and Public Administration Committee recommends that the Budget (Scotland) Act 2024 Amendment Regulations 2024 draft be approved.—Ivan McKee

Motion agreed to.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

I thank the minister and his officials for their evidence. We will publish a short report to the Parliament setting out our decision on the draft instrument in due course.

As that concludes the public part of the meeting, we will move into private session to consider the remaining agenda items.

12:00 Meeting continued in private until 12:15.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.