I am delighted to open the debate as convener of the Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee. I begin by thanking all the committee members, who have approached our work in such a collegiate and informative manner. I thank the clerks who organised all our evidence sessions, and I thank everyone who submitted written evidence, appeared at committee or met us during the inquiry.
We considered how trade in goods between the European Union and the United Kingdom is currently working and, importantly, where there are opportunities to improve the trading relationship. That comes in advance of the forthcoming mandatory review of the implementation of the UK-EU trade and co-operation agreement, which is due in 2026.
The agreement governs the UK’s relationship with the EU post-Brexit and sets out the terms of trade with the EU, which is the UK’s largest trading partner. Trade with the EU and the agreement that governs it is of central importance to the Scottish economy. Let us not forget that the EU accounts for a significant proportion of the export value of our key Scottish produce, from 60 per cent of Scottish salmon exports to 95 per cent of red meat, including Scottish beef, lamb and pork. That is why it is crucial that we understand how better to facilitate trade with our European neighbours. It is also why the committee was pleased to undertake the first parliamentary inquiry in the UK on the impact of the post-Brexit trade agreement on business and trade.
I thank again those who gave evidence, particularly the individual trade bodies, as well as civil society and think tanks, which were all consulted.
We visited two Scottish businesses that are trading with the EU—the haggis and black pudding producer, Macsween of Edinburgh, and the confectionery firm Aldomak. We learned more about the barriers to trade that have arisen post-Brexit and how they might be addressed.
As we discussed the operation of the TCA with academics, businesses and parliamentarians on a visit to Belfast and Dublin, we got rich evidence that helped our inquiry and contributed to our report. The evidence was overwhelmingly that Scottish businesses were experiencing a significant challenge in exporting goods to the EU under the terms of the TCA, with there being considerable non-tariff barriers to trade. Under the TCA, there are zero tariffs and zero quotas on trade in goods between the UK and the EU, but there is no agreement on non-tariff barriers and the TCA does not provide for common regulatory standards for goods.
The National Farmers Union of Scotland said that trade is now
“tariff free and quota free, but it is certainly not friction free.”—[Official Report, Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee, 7 March 2024; c 2.]
As the UK is no longer required to observe EU rules, the respective regulations in the UK and the EU might diverge further over time. That means that customs and regulatory checks are imposed at the EU border, with all imports to the EU market required to meet all EU regulatory standards. However, border checks on goods entering the UK from the EU are still being phased in, following delays post-Brexit. That disparity has created an uneven playing field for UK businesses. We found that non-tariff barriers, including the requirements for full customs and regulatory checks, have placed considerable administrative resource and cost pressures on Scottish businesses, particularly our small and medium-sized enterprises—so crucial to the Scottish economy—as they have no capacity to absorb that additional cost.
The additional burden is not only in complying with customs and regulatory requirements, but in monitoring UK-EU divergence to ensure compliance of goods with changing EU regulations. Increasing regulatory divergence between the UK and the EU presents challenges for businesses in seeking to comply with changing EU regulations. If such divergence intensifies, it will be a barrier to future trade.
The Agricultural Industries Confederation Scotland has said that:
“divergence in regulatory standards between”
the UK
“and the EU ... is causing difficulties for members to trade goods.”
I should have said “GB” there, in fact, as Northern Ireland is not constrained by the terms of the TCA.
We heard from UK in a Changing Europe that there has been a
“slow drip”
of divergence
“that will create new regulatory barriers”.—[Official Report, Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee, 14 March 2024; c 19.]
Those non-tariff barriers to trade have harmed exports, with many businesses withdrawing from the EU market as a result.
The challenges have been particularly acute for our agri-food producers, which are required to meet the EU’s sanitary and phytosanitary measures. There are additional requirements for veterinary inspections, and there is increased risk as a result of the time-sensitive nature of products if goods are delayed during border checks. We heard from Quality Meat Scotland of an incident last year in which £250,000 of Scottish produce was written off as a result of delays with SPS checks at the French border. We also heard from Innovate Foods, which had stopped exporting to the EU since it had goods held up at the border and written off. As I mentioned, that has an impact in particular on the sole traders, sole exporters and smaller businesses—there is a disproportionate impact on our smaller operators.
Let us be clear: all those challenges are a consequence not only of leaving the EU, but of the type of Brexit that the TCA was intended to deliver. In the committee’s view:
“There is now therefore a need for the UK Government to negotiate improvements to the trading relationship to better facilitate UK-EU trade.”
The Labour Government has told us that it wants to “reset” relations with the EU and “tear down” barriers to trade. However, the committee is still waiting for a full response from the UK Government and a meeting with the UK Minister for the Constitution and European Union Relations.
The committee has recently returned from Brussels, where we presented the findings of our report to members of the European Parliament, as well as to the European Commission and the European Council. It was clear that, while the general view from Brussels is that it is open to offers and to negotiation of the TCA, and there is a willingness to consider proposals from the UK Government on how to improve the UK-EU trading relationship further, it is not keen on an opening up of the TCA in full and major renegotiation in this area.