Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Passenger Railway Services (Public Ownership) Bill

Thursday 31 October 2024 Meeting of the Parliament Bill debate 10 contributions · 5 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
Alison Johnstone The Presiding Officer · Lothian
link

The next item of business is consideration of motion S6M-15088, in the name of Fiona Hyslop, which is a legislative consent motion on the Passenger Railway Services (Public Ownership) Bill.

Motion moved,

That the Parliament agrees that all relevant provisions of the Passenger Railway Services (Public Ownership) Bill, introduced in the House of Commons on 18 July 2024, so far as these matters alter the executive competence of the Scottish Ministers, should be considered by the UK Parliament.—[Fiona Hyslop]

16:59

Sue Webber Con Lothian
link

The Passenger Railway Services (Public Ownership) Bill would remove the presumption in favour of franchised passenger railway services being provided by the private sector and would instead allow train operations to be provided by a public sector company when existing franchise contracts end.

Clause 1 would prohibit the Secretary of State for Transport or the Scottish ministers from extending existing rail franchises or entering into new franchise agreements, apart from in specific limited circumstances. It would also remove the presumption in favour of franchised railway passenger services being provided by a private operator. Instead, these will be provided by a public sector company, under a public sector contract.

Clause 2 would place a duty on the relevant franchising authority to provide or secure passenger rail services by giving a direct award to a public sector company. The secretary of state would also have the power to extend existing franchises or to agree new franchises with the same private sector operator as currently operates the service.

Clause 3 would give the secretary of state the regulation-making powers to make consequential amendments, including to primary legislation.

Ultimately, the aim of the bill is to bring all rail franchises into public hands—

Sue Webber Con Lothian
link

—and that is something that my party cannot support.

On 17 July 2024, the shadow transport secretary, Helen Whately, described nationalisation as

“a move that can only be based in ideology”,

and said—[Interruption.]

Sue Webber Con Lothian
link

She said that

“Nationalising well-run operators won’t bring fares down or make services more reliable”.

Furthermore, Rail Partners, which represents the interests of private sector train and freight operators, has argued that

“full nationalisation is a political not a practical solution, which will increase costs over time”.

Ross Greer Green West Scotland
link

Ms Webber seems to be arguing that nationalisation is ideological, and therefore a bad thing. Surely privatisation was the ideological choice that was made in the first place.

Sue Webber Con Lothian
link

My party believes that the bill would have a detrimental effect on Scottish travellers who rely on key cross-border services such as Avanti West Coast. It would also limit competition. Cut-price rail providers such as Lumo, which planned, over the summer, to provide an increased east coast mainline service from Edinburgh Waverley to London King’s Cross, and which also hopes to expand through to the west in Glasgow, could be prevented from providing such a service once the franchise ends.

Finally, and more importantly, the legislation would tie the hands of Scottish ministers and compel them to keep ScotRail and the Caledonian sleeper in public ownership.

17:02

Fiona Hyslop SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Transport · Linlithgow
link

The Scottish Government’s policy aims and objectives are for a fully publicly owned railway to deliver for the people of Scotland and to achieve our vision of a reliable, resilient, affordable and accessible railway. The Passenger Railway Services (Public Ownership) Bill aligns with our policy aims, which is why we support the legislative consent motion and recommend that the Scottish Parliament supports it.

Since ScotRail and the Caledonian sleeper moved into public sector control through operator-of-last-resort arrangements, we have seen continuous improvements as a result. ScotRail has added more than 200 additional services each weekday, offering 7 per cent more seats, and passenger numbers have increased by 75 per cent, from 46.7 million in 2021-22 to around 82 million in 2023-24. On average, ScotRail remains one of the highest-scoring operators in terms of overall passenger satisfaction. It is fully appreciated that the past few months have seen a dip in comparison with the preceding period, which coincided with a reduced service as a result of a temporary timetable.

The changes that the bill will make to the current railways legislation will allow rail passenger services to be delivered by a public sector company as the first-choice option, rather than as a last resort under a franchising model that the Scottish Government has regularly criticised. That will enable current public sector delivery arrangements to be made permanent, providing a stable framework from which we can continue to provide those services.

We are not in favour of returning to the failed Tory franchise system, but any concern that the bill removes the power of any future Scottish Government that may wish to reintroduce the franchise model—a failed model—is incorrect. The Scottish Parliament cannot currently make provision regarding the manner in which rail passenger services are provided; that is a reserved matter, and nothing in the United Kingdom bill will change that. Therefore, it is only through full devolution of rail that any future Scottish Government would truly be able to decide the preferred method of rail service delivery, whether that be publicly or privately operated.

That is one of the reasons why full devolution of rail has been a long-standing objective of Scottish ministers and it is a reason why all members should support that position in consideration of the future UK Great British railways bill. Any future changes to the railways legislation that would impact on devolved powers would also be subject to the convention that the UK Government will not normally legislate with regard to devolved matters without the Scottish Parliament’s consent, which would be sought through a further legislative consent memorandum process, as appropriate.

Therefore, to ensure that we have a publicly owned and publicly run rail system in Scotland, I recommend that the Parliament votes to support the legislative consent motion for the UK Passenger Railway Services (Public Ownership) Bill.

Alison Johnstone The Presiding Officer · Lothian
link

The question on the motion will be put at decision time.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

Votes on these motions that day

  1. General Question Time Questions · 1
  2. Forced Adoption Questions · 6
  3. NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde (Meetings) Questions · 4
  4. Education Funding (Malawi, Rwanda and Zambia) Questions · 4
  5. Disability Equality Plan Questions · 6
  6. Rural Ambulance Provision Questions · 8
  7. Police Scotland (Investigation of Crime) Questions · 4
  8. Gender Questions · 4
  9. First Minister’s Question Time First Minister’s Questions · 1
  10. Tax Increases First Minister’s Questions · 16
  11. United Kingdom Government Budget First Minister’s Questions · 12
  12. Climate and Nature Emergencies (Funding) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  13. United Kingdom Government Budget First Minister’s Questions · 13
  14. Police Scotland (Professor Sam Eljamel) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  15. Sex Crimes First Minister’s Questions · 8
  16. Veterans Services (Funding) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  17. Moss Park Care Home (Proposed Closure) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  18. Flights (Western Isles) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  19. Third Sector Funding (Edinburgh) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  20. Consent Process Handling First Minister’s Questions · 7
  21. District Nurses’ Pay (NHS Tayside) First Minister’s Questions · 3
  22. Point of Order Procedure · 2
  23. Invasive Non-native Species Members’ business · 23
  24. Net Zero and Energy, and Transport Questions · 1
  25. Built Environment (Energy Consumption) Questions · 4
  26. Bus Service Franchising Questions · 9
  27. A96 Dualling (Inverness to Aberdeen) Questions · 8
  28. Renewable Energy Projects (Consultation) Questions · 8
  29. Strategic Transport Projects Review 2 (A77) Questions · 6
  30. Orkney Internal Ferry Fleet Questions · 4
  31. Under-22s Bus Travel (Glasgow) Questions · 4
  32. Housing (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 32
  33. Scotland’s Commissioner Landscape Debate · 107
  34. Passenger Railway Services (Public Ownership) Bill Bill debate · 10
  35. Decision Time Decision time · 20

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.